6 ms·
This is the kind of empathy that I think lots of people fail to have when it comes to sites with user-generated content. As another example, lots of people seem
by sanderjd 8y ago
This is the kind of empathy that I think lots of people fail to have when it comes to sites with user-generated content. As another example, lots of people seem to think Facebook is negligent for failing to properly delineate between fake and real news articles or between organic political speech and propaganda. Purely from an engineering perspective, I just don't see how they could possibly do even an adequate, let alone a good job of that.
- borplk 8y agoIt's only recently that people have started to assign blame and responsibility to the platform hosting the content (really only after the US election drama). Back in the earlier days of the internet the attitude was quite different. It was all celebrated free speech and "anyone is empowered to do anything it's all open and free and happy for everybody and there's some bad stuff so what" (happy early Web 2.0 days where the web was moving from static pages to "textboxes and submit buttons"). Now a pin drops and 50 publications write an "Facebook negligently allowed someone to ... they must be held accountable and regulated and broken apart" article. It's just a mindless pendulum swing. Those of us in the middle always get the shit. Back in the day we got blamed for saying anything against the "open and free and rainbows for all humanity" rhetoric and now it's gone to the other side.
- aylmao 8y ago> Now a pin drops and 50 publications write an "Facebook negligently allowed someone to ... they must be held accountable and regulated and broken apart" article. I think part of it is this; those "50 publications" --the media-- is paying attention now, and they judge the internet like a media publication and not a forum. There's debate of course; does the sorting of the newsfeed equate editorial curation? Does this make Facebook a media company vs a communications platform? I do think that a lot of the outcry I've been hearing against these open communication mediums have come from old media more so than from the average person.
- gnarbarian 8y ago> does the sorting of the newsfeed equate editorial curation? there are quite a few independent YouTube news channels I trust far more for showing me the truth than any giant network with vested interests. two examples: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJdKr0Bgd_5saZYqLCa9mng https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJdKr0Bgd_5saZYqLCa9mng https://www.youtube.com/user/Timcasts https://www.youtube.com/user/Timcasts
- forgottenpass 8y ago>I think part of it is this; those "50 publications" --the media-- is paying attention now, and they judge the internet like a media publication and not a forum. The funny thing is, those internet companies had a chance to show the media they're not be seen as publications. But the platforms didn't. They wanted an out that let them exercise power over content at the discretion of the people in control of the platform. It's the cost-benefit tradeoff they signed up for. And now other entities are exercising their soft power over the platform to get them to exercise power over the content on the platform.
- makomk 8y agoThey're definitely not judging the internet like a media publication; for the most part, they're quite happy to defend almost anything their fellow publications do. They're treating it like a dangerous new threat that's not part of their clique and is eating directly into their profit margins. Compare, for example, how they cover Google and Facebook's compliance with the GDPR and abuse of personal data with how they cover publications doing the same. For instance Fortune and Forbes are doing some heiniously noncompliant stuff in order to ensure they can use people's personal info for profit, but this doesn't seem to be getting any coverage. In order to view this very article, you must go through a forced-consent wall of the very kind the GDPR forbids.
- bluntfang 8y ago>It's only recently that people have started to assign blame and responsibility to the platform hosting the content (really only after the US election drama). Pretty certain 4chan would have been shut down and held responsible if they did not cooperate with the FBI in reporting and moderating cheese pizza a long time ago (at least 2010).
- deanCommie 8y agoFacebook used to have a feature where when you wrote a comment to a news article, it would give you suggestions of 3 "suggested" response links that you could post in response. 99% of the time when I started writing a response to a news story I knew to be false, the top recommended link was a Snopes article debunking the story. I could just click on that, and be done with it. So they already had an engineering fix for this problem, and it worked GREAT. Why did they take it out? Probably because the metrics showed that stuff like this killed conversations, and the virality of people reposting stories. Nobody is going to Share a news post when one of the top comments is a big Snopes "FALSE" preview. Some engagement metrics went down and they took it away.
- pentae 8y agoWell from an engineering perspective you could create a blacklist and a whitelist. There's not a huge amount of variance in news sources out there, i'd say 80% of news sources being shared on social media are less than 100 domains. The rest of the fake news sites domains could be added to the blacklist based on a combination of user reporting and moderation. You could literally put a team of about 5 people on this and over a long enough timeline it would be solved.
- bonniemuffin 8y agoThere's a huge long tail of small publishers though-- probably tens of thousands, and shadier fake news sites can always put up a new domain if they get blacklisted.
- pentae 8y agoHaving 200 million users to "Report this site as fake news" and a moderation team should overcome that
- mikeash 8y agoThe moderation team is key. Too often I see techies say a problem is impossible because computers can’t do it. Humans are also an acceptable solution, even if companies like Google try to pretend otherwise. I anticipate replies along the lines of “Facebook has a billion users, they’d need a gigantic team to handle their volume.” To preemptively respond: yes they would. That’s the nature of business. Sometimes you have to put substantial resources into it. Not all problems scale infinitely with just data centers. If you really want to scale with just data centers, stick to services where that’s appropriate.
- bonniemuffin 8y agoThe parent said "You could literally put a team of about 5 people on this", and now we're up to "they’d need a gigantic team" in 3 levels of comment replies. I bet if it was easy they would've already done it, and I wouldn't be surprised if they DO have a gigantic team working on it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]