4 ms·
> Google's INTERNAL use of copyrighted material is within the legal bounds. No, there is no such exception in US copyright law. Internal use of material falls
by dahart 8y ago
> Google's INTERNAL use of copyrighted material is within the legal bounds.
No, there is no such exception in US copyright law. Internal use of material falls under the same rules as anything public facing.
> you are free to add a copyrighted song to a family vacation slideshow only intended/accessible to your family offline
That's murky. It is not automatically legal. It is probably illegal if you're including your extended family and intend for them to copy & save your slideshow.
> IF your son leaks the said video,are you to blame?
Yes, if your son is less than 18 years old, you are legally responsible for his copyright violations. You can get sued for it, and some people have been. Maybe you missed the rash of RIAA lawsuits a few years ago? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_group_efforts_against_file_sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_group_efforts_against_fi...
- krona 8y agoNext you're going to tell us that singing Happy Birthday to your child is legally murky and probably unwise.
- dahart 8y agoHehe, well I might have, but Happy Birthday is now pretty safe, the US copyright was successfully challenged in court and the EU copyright expired. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Birthday_to_You#Copyright_status https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Birthday_to_You#Copyrigh...
- spyhi 8y agoIt isn't anymore, if it ever was. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/02/happy-birthday-is-public-domain-former-owner-warnerchapell-to-pay-14m/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/02/happy-birthday-i...
- crystaln 8y agoHappy Birthday is in the public domain now. As of a few years ago though, it was indeed legally murky though perhaps not unwise as long as performed in your basement with the lights out, and all in attendance are trusted and sworn to secrecy.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 8y ago> No, there is no such exception in US copyright law. Internal use of material falls under the same rules as anything public facing. Internal vs. external use will in most cases materially impact at least one of the fair use criteria (effect on market for the protected work), so while it's true the same rules apply, it's not true that those rules necessarily produce the same results if that is the only element that changes. > Yes, if your son is less than 18 years old, you are legally responsible for his copyright violations. As a parent as such, probably not; neither copyright law nor general federal law on civil liability has a parental liability provision which would have this effect. State tort-law parental liability provisions generally aren't expansive enough to cover most (or in many cases any) copyright claims, though something like Hawaii’s particularly expansive parental liability rules might, if they applied to the act in question. > Maybe you missed the rash of RIAA lawsuits a few years ago? Maybe you can cite even one where a court upheld the parental liability theory you articulate; none of those referred to in your source seem to (the only one that mentions a minor infringer seems to mention the amount minor’s direct liability, but not any parental liability.)
- shkkmo 8y ago> Internal vs. external use will in most cases materially impact at least one of the fair use criteria (effect on market for the protected work) But the creator says: "A fair amount of my footage has been licensed for internal use only" Doesn't this mean that this violation does impact that market?
- dahart 8y ago> while it's true the same rules apply, it's not true that those rules necessarily produce the same results if that is the only element that changes. Right, and I was only talking about the legality. It's not any more legal for Google to infringe copyright internally, even if the material impact might be less. > neither copyright law nor general federal law on civil liability has a parental liability provision which would have this effect. State tort-law parental liability provisions generally aren't expansive enough to cover most (or in many cases any) copyright claims Federal and state issues of parental liability are discussed a few places. You're right that it's not super clear cut, though many states do have general parental liability laws that hold parents accountable for damage. https://www.newmediarights.org/copyright/are_parents_liable_children%E2%80%99s_illegal_filesharing https://www.newmediarights.org/copyright/are_parents_liable_... https://www.eff.org/document/parental-liability-copyright-infringement-minor-children https://www.eff.org/document/parental-liability-copyright-in... https://www.mwl-law.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/parental-responsibility-in-all-50-states.pdf https://www.mwl-law.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/parental-... Worth mentioning that in some cases the RIAA filed suits against minors directly. Also worth noting that many families settled before any ruling on liability or even guilt. Being sued under plausible sounding rules can be damaging even if there's no actual law to back it. Regardless of the technicalities here, @mankash666's question wasn't necessarily a legal one. The real answer to that question is that you are at least partially to blame for files being shared if you make videos using unlicensed music and share it with your son who then shares it online. Even if you don't get caught or fined, it's still kinda your fault.