2 ms·
One of the things that philosophy is actively working on is determining what "right" and "good" actually mean. There are epistemic/analytic senses ("the answer
by woodruffw 8y ago
One of the things that philosophy is actively working on is determining what "right" and "good" actually mean. There are epistemic/analytic senses ("the answer on the test was right", "all bachelors are unmarried"), practical senses ("it's good to run"), normative senses ("you ought to run"), and so on. A great deal of contemporary philosophy is invested in further delineating these senses and explaining how they relate to our ontology, our metaethical views, etc.
I've heard more than one person say, too, that philosophy progresses by creating new subjects. When you consider that pretty much all of logic, political thought, and biology come from the tradition started by Aristotle, that claim sounds reasonable.
- avip 8y agoEncouraging. And how is that going so far? If I meet a fellow Philosopher now, can I prove him wrong in a way he'll accept?
- woodruffw 8y agoIt depends on what you mean by that. If someone presents a view that is inconsistent with the accepted facts, then you you can "prove them wrong" in that sense. But that's not really the point of philosophical inquiry -- the point is to flesh out each view entirely, and look for the best possible explanation of the subject. Those kind of explanations don't always (or even usually) come from outright rebuttals -- they come from synthesis, refinement of the situations considered, improvements in clarity, etc.