4 ms·
1. is pretty much the basic idea behind Do not track headers. Acceptance of it among websites is... low, and given the history around it its probably not legall
by detaro 9y ago
1. is pretty much the basic idea behind Do not track headers. Acceptance of it among websites is... low, and given the history around it its probably not legally viable to treat DNT: 0 as "I consent to tracking", since there's no clear standard what exactly it'd be consent for, and no clear way to be sure that the user has seen enough details about it. (DNT: 1 as "I do not consent" wouldn't be a problem, but why respect that if you can annoy the user with a popup and try to get consent anyways?)
But your 2 examples only cover a tiny sliver of what GDPR covers, so no, it wouldn't make sense for the regulation to be replaced by proposals like this.
Nothing stopping the tech industry to develop standardized mechanisms to communicate privacy rules though, and use them where appropriate. I haven't seen much in the way of proposals for this though, I suspect because a fair implementation of that would have the same issue the advertising industry had with DNT: don't make it to easy for users to not consent, that's bad for profits.
- Guest9812398 9y agoWhy not force publishers to respect the do not track headers, and clarify what it means to not be tracked? I'm not asking for GDPR to be replaced, and I understand it covers a much wider range of issues. However, I want to say that analytics, advertising and cookies are the ones that most affect users, and are the ones that will be causing the popups everywhere online. I feel this process should be simplified, users shouldn't need to update these settings with every website they visit, and we shouldn't trust publishers to be the ones asking for consent, since they have a high interest in misleading users and finding creative ways to obtain consent, which we can already see happening. As for your last point, there are standards being implemented related to obtaining and communicating consent (http://advertisingconsent.eu http://advertisingconsent.eu). However, these standards are being set by the ad networks, and as you would expect, they are looking out for their best interest and bottom line.