7 ms·
I am historically[0], categorically opposed[1] to the cargo cult surrounding Code of Conducts.. However, this one is quite fair and toothless. It's not against
by dijit 8y ago
I am historically[0], categorically opposed[1] to the cargo cult surrounding Code of Conducts.. However, this one is quite fair and toothless.
It's not against any people or even for any people- It seems rather devoid of political affiliation..
It's just about attempting to be fair when interacting with people.. which we should all be doing anyway.
https://golang.org/conduct https://golang.org/conduct
[0]: https://blog.dijit.sh/freebsd-i-guess-we-weren-t-destined-to-be https://blog.dijit.sh/freebsd-i-guess-we-weren-t-destined-to...
[1]: https://blog.dijit.sh/moving-away-from-github https://blog.dijit.sh/moving-away-from-github
- ronnier 8y agoIt seems more targeted towards the intellectual bullies, the online jerk types and seems to stay clear of politics.
- geofft 8y agoI would think then that you should be supportive of codes of conduct: you know up front that you have a fundamental distrust of the FreeBSD project leadership and GitHub organizational leadership, and not of the Go project's leadership, precisely because they have different codes of conduct saying different things. (I'm opposed to cargo-culting codes of conduct for this exact reason. By all means, copy the Contributor Covenant word-for-word, but only if you truly agree with every word!)
- dijit 8y agoThat is a fair point, using it as a litmus test of what technology leaderships believe. However, I have this crazy idea that a technologies worth is not tied to the political affiliation of the creator or maintainer. I would like us all to focus on the technology and less on the individual or group.. I imagined it would be easy- as on the internet, nobody can tell you're a dog. But apparently I'm wrong.
- geofft 8y agoI don't think you're wrong - the technology's worth isn't tied to the politics of the creator or maintainer. It's important that free software is free for literally anyone to use without discrimination, and I think you'd find very few supporters of CoCs who disagree with that (at least, among those who also identify themselves with the free software or open source movements). But the problem is that the way technologies are developed is inherently not a technical problem, it's a social problem. If it were a technical problem, we'd have code writing and reviewing code, not humans. (I've never heard a single open-source project saying "The problem is that our maintainers have too much free time and there are too many high-quality patches to merge.") It's about how humans interact, and how humans work in community, and how humans provide each other feedback. And this unavoidably brings up all sorts of weird human behaviors that have very little to do with technology. As a random example, I'm writing this comment from the OpenStack Summit, which is an in-person event that you probably want to be attending if you're involved with development of OpenStack. If you can't get a visa to the country where it is, that's a problem. If the conference venue is located somewhere with laws about bathrooms and gender assigned at birth, and you refuse to use the bathroom that matches the gender assigned you at birth, you probably won't be at the venue for the entire day. Should the project care about these things? Should it decide that these laws are bad and we value our contributors who have these constraints enough to find a locality without them? This has zero to do with technology, but (apparently) we've decided that technical projects give better results with in-person meetings, and if you're going to be expected to attend in-person meetings, you want to know whether the community will have your back. Nobody cares if you're a dog, if you can interact with the other humans (or dogs) on the project in a productive way. An obvious (and entirely unfortunate) example is how the language of almost all open-source communities is English; if your native language is something else, you'd better pick up a working understanding of technical English. If you're a dog (or a human) who can't do that, and you try to work inside a technical community, people will care - not about who you are, but about how you interact. But again, this is all about how technologies are developed. If you just want to use it, nobody cares if you're a dog or a corporation or a missile guidance system. And if you want to fork the project (which is really a misnomer, what is being forked is the community), you may. And if you produce patches that are worthwhile and license them freely, and someone in the original community wants to engage that community in cherry-picking your patches, they may.
- swebs 8y agoSounds like No Code Of Conduct would be up your alley. https://github.com/domgetter/NCoC https://github.com/domgetter/NCoC >1. We are all adults. Capable of having adult discussions. >2. We accept everyones contributions, we don't care if you're liberal or conservative, black or white, straight or gay, or anything in between! In fact, we won't bring it up, or ask. We simply do not care. >3. Nothing else matters!
- CBLT 8y agoSomething's wonky with your DNS, a minority of the queries I make for dijit.sh take over 3 seconds. Unfortunately, the first one must have timed out when made by my resolver and was negatively cached.
- Rapzid 8y agoI'm glad you posted this.. I had heard about anti CoC a while back(perhaps from you?) but never really dug into it.. Video game journalism was ruined for me back in 2011 and 2012 for reasons we all know and I was hyper aware of at the time. It went through a very dark time and is hopefully coming out the other side now.. I had not really paid much attention to the infiltration of the tech community. While I had noticed a few things such bikeshedding of issues on Github, as well as the whole node.js trigger word ordeal, my distaste for the whole thing at that point led me to largely ignore it.. I've been on a huge information gathering binge since your post though. Randi Harper, electronconf, USC Legends of Gaming, entryism targeted toward GitHub, shaming and threatening tactics used to seed OSS with CoCs.... Wow. I hadn't realized how out of hand and toxic things had gotten. Luckily, it seems that the industry is somewhat successfully pushing back? I'm getting the sense that the larger community has found its voice and is pushing back against the intellectually bankrupt thinking and tactics.. This is the best intellectual analysis of the situation I've come across so far(I'm still digging though): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gatn5ameRr8&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gatn5ameRr8&feature=youtu.be