4 ms·
> I now need to go to a bank, and then to a shop Hmmm...if you go to a bank to withdraw cash every tine you go to a shop I could see your point, but I would su
by mpweiher 8y ago
> I now need to go to a bank, and then to a shop
Hmmm...if you go to a bank to withdraw cash every tine you go to a shop I could see your point, but I would suggest that "you're holding it wrong".
> I have to carry a lot of little bits of valuable paper around with me
Which are limited in terms of risk, whereas a card can withdraw...whatever your limit. Carrying the bits of paper (and coins) has the big benefit of being tangible, that is we get to use all our senses to understand something otherwise very abstract.
> when I pay I have to wait [..]
Err...sorry, cash transactions are invariably much quicker than card transactions around here.
> I get no protections such as insurance
You mean you don't have ridiculous services bundled together for no reason whatsoever.
> I can't how understand how anyone can argue cash is more convenient!
And I can't understand how anyone can argue that cards are more convenient, when they clearly are not.
>And how can you possibly argue cash is faster? Paying by card takes 0.5 seconds -
Where? Around here, card transactions always take longer.
> arcane things like inserting your card, paper printouts, signing with a pen [..] decade or more.
Actually, having to sign on EC payments has become a thing recently, it used to be exclusively PIN. And sometimes it's PIN, sometimes it's signature, in the same shop, with the same card. They payment processor seems to choose by some randomized algorithm.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBut going to N shops is more convenient than going to N shops + 1 bank isn't it? I mean it is literally strictly less places to visit. > whereas a card can withdraw...whatever your limit That's not my liability - it's the card company's. As long as I'm not negligent, like giving someone my PIN, I am not liable for someone stealing my card and using it. I don't lose anything. I'm strictly liable for less value with card than cash. > Where? Around here, card transactions always take longer. How does it manage to take longer? Don't you have contactless in Germany? If you don't, then that's the problem - not the cards themselves. The last point seems debatable given Germany's backward card infrastructure, but for liability and number of places I have to visit, it just seems a mathematical fact that cards are more convenient.
- mpweiher 8y ago> N shops + 1 bank Only by 1/N. And since there are ATMs near my shops and it's mostly about trips, not about # of shops, it's both negligible and certainly well worth it for the benefits. And if that epsilon of effort is too much for you, you can get cash-back at most grocery shops, though the amount will typically be smaller, one reason I prefer the bank ATM. > That's not my liability - it's the card company's Not around here it ain't. And of course if the card company "takes on" the liability, it just redistributes it to its customers. So you are paying for it. > Don't you have contactless in Germany? Rarely if at all. Also I don't see how contactless (you just swipe? No PIN?) manages security. So: tangibility, security and data protection are clear benefits. Convenience as well around here, and can only be improved by making the entire thing less secure.
- chrisseaton 8y agoIt sounds like Germany has a self-imposed chicken and egg problem - you don't think cards are better, so you don't implement modern cards, but card aren't better because you haven't implemented modern cards. We had a card-provider sponsored big-bang on contactless payments years ago in the UK and it's been an epiphany. Life is so much better cashless.
- mpweiher 8y ago> you don't think cards are better No, for us, the value proposition is just not there. The benefits are at best highly marginal and the disadvantages profound, if less visible. > card-provider sponsored big-bang Hmmm...and they did this out of the goodness of their hearts? Cards were introduced in order to get you to spend more, in particular money you don't have, which is why it started with credit cards. Making a payment by card is essentially the same, whether it's € 1 or € 100, or even € 1000. With cash, there's a bit of a pause as you count out the bills. And you notice it much more when prices go up. etc. And of course the whole brouhaha about anonymous digital currencies. Huh? More technology to fix problems with technology? How about we use this really old technology that already has all these benefits.
- spinningarrow 8y agoWhere is "here"? I agree with your parent, in places that support Apple Pay/Android Pay/PayWave/contactless payments (e.g. Singapore, the UK, and surely more that I don't know), cashless is easily more convenient. In places that don't have contactless payments, cashless may be less convenient but contactless is probably on its way there so your argument seems like a bit of a straw man. At any rate, I'm sure it can be agreed that contactless cashless payments are more convenient that cash ones.
- ianhowson 8y ago> whereas a card can withdraw...whatever your limit Cards also have a dispute process. > much quicker than card transactions around here That's because German vendors are hopeless at processing cards. Australia/HK/Singapore/China/most of Europe: the reader prompts you with the sale amount. You tap your card. It adds zero time to the transaction. Germany: the vendor asks to hold the card. They insert the card. They ask the terminal to do a credit transaction. They give the reader back to you for the PIN. You hand it back. They ask for your ID because you're a foreigner. Blah blah blah. > having to sign on EC payments has become a thing recently So you're actively going backwards, then? I'm also going to point out three other annoyances with the German banking system: - Cash machines are rare (kilometres apart) - To avoid fees, you have to use machines in your network - The fees on out-of-network withdrawals are huge (3-5 EUR, but apparently unrestricted; I paid 10 EUR for a temporary ATM at an event once). So you carry a lot of cash.
- mpweiher 8y ago> So you carry a lot of cash. Define "a lot". But yes, I usually have a week or two supply. Why on earth would I not? > You tap your card. As asked elsewhere: how is this secure?
- chrisseaton 8y ago> As asked elsewhere: how is this secure? It's more secure than your two weeks' worth of untraceable cash that you're lumping around everywhere. If you lose your card you cancel it. I can do this on my phone in 30s flat when I notice it's gone. Things bought in the mean time are covered by the card provider, and they prosecute the criminal to get the money back. If you lose your two weeks' supply of cash what do you do?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 8y ago> more secure than your two weeks' supply of cash Nope. If my cash is gone, that's all that's gone. With a card, you can do a lot more damage. Cash also doesn't get denied for random/unpredictable reasons when you are abroad. > 30s flat when I notice it's gone. Coordinated gangs will clear out your bank accounts faster than that. If I lose my cash, that's it. I don't have to cancel anything, I don't have to reapply for anything. I can borrow cash, or loan out some cash. Easy peasy. Contactless is a solution looking for a problem.
- bchallenor 8y agoI am visiting Berlin at the moment, and I miss the convenience and speed of being able to pay with contactless, by card or phone. Regarding the speed of transactions: cash might be faster than signature or even Chip+PIN, but is surely not faster than contactless. For example, anyone with a contactless Visa/Mastercard or phone can enter the London Underground by simply tapping at the barrier. They do not need to have a pre-existing relationship with Transport for London, to buy a ticket in advance, or to preload a stored-value card (as you generally must do in other city transport networks). And the ticket barriers open on average in 480ms. [1] That's pretty fast. You can't even pay by cash on a bus in London any more. [1] https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/payment_methods_time_taken_by_pa https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/payment_methods_time_...
- mpweiher 8y ago> anyone with a contactless Visa/Mastercard or phone can enter the London Underground by simply tapping at the barrier In Berlin, there is no barrier.
- bchallenor 8y agoMy example was to give quantitative evidence for the speed of contactless transactions. It is true that there is no barrier in Berlin, but you still need to buy a ticket. For casual users such as myself, who don't have a season ticket, this takes significantly longer than 480ms: find ticket machine, queue, navigate menu, insert cash, wait for change and ticket to be printed, find ticket validation machine. It is quite possible to miss the train here by having to queue to buy a ticket, particularly in busy places like the airport. This could be avoided if the tourists were able to use their existing cards/phones to tap in.
- newman8r 8y ago> Carrying the bits of paper (and coins) has the big benefit of being tangible, that is we get to use all our senses to understand something otherwise very abstract. This is a much bigger deal than a lot of people will admit. It's a lot easier to waste your money without a second thought when you're using a card. It's similar to chips in vegas - you're much quicker to gamble the chips than you would have been with cash. It's not as big of a deal if you're really responsible financially, but if you're the kind of person who binge-shops amazon then going cash-only for a few months might be an eye-opening experience.