5 ms·
Media companies fear and photographers love Richard Liebowitz
- znpy 8y agoSo if regular people download music and movies it's "unethical" and "hurts the industry", but if big corporations make profits photographers' work then it's "fair use" ? It really smells like BS to me.
- a3n 8y agoIf you think of yourself as primarily a resource to governments, law enforcement and corporations, as they do, then it makes sense.
- ubernostrum 8y agoHigh-pressure tactics based on demanding settlements due to the ruinous cost of litigation, threats of even more ruinous statutory damages, and all the other tricks detailed here have been used by media conglomerates against individuals. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
- vatueil 8y agoAre we talking about the same "media companies" though? While many wouldn't shed a tear for entertainment groups such as the RIAA and other big media companies, the list of targets includes many newspapers and smaller media outfits: > He sues media companies of all sizes—including Condé Nast, Hearst, Time Inc., Univision, Forbes, Barstool Sports, Breitbart News, Business Insider, Inside Edition, Zagat, Rolling Stone, the Daily Beast, the Daily Caller, the Daily Dot, the Daily Voice, the Village Voice, NBC, ABC, CBS, CNN, Fox News, Vox Media, Cox Media, Uproxx Media, and, yes, The Slate Group—and in all seasons. Even if Liebowitz's current attacks on news media are acceptable, I would worry whether such attacks from him and other lawyers might broaden their scope in the future. As the article mentions, the recent SDNY ruling that websites are liable for embedded content may be but the first expansion: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/02/federal-judge-says-embedding-tweet-can-be-copyright-infringement https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/02/federal-judge-says-emb...
- ubernostrum 8y agoNews organizations have engaged in "copyright trolling" too. Your Google search term for a notorious case is "Righthaven".
- a3n 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Righthaven https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Righthaven
- marcus_holmes 8y agoThe bloke deserves a medal
- rrauenza 8y agoTony and Chelsea Northrup describe their experience with suing an Australian firm that used his photo/her image in product packaging: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUEbi4r8Pg0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUEbi4r8Pg0 It was enlightening how stressful it can be chasing these guys down ...
- cocacola1 8y agoSeems easy to avoid, though. 1) Get permission. or 2) Use public domain images. Bam. Problem solved.
- mosselman 8y agoBeing first with a story is often what media are after, so getting permission is, I imagine, not usually something they really want to wait for. So yes 2 seems a viable solution or using some sort of subscription for images as described in the article.
- mikeash 8y agoIn the electronic age, stories can be updated after the fact. Run with the images you have permission for, add more later as you obtain more.
- brandnewlow 8y agoThis man is a hero. This story tries to take an even tack with him but fails to accurately characterize the actions of the media companies. They should not be excused when “an intern makes a mistake”. If they’re unable to adequately train their interns then they shouldn’t use interns. And if they can’t afford well-trained professional editorial workers they should go out of business. I say this as someone who used to work in media and saw media companies blow up out of nowhere on the back of fair use abuse (Bleacher Report, HuffPo).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yardie 8y agoThese million dollar companies are worried about paying thousands for a photo to an a freelancer. Meanwhile individuals deal with bankruptcy, prison, and even suicide due to these companies suing them for a song, photo, or video. I shall play the tiniest violin for their troubles.
- killjoywashere 8y agoI don't get the sense the CEOs are that worried. It's counsel that's annoyed, and probably suggested the topic to this writer. Slate, after all, is one of the affected companies.
- yardie 8y agoIt’s also counsel that determines and requests the damages when songs and movies are shared. These lawyers are worried that Leibovitz will file 600 lawsuits but see nothing wrong in filing suits against 1000+ individuals for their clients.
- arkades 8y agoI appreciate the irony that these media companies leverage the cost of litigation in order to avoid paying for photos but, when the cost of litigation is used to extract compensation for their victims, this whole litigation blackmail thing is just evil and out of control! I can’t help but feel the article chose to veer too far in the direction of sympathizing with the serial-thieving companies here. Is the best that could be said for this guy is hat he’s an ass “of the media’s own making”?
- jasonjayr 8y ago> In conversation and in court documents, attorneys who have tangled with Liebowitz have vented over what they deem his chronic overvaluation of his clients’ claims, his habit of dodging discovery obligations, his disregard for the admittedly vague concept of fair use—which, basically, is the doctrine that makes it OK for journalists and commentators to quote limited portions of copyrighted works without first asking permission. (“Fair use is an area that, so far as Richard is concerned, apparently doesn’t exist,” one attorney told me.) Large media owners also seem to think fair use doesn't exist, and deliberately make it hard for citizens to exercise fair use. It's interesting to see them squrim when the shoe is on the other foot. (and the irony of this post is not lost on me ....)
- kapauldo 8y ago$150k for a photo is ridiculous and its not "work"