5 ms·
Amazon's response, from Ars' article: > Echo woke up due to a word in background conversation sounding like "Alexa." Then, the subsequent conversation was hear
by gnicholas 8y ago
Amazon's response, from Ars' article:
> Echo woke up due to a word in background conversation sounding like "Alexa." Then, the subsequent conversation was heard as a "send message" request. At which point, Alexa said out loud "To whom?" At which point, the background conversation was interpreted as a name in the customers contact list. Alexa then asked out loud, "[contact name], right?" Alexa then interpreted background conversation as "right." As unlikely as this string of events is, we are evaluating options to make this case even less likely.
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/05/amazon-confirms-that-echo-device-secretly-shared-users-private-audio/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/05/amazon-confirms-that...
- RyanShook 8y agoSeems like a pretty big stretch...
- bisby 8y agoI mean, if this was a one in a million chance of happening, and there have been billions of conversations happening near devices like these, I'm surprised this hasn't happened more often. If you have an echo and it kicks on unexpectedly, you can go to the app to see what it thought you said, along with a recording of you saying it. I've had "alright, uhh..." trigger it. and on the grainy bad across the room recording, I could see how the computer thought it was "Alexa". So I could see how if the computer is purposefully listening for "right" or "yes" that it could mistake any number of other words for that. I would much prefer an open source + open hardware alternative that works reliably, but I received an Echo dot as a gift, so after a few months of debating, I plugged it in. Having an always listening internet connected device that has access to your contact list is a pretty big stretch. But somehow we go along with that just fine.
- jacobsenscott 8y agoGiven the numbers it has almost certainly happened at least hundreds of times and probably thousands of times. But the remaining sequence of events - the receiver notifies the sender, and a media outlet picks it up, and amazon comments seems to have only happened once so far.
- acdha 8y agoAfter using these systems I think it's plausible: the current ML systems produce valid but incorrect words frequently and since the UI is designed for marketing rather than usability nobody wants to expose low confidence levels or a correction UI. They have enough customers that someone was bound to get a false positive which the system mapped to one of a few constrained choices in a brittle interface tree. As an example, I've noticed that Siri tends to default to offering to open Notes on my iPhone any time it fails to recognize a query correctly. Alexa on the FireTV is better but still has lots of failure modes which look suspiciously like the default branch of a switch statement where it ends up really off on a common query in a quiet room.
- mindfulhack 8y agoI want some YouTube tech channel to test this out and see if this story by Amazon is bullshit or not. Have a private-sounding conversation and intersperse it with a sudden nonchalant, 'hey, alexa visited me today and...' and then keep talking and then 'I really want to send a message to these students, you know and...' and so on and so forth.
- Uberphallus 8y agoNot a test, but obligatory link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMRI-YDHT2I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMRI-YDHT2I When the episode was aired there were numerous reports of the show triggering Alexas and Google Homes of the viewers.
- tetrep 8y agoI think it's decently plausible if your Alexa hears you, but you don't hear your Alexa. So you continue on your conversation, and you say enough to keep progressing the flow. I would assume any failed speech recognition attpempts are recorded so Amazon can have a human look at and classify them, but at the very least they probably keep logs, so they should have this information when debugging. Maybe we'll get a more detailed postmortem later.
- sorokod 8y agoAs unlikely as this string of events is, we are evaluating options to make this case even less likely. Would be very interesting to see the actual probabilities assigned to these "unlikelys"
- ItsMe000001 8y agoIt's like those "one in a hundred million years" events that nevertheless do happen, inexplicably, because hey, we calculated the odds, why won't the universe adhere to our calculations? :-) Taleb, Black Swan, etc... I'm aware I'm not making a high-quality comment of amazing insight, on the other hand, plenty of examples where people don't seem to care. Since I presume people, while being "people", are not that gullible, I'm sure if one follows the incentives one may find reasons...
- spir 8y agoIn my house, there is a design flaw in Alexa which encourages this failure mode: there is a single volume level for the system, instead of separate volume levels for Alexa voice vs. music/application audio. I keep my Alexa's volume at 2-3, because otherwise the music / podcasts are too loud for me. However at volume 2-3 the Alexa system voice is fairly quiet and I often miss things Alexa says- requested or accidental. I'd prefer to keep Alexa system voice at volume 5, but music at 2-3. I requested this feature of a distinct Alexa voice volume years ago. I would be interested if anyone has a solution for this.
- Corrado 8y agoI would like a feature where Alexa detected the sound level in the room and responded with an appropriate volume. For example, in the quiet of the early morning I just want to hear the days weather forecast at a low volume, to avoid waking others in the house. However, during the afternoon, when kids are playing and the A/C is rattling and the dog is barking, I would like my responses in a higher volume.