5 ms·
I observe that cars and other objects often come very close to each other, so it would seem impossible to simply brake based on "converging paths". It's necessa
by perl4ever 8y ago
I observe that cars and other objects often come very close to each other, so it would seem impossible to simply brake based on "converging paths". It's necessary to know what an object is and how it's going to behave. If you don't, I don't see how you can go anywhere.
- slavik81 8y agoYou don't need to stop if you're uncertain, but you should slow down. That makes it easier to stop once you know you have to.
- w0m 8y agowith significant fuzz factor, agreed. If i'm on the sidewalk and take a step toward the road, should it make the car jerk? Probably not, it's a hard call for passenger comfort. From another angle, think of subway tracks - the algo your describing would slow to a crawl as it crosses every station.
- fabianhjr 8y ago> From another angle, think of subway tracks - the algo your describing would slow to a crawl as it crosses every station. As far as trains go, they do slow down when passing trough a track adjacent to a platform. There are some non-platform adjacent tracks the train companies use to avoid slowing down, however they will slow down or even stop if something is going on. Similarly, high speed rail doesn't have level crossings due to safety considerations. Overall trains are very safe and they are _designed_ for safety. It is highly irresponsible and immoral to just wing it with people's life/safety.
- w0m 8y ago> It is highly irresponsible and immoral to just wing it with people's life/safety 100% agree. > As far as trains go, they do slow down when passing trough a track adjacent to a platform. There are some non-platform adjacent tracks the train companies use to avoid slowing down, however they will slow down or even stop if something is going on. The equivalency isn't 'trains slow down through stations' (That would be cars having lower speedlimit in pedestrian areas - they do and the ubers honor) , it would be 'train spikes breaks if someone takes a step toward the edge' (Which they don't, even though it would potentially save lives). There's always a tradeoff between usability and absolute safety. I'm not saying the uber did nothing wrong, at a minimum it should have spiked it's breaks. The 'perfect world' solution would be the uber knowing mass and momentum of approaching objects, and whether they could stop in time. But honestly, here would that have helped? We'll never get rid of people walking in front of moving cars, just have to be find the happy balance (which we clearly haven't)
- Symbiote 8y ago> 'train spikes breaks if someone takes a step toward the edge' (Which they don't, even though it would potentially save lives). A train's deceleration under maximum braking is far, far lower than a car. [1] suggests 1.2m/s² (paragraph 8). [2] says the deceleration of a low-speed train crashing into the buffers at the end of the line in a station should not be more than 2.45m/s² (paragraph 35). That caused "minor injuries" to some passengers. Trains do slow down earlier if the platform they are approaching is very crowded, but there's not really anything else they can do. [1] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/547c906640f0b602410001b3/R252006_070108_Part_1_Esher.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/547c906640f0b... [2] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/547c906640f0b602410001b3/R252006_070108_Part_1_Esher.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/547c906640f0b...
- reubenswartz 8y agoWith trains, nothing else is supposed to be on the tracks. With cars, there is an expectation that you have to share the road with other vehicles, objects, obstacles, pedestrians, etc.
- slavik81 8y ago> If I'm on the sidewalk and take a step toward the road, should it make the car jerk? No. That's my point. Take less drastic measures earlier, and only escalate when you have to. That's how I drive, and a self-driving car can do the same.
- majormajor 8y agoIt absolutely is not necessary to know how another object will behave on the road: you slow down because of the uncertainty! "It might move out of my way" is no reason to get so close at such a high speed that you can't avoid it when it doesn't!
- maxxxxx 8y agoThat's not how traffic works at the moment. I often have pedestrians walk towards the street and I assume they will stop so I don't slow down unless they are children or similar. Almost every day I could hit pedestrians if they kept walking.
- majormajor 8y ago> I often have pedestrians walk towards the street and I assume they will stop so I don't slow down > the self-driving system software classified the pedestrian as an unknown object, as a vehicle, and then as a bicycle with varying expectations of future travel path Little different, huh? If you see something that looks like it might be in your way, and you aren't sure what it is, you just keep going? And if I see a pedestrian in the middle of the road at a random spot, especially at night, I'm slowing down since I don't know WTF they're thinking. Or if I'm in a neighborhood with regular street crossings carved out of the sidewalk and someone's coming up to one of those - I don't know how well they're paying attention to their surroundings.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI can tell pretty quickly if something is pedestrian or a bicycle and plan accordingly. In addition I can tell where the pedestrian is looking. Sometimes I slow down, sometimes I don't depending on how I assess the situation. I think it comes down to the fact that the classification algorithms are not ready for primetime.
- c22 8y agoYou should slow down. Those people you are describing sound like they want to cross the street, and they probably have right of way, so yield for them. Also, my two year old will sometimes walk towards the curb, but she is very good with streets, so I am not worried. She always stops and waits to hold someone's hand before crossing. This behavior freaks some drivers out, causing them to slow or come to a complete stop, which is the nicest outcome because then I can take her hand and cross the street. When I am walking by myself drivers rarely yield even as I am stepping into the street, even at marked crossings. I guess my point is if my two year old exhibits the behavior you ascribe to a hypothetical non-child pedestrian then how can you be sure your hypothetical pedestrian won't just "keep walking"? What if they are blind, or drunk, or reckless? Perhaps you have been lucky before and never struck a pedestrian but I strongly urge you to assess your behavior. Stop for pedestrians, it's the nice thing to do and it's probably the law where you live.