4 ms·
If design is so irrelevant to profits, how come Apple’s phones capture almost all of the profits in the mobile industry? Surely if your company has at great exp
by simonh 8y ago
If design is so irrelevant to profits, how come Apple’s phones capture almost all of the profits in the mobile industry? Surely if your company has at great expense developed a legally protected advantage in the market that gains you the majority of the profit share, someone else copying your legally protected advantage and churning out products using all the same design features you spent years on must be pretty sickening?
Especially when it turns out your rival produced a 132 page design analysis detailing exactly how to copy your product design and UI, with photos, comparing it to their product and specifying “directions for improvement”[1]. Not all 132 pages are about rounded corners.
[1]https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2012/8/8/3227289/samsung-apple-ux-ui-interface-improvement https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp...
- vidarh 8y agoI don't think design is irrelevant to profits, but I also think tying it to Apple's position as the most profitable mobile manufacturer is weak. While Apple has competition, it is at the same time in a position where it's competition can't sell iOS phones. That gives it a substantial buffer against price pressure that none of the Android manufacturers face. If you're agnostic to the OS, then, yes, Apple needs to convince you to buy theirs. But if you've decided on a platform - and design may certainly be part of that -, Apple has no competition, while every Android manufacturer is competing in an environment where people aren't only competing with unique devices but where they're also facing clones of clones of clones (e.g. my current Android phone is a Vernee Mix 2; Google recognises it as a Xiaomi Mix 2... there's at least half a dozen Mix 2 "clones" on the market, copying anything from just the exterior case to being near perfect copies including copying aspects of Xiaomi's UI) So Apple has a much more sheltered position, especially as users get entrenched with large investments in apps and the overall ecosystem. Most of the Android competitors are competing in price segments Apple are uninterested in, but for most Android manufacturers at any price point has to deal with competitors selling phones that look and feel almost as theirs but costs 10% or 20% or 30% less - close enough to have near feature parity and attract the same customer segments -, which affects their margins substantially. Couple that with Apple's logistics and manufacturing and integration and it's not surprising that Apple is so much more profitable.
- simonh 8y ago> ...it is at the same time in a position where it's competition can't sell iOS phones. That gives it a substantial buffer against price pressure that none of the Android manufacturers face. Alright, but what is it about iOS that makes it an advantage, if it isn't it's design? The design isn't just what it looks like, it's how it works. Have a look at that 132 page document, the article I linked has screenshots from it. It's a manual for how they duplicated iOS functionality. Do you really think that's acceptable? As for logistics and manufacturing integration, Apple don't even make their own phones. They're made by the same contractors everyone else's phones are made by. Samsung is primarily a hardware manufacturer. How incompetent do they have to be for Apple to have that as a primary advantage for decades?
- vidarh 8y ago> Do you really think that's acceptable? For the most part, yes, I do. Most of it is not in any way anything that can be legally protected. Some of it may be, but suggesting that all of that 132 page document is somehow an indictment of Samsung is misleading. They may have stepped over the line, but analysing how to adopt the best part of what a competitor does is part and parcel of competition. But to your main question: In addition to the design: Brand, integration with the rest of the Apple ecosystem, investment in apps. To put it another way: If it was only design, you can buy <$100 Android phones from China that are skinned to look at act like iOS, in shells that look like iPhones, at least you could the last time I checked (cheapest I've seen at AliExpress was $15). If it was only design there'd be far more than them, and they'd actually sell at decent volumes. But they don't, because they don't give people the other things they want. > As for logistics and manufacturing integration, Apple don't even make their own phones. I don't know what you think that suggests, but what it actually means is that Apple as part of their effort of streamlining their supply chain has largely outsourced the risks on the manufacturing side while they still place a massive amount of demands on their manufacturers that they're able to thanks to their volume. Tim Cook's rise in Apple was largely down to closing down internal manufacturing and instead dictating terms to contract manufacturers that virtually removed Apple's inventory, and doing things that other people thought were crazy, like starting to ship electronics by air, betting it'd pay for itself by letting them not have e.g. weeks worth of inventory on ships and being able to respond to demand changes much faster (and hence needing to place orders much later). Apple's shift to using contract manufacturing was part and parcel of the company more tightly integrating their entire supply chain and shortening it drastically, by entering long term contracts with companies close to e.g. their component sources. > How incompetent do they have to be for Apple to have that as a primary advantage for decades? Not at all. They had $50bn worth of operating income in 2017 from Samsung Electronics compared to $61bn for Apple. Their Android business is low margin because it is extremely competitive. Their contract manufacturing and other product lines are generally much more profitable.
- tooltalk 8y agoI always thought benchmarking your competitors' products was fairly common -- how else do you think Apple came up with phablets and stylus, after denouncing it and declaring that nobody would buy something that big?