4 ms·
> while it's true the same rules apply, it's not true that those rules necessarily produce the same results if that is the only element that changes. Right, an
by dahart 8y ago
> while it's true the same rules apply, it's not true that those rules necessarily produce the same results if that is the only element that changes.
Right, and I was only talking about the legality. It's not any more legal for Google to infringe copyright internally, even if the material impact might be less.
> neither copyright law nor general federal law on civil liability has a parental liability provision which would have this effect. State tort-law parental liability provisions generally aren't expansive enough to cover most (or in many cases any) copyright claims
Federal and state issues of parental liability are discussed a few places. You're right that it's not super clear cut, though many states do have general parental liability laws that hold parents accountable for damage.
https://www.newmediarights.org/copyright/are_parents_liable_children%E2%80%99s_illegal_filesharing https://www.newmediarights.org/copyright/are_parents_liable_...
https://www.eff.org/document/parental-liability-copyright-infringement-minor-children https://www.eff.org/document/parental-liability-copyright-in...
https://www.mwl-law.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/parental-responsibility-in-all-50-states.pdf https://www.mwl-law.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/parental-...
Worth mentioning that in some cases the RIAA filed suits against minors directly. Also worth noting that many families settled before any ruling on liability or even guilt. Being sued under plausible sounding rules can be damaging even if there's no actual law to back it.
Regardless of the technicalities here, @mankash666's question wasn't necessarily a legal one. The real answer to that question is that you are at least partially to blame for files being shared if you make videos using unlicensed music and share it with your son who then shares it online. Even if you don't get caught or fined, it's still kinda your fault.
- candiodari 8y agoActually because internal distribution at companies is generally considered to not be distribution because it's the legal entity that is the company that's using it. The internal employees actually watching/changing the content are simply acting as the agents of that legal entity. Therefore only the legal entity that is the company needs to have rights to the content, not the employees. For instance, you can install windows on computers at work (which definitely is distribution), without the rights to do so. Only the company needs said rights. That's why "the rules are different" for companies. They're not different, they just apply to different legal entities.
- dahart 8y ago> Actually because internal distribution at companies is generally considered to not be distribution This is not true. Copying material internally to a company is distribution. If you (person or company) don’t have the rights to copy, then it is illegal. If you do have a license, then it's legal distribution. It seems like you’re conflating copyright rules with licenses. The copyright rules are not different for companies than for individuals; without the right to copy, no entity, person or company, other than the copyright holder and license holders, can do so legally. It’s fairly simple. > That's why "the rules are different" for companies. They're not different, they just apply to different legal entities. Also not true. Copyrights belong to the author/creator of a work, they protect the author, they grant the author exclusive right to copy the work. This protection does not differentiate or change based on who wants to copy the work. Licenses are what apply differently to different legal entities. > The internal employees actually watching/changing the content are simply acting as the agents of that legal entity. That’s only true when the content has been licensed to the company for company-wide internal use. If the content was licensed to an individual and then distributed internally to a company, co-workers might not be allowed to consume that content, depending on the license. Furthermore, some content can be licensed to an individual at a company, such that the same individual is not allowed to use that content outside of work, and no other individuals at the company can use it either.
- candiodari 8y ago> This is not true. Copying material internally to a company is distribution. If you (person or company) don’t have the rights to copy, then it is illegal. If you do have a license, then it's legal distribution. It's only distribution if access changes from one (legal) person to another. If a company gives access to employees acting as agents for that company, that's not distribution. But yes, one would hope that there was a license for the thing being distributed, to the company, before this happened. > That’s only true when the content has been ... In the sense that licenses are contracts, and can contain any restrictions you want. On the other hand, if you buy a boxed copy of software at a store, and then regularly let whatever employee happens to be available actually use it (e.g. letting a copy of word get used by whichever secretary the temp agency sent this week) is perfectly legal, and very, very, very common.