4 ms·
Google was making commercial use of copyright material without the correct permissions. That's a pretty clear infringement, and the rights holder can sue for lo
by DanBC 8y ago
Google was making commercial use of copyright material without the correct permissions. That's a pretty clear infringement, and the rights holder can sue for losses.
> you are free to add a copyrighted song to a family vacation slideshow only intended/accessible to your family offline.
I'd question whether you can in fact do this. Obviously the rights holders aren't going to sue, but even so the law probably doesn't allow this. (It doesn't in the UK, even if we ignore the format-shifting).
- kbenson 8y agoIs it the commercial part that makes it infringement, or does that just make it clear infringement? I was under the impression as long as it's non-commercial use it's mostly allowed, but I'm not sure how that works out if for example I play something on a large screen in a public park. Is that infringing? If so, is it because it's shown to a lot of people, or because the reputational benefit of doing so may have some commercial ramifications and it's argued under that aspect?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoInterestingly, this article on performing rights: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Performing_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Performing_rights seems to suggest "public" performance is any amount of people outside your close circle of family and friends. Which would seem to suggest that any internal workplace transmission would constitute a "public" performance of a copyrighted work.
- bigiain 8y agoTo a first approximation, copyright law covers the rights you have to copy other people's work. There are some extremely limited exceptions based on your reasons for copying it (things like parody, commentary, new reporting), these are very tightly defined exceptions called "fair use". There are no blanket exceptions for "non commercial" use. Keep in mind, the creation/ownership of the work gives the copyright holder unlimited authority to ban _any_ use of the work. If I write a song or make a video, I 100% have the right to say "Nobody can use this for any purpose" - then the _only_ legal uses other people can make of it are those tightly defined exceptions permitted by copyright law. "Fair use" _is_ a legal right to use copyrighted work without permission, but it's possibly one of the least understood and most violated laws in existence... And no - it does not give you any rights to "play something on a large screen in a public park"...