5 ms·
So EU citizens will either revolt and destroy EU or read their news from somewhere else? More likely, will do the usual thing people do for geo-locked content:
by mrtksn 8y ago
So EU citizens will either revolt and destroy EU or read their news from somewhere else? More likely, will do the usual thing people do for geo-locked content: Use proxy or pirate until a convenient solution takes off. That convenient solution will be GDPR compliance by the offender or a competitor.
I mean, mild annoyance is nothing compared to the annoyance of war thorn continent, I wouldn't bet too much on the destruction of EU or even withdrawal of GDPR
- kodablah 8y ago> So EU citizens will either revolt and destroy EU or read their news from somewhere else? Those are the only two options? Now that I know that, instead of what a practical person might deem as an option which is to repeal the law, the EU and GDPR proponents' mindsets make a lot more sense. I often wondered why new legislation was piled on older legislation that wasn't even enforced then, and why other statues wrt cookies and what not cannot be seen by legislators as more bad than good and worth removing. Now I know.
- mrtksn 8y agoMy next sentence is literally a third option, describing what happens with geo-blocked content.
- kodablah 8y agoAnd that it isn't even an option to recognize a bad law and repeal it, even if it had good intentions, speaks volumes.
- mrtksn 8y agoAs an EU citizen, I don't think the law is bad but you are free to be upset about it, of course. Please respect our laws and privacy or don't do business with us. We will be very sorry if your product is irreplaceable or we will use a competing product that complies with GDPR.
- kodablah 8y agoI didn't say the law was bad, I was saying if it turns out to be, repealing it should be an option. Too often there is no going back from these things because it's not considered an option. Instead only options like revolt, go elsewhere or use a VPN are presented. Obviously the last incarnation of the GDPR didn't work for multiple reasons, the most oft-cited one being non-enforcement. Was the option to repeal and take other approaches to the problem considered? Nope...double down. Since people agree with the intent, the approach often appears above reproach.
- mrtksn 8y agoOf course, it is an option, the problem is that you claim not to be and you claim that "the EU and GDPR proponents' mindsets make a lot more sense" because I asked a question to emphasize the "test" on the EU citizens. I see you're in Texas. Don't worry too much about EU, we are doing fine. We will figure this thing out if it turns out to be more bad than good.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoPlease respect our laws and privacy or don't do business with us. Stop sending us your data and money? I don’t leave the US to deal with EU customers. You send requests to my server in the US. If you’re unhappy with me, stop doing that. And it’s pretty rich to complain about companies not complying and leaving the market, while also using VPNs to use their service anyway. Apparently protecting your data isn’t as important as you say?
- mrtksn 8y agoI haven't been given an option not to make calls to your servers, those websites used to load 20 tracking scripts without asking me. Thanks to the GDPR now I will be able to stop sending requests. What's the problem? See, how browsers work is that they load this thing called HTML that describes the content and can load other stuff without asking me. Apologies if I accidentally sent any data or money, it wasn't my call. It was in the HTML that I loaded because I was offered to view a free article.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]