4 ms·
Question of free will as a fundamental philosophical question is settled in a sense that it made only sense together with dualism and soul (there are still peop
by nabla9 8y ago
Question of free will as a fundamental philosophical question is settled in a sense that it made only sense together with dualism and soul (there are still people who are dualists and believe in individual entity called soul. For them the question remains).
Albert Einstein:
>I do not believe we can have any freedom at all in the philosophical
sense, for we act not only under external compulsion but also by inner
necessity. Schopenhauer’s saying— “A man can surely do what he wills
to do, but he cannot determine what he wills”—impressed itself upon me
in youth and has always consoled me when I have witnessed or suffered
life’s hardships. This conviction is a perpetual breeder of tolerance,
for it does not allow us to take ourselves or others too seriously; it
makes rather for a sense of humor.
Modern version of free will has degenerated into question of deterministic vs randomness and few other more vague branches. If human makes random decision, he is making random decision not free decision. Calling it "free will" is just a way to make the question sound more important.
- foldr 8y ago>Question of free will as a fundamental philosophical question is settled in a sense that it made only sense together with dualism and soul It might be settled from your own point of view, but it's certainly a matter of current philosophical controversy whether physicalism entails the absence of free will.
- nabla9 8y agoThe modern question of free is very different from the "the will does not have to be such as it is". Remaining issues in physicalism and free will requires a radical revision of the term. It's like asking something completely different.
- foldr 8y agoNo, whether or not free will in the classical sense exists is still debated, even among physicalists.
- nabla9 8y agoSources and not just fringe sources please.
- foldr 8y agohttps://plato.stanford.edu/entries/freewill/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/freewill/
- mannykannot 8y agoFree will is arguably the hard problem for physicalists who feel that they have it.
- visarga 8y agoThe concept is a bag of very different meanings. Define "free will" as acting mostly based on internal reasons and we all have it. And this is the meaning of the word for the masses. Define "free will" as a kind of supremacy of human will over physical determinism and nobody has it.
- foldr 8y agoI don't think anyone has ever defined free will as a supremacy of human will over physical determinism.
- goatlover 8y agoYou're skipping over the question of whether some version of free will worth it's name can be compatible with determinism. Dennett wrote a book on it. Also, there is the question of what role our conscious choice makes in decision making. Some people have suggested that our consciousness is just along for the ride, instead of being in the driver's seat. But that interpretation is controversial.
- nabla9 8y agoYes. These are the branches of the original question. But they are not center issues in the philosophy. They are not burning questions of utmost importance as the question of fundamental freedom of will once was.
- sdhgaiojfsa 8y ago> Dennett wrote a book on it. Lots of people have written books about lots of things. That doesn't always mean those things are worth studying or thinking about. Witness the vast plethora of literature about minute points in Christian/Muslim/etc. theology. You could fill libraries with the books that have written about these subjects, none of which have any real basis in reality.
- danbruc 8y agoModern version of free will has degenerated into question of deterministic vs randomness and few other more vague branches. I don't think that is accurate, I think the more important aspect is [still] the definition of free will. It was rather surprising to me that at least some and maybe most people mean something entirely different when they use the term free will then what I thought free will should obviously mean. I always thought it should obviously mean that in given situation one has several possible actions and one can make a free choice among them but it turns out that is not what some or even most people mean or are interested in when talking about free will.
- nabla9 8y agoIn any case the classical definition of free will has been solved. The question of free will in voluntary action implicitly was important in the context of soul and dualism. Any action that originated "inside self" could be done at least in principle without outside influence, "the will does not have to be such as it is". There was at least possibility of fundamental free will. If there is no fundamental system boundary, the question of free will is defining less fundamental boundaries and the question loses its status as fundamentally important question. Generating new definitions for free will can of course continue.
- danbruc 8y agoIn any case the classical definition of free will has been solved. What is the classical definition and how has it been solved, in case it is not obvious from the definition? Or, in case it takes to much text to answer that, who proposed the classical definition or who wrote a good book on it? I did not put a huge amount of effort into this topic but at least quite a bit, but I am still puzzled what a common, the most common, or a classical understanding of free will is.
- nabla9 8y agoThe Aristotle's definition and others like it. For Aristotle there was three causes for things: chance, necessity, chance, a third thing (the agent-causality) or "up to us". In the Nicomachean Ethics virtue and vice are "up to us". We have desires and we deliberate and make voluntary choice. What is left unsaid because it was self evident at the time was that there was something called soul or person separate from the environment. In the modern sense "up to us" is not same level ultimate origination concept as change and necessity.