8 ms·
Yeah and it's obnoxious as hell. When I moved to Munich from the bay area, suddenly having to actively manage cash and coins on a daily basis felt like I'd step
by TulliusCicero 8y ago
Yeah and it's obnoxious as hell. When I moved to Munich from the bay area, suddenly having to actively manage cash and coins on a daily basis felt like I'd stepped through a portal to a few decades ago. So many places being cash-only is very much "WHAT YEAR IS IT??"
Some Germans defend it as "well Germans just prefer their privacy" but they still sign up for loyalty card programs and they are adopting cards for payment, just very slowly for how otherwise-developed they are. This isn't really a stance borne out of principled concerns, it comes from a general skepticism/paranoia of consumer technology/innovations.
I see the same thing with how many German institutions still rely on mailing physical letters whereas the equivalent American ones switched to emails a decade+ ago. For example, the Grundschule my son will start at next year needed to tell us about an appointment. Did they use an email, perhaps one they gathered from an earlier appointment we'd had there? Of course not, they mailed a letter, a letter that didn't come until the day of the appointment, which they then berated my wife on the phone for missing.
Other examples: to create an online account for my health insurance provider, they sent me a code to confirm the account...using an actual letter for the code. Same deal for recharging an Aldi-Talk SIM, you need to have them mail a letter to your address, and then and only then may you pay (via bank transfer). And the websites I've looked at for the Grundschulen (elementary schools) look like they were made by a high schooler in 2006, whereas when I look at ones for school districts for my nephews and nieces in the states, they actually appear reasonably modern. Or when I got photos from people in my son's kindergarten, only one person did sending them over a photo/file-sharing service, the others were a flash drive, a CD, many emails with one or more photos attached, and also someone just handing me their whole camera.
tl;dr Germany is surprisingly backwards when it comes to consumer technology
- CaptainZapp 8y ago"Yeah and it's obnoxious as hell. When I moved to Munich from the bay area, suddenly having to actively manage cash and coins on a daily basis felt like I'd stepped through a portal to a few decades ago. So many places being cash-only is very much "WHAT YEAR IS IT??" " We wonder the same thing about US credit cards, that just now switched to Chip & Signature It's not exactly a new concept, considering that the first smart cards for banking purposes were issued in France in 1986[1] Those that sit in glass houses... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMV https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMV
- TulliusCicero 8y ago> We wonder the same thing about US credit cards, that just now switched to Chip & Signature Absolutely the US is backwards in some ways when it comes to tech (bank transfers are another point where Germany is much better). Germany is just more backwards overall. That Germany has no major internationally successful consumer tech companies became a lot more understandable once I moved here, the country is designed for stability over innovation. The other thing I noticed is that Germans are much more prickly/defensive than Americans when it comes to criticism. Liberal Americans, at least, will eagerly nod their heads and agree when someone foreign points out how dumb it is that college and healthcare are absurdly expensive in the US, or other American problems like too many guns, too little public transit, etc. But any equivalent criticism seems to have even left-leaning Germans circling the wagons.
- craigsmansion 8y ago> That Germany has no major internationally successful consumer tech companies ... What?! > more defensive [..] when it comes to criticism Maybe it's the special air of ignorance combined with assumed superiority that sets them off, eager nodding not-withstanding.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago> ... > What?! Well, do you have any examples? Anything like Amazon, Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Apple, Uber, Airbnb, Dropbox, etc.? Because I'm looking at this list(1) and not seeing anything on that level, or even very close to it really. Or look at the Fortune Global 500, no German tech companies there, only car or manufacturing companies. > Maybe it's the special air of ignorance What ignorance? Nothing I've said is wrong, shit my one friend I had in Munich before moving here said more or less the same thing to me before I had even come to this conclusion (granted, he works at Amazon). > combined with assumed superiority that sets them off, eager nodding not-withstanding. That's just your own sensitivities at play. If I thought the US was flatly superior to Germany, I wouldn't have moved to the latter. I could go on and on about areas where Germany is clearly superior to the US -- land use, transportation, social safety nets, egalitarian policies, etc. -- but none of those are the topic of this thread. Perhaps you should be asking yourself why you responded to accurate criticism by lashing out. Again, I've seen plenty of threads on, say, healthcare, where Europeans will comment on how outrageous and stupid the US system is, and Americans will upvote their comments and reply with how much they agree. When particular European countries are singled out though, and particularly some of them like Germany, you don't see the same behavior. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Technology_companies_of_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Technology_companies_...
- sveme 8y agoHealth insurance -> physical letter: security. Kindergarten photos: wouldn‘t want pictures of my kids to end up on the web either, maybe slight, but I guess justified paranoia. AldiTalk: anonymous phones have been illegalized by law a couple of years back. Maybe that? But you could always just recharge via SMS or the web? Don‘t understand that particular point.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago> Kindergarten photos: wouldn‘t want pictures of my kids to end up on the web either, maybe slight, but I guess justified paranoia. I mean, using a file-sharing service (which one person did) isn't really different from emailing them to me. It's just more convenient/advanced. > But you could always just recharge via SMS or the web? Don‘t understand that particular point. At least when I was using it, no. You had to get a letter first to setup a bank transfer method of payment, then you could pay online using the web or app. Otherwise you had to actually go to an Aldi. My wife still does this because she's still on Alditalk and hasn't bothered to get the letter.
- sveme 8y agoRegarding emails: if you‘re using gmail, there‘s obviously no point in using emails instead of using google drive. If you used emails associated with web hosting, there‘s a difference.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoI really don't see the difference. If you don't blast the file-sharing link to everybody and their brother, it's the same as emailing the pictures to someone. Either way you're just trusting that the person you're sending the pictures to isn't an asshole.
- wolfgke 8y ago> I mean, using a file-sharing service (which one person did) isn't really different from emailing them to me. It's just more convenient/advanced. You should also avoid mailing them around. Better rent some personal webspace/server (rule of thumb: if you do not pay for it, you are not the customer, but the product), put it there and create for everybody who should have access to the data a private account. EDIT: If you must mail the data around, encrypt it beforehand.
- darklajid 8y agoIf I send you an email for my healthcare service and you click on a link in it, you confirmed your (free? most likely?) email address. If I send you a letter for the same service and you enter the code within, you confirmed your address. Different things and the former is usually considered useless, the latter interesting to the other party. I'm a German, now living in Singapore. I used as much cash in DE as in SG: Only where needed and somewhat rarely. In DE it's usually a small shop (kiosk), local public transportation (sometimes) or events. In SG it's food courts/hawker places and events. Everywhere else cards work, Singapore or Germany (or Israel for what it's worth) work the same in my experience.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoWell, I'm in Munich and have to use cash all the time. Lots of restaurants and little shops like kiosks/bakeries seem to be cash-only. And a lot of places that take "cards" only take, like Germany-specific debit cards (or maybe Europe-specific? Not certain). In comparison, in the bay area, and to a slightly lesser extent in other parts of the US I lived in, even little kiosks or food trucks, hell even farmer's market stands almost always take credit cards. I had to use cash in the US maybe once or twice a month on average. And again, it's not a "well they only do this in cases where privacy is actually really important (like healthcare"), because why does Alditalk care so much when the purpose of the address verification is solely for putting more money onto the account? Are they worried a random stranger is going to give me money?
- darklajid 8y agoRestaurants surprise me. Small shops I know and that can be annoying. Bavaria is kinda backwards even in my mind and a traditional family run bakery might be cash only, "Backwerk" etc. accept cards I think. The _kind_ of cards doesn't matter for the article, I think. Cashless is cashless, debit card or credit card? Credit card adoption is a different problem (they aren't popular) and only recently rose quite a bit. You can pay at McD or Aldi with Visa Paywave / Google Pay. The whole contactless method seems to be a motivator for CC adoption afaict. If you complain that a CC is not accepted then get a local debit card :-) No idea about address verification just for top ups. For me it was paying for a voucher, call a number, enter code, done - but I haven't been on prepaid for a long time.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoGermans keep wanting to say that it's not that Germany sucks at consumer technology, but that Germany is more privacy-aware or more principled or something like that. But if that's true, where are the major German tech companies that simply follow those values? They don't exist. Look at the Fortune Global 500: the US has tech companies for days on there, Germany only has car or manufacturing companies. Because Germany just isn't very good at consumer-facing software and services. The whole culture is minimum moderately skeptical of innovation in that area.
- dang 8y ago> "obnoxious as hell" "surprisingly backwards" Could you please not post this sort of flamebait? HN is a highly international community. People need not to make snarky generalizations about each other, and it isn't necessary to make a substantive point.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoI'm not sure I follow which parts are flamebait. Is it the generalization, or the slang-y/blunt way I phrased it? Because people make similar generalizations here, well, all the time, and I feel the generalization itself was both accurate and relevant. If I described public transit in the US as an "absolute disaster" I doubt anyone would blink an eye; it's blunt, but also accurate. I don't feel it's wrong or messed up to criticize a particular part of a country's culture or policies, as no nation is perfect. I could definitely reword "obnoxious as hell" to just something like "really obnoxious/annoying", but I don't feel "surprisingly backwards" is actually flamebait: it's strong language that might irk some people, but it's also my earnest opinion; I was trying to express how it actually felt for me as an immigrant, not trying to piss people off. And I wasn't applying it to Germany as a whole, but a particular area. I'm not trying to troll you here, I'm trying to see where exactly you draw the line with strong language/what exactly was objectionable so that I understand what's considered acceptable.