5 ms·
Go ahead and be an unpaid data gathering tool that can be used by bigcorps, those with the right exploit or (even if they don't do now) when ToS changes and tha
by r00fus 8y ago
Go ahead and be an unpaid data gathering tool that can be used by bigcorps, those with the right exploit or (even if they don't do now) when ToS changes and that company starts selling your information to the highest bidder.
They profit at your ignorance.
The fact that it will execute commands with your recorded voice should tell you there's a lot of exploits that can happen without your intervention.
If I want a device to start listening I'll go and push a button for it. The always listening stuff is way too big an vulnerability (like an unsecured API into your house).
- blackflame7000 8y agoI exist, and I also need email. Seems like a win-win for me and google. Realistically, what are you afraid of? Like I said if someone wanted to listen to me it would be very boring.
- icebraining 8y agoIf the only people who use private communications are those who need it, they'll be much easier to track, and that harms you indirectly.
- blackflame7000 8y agoI mean they can only track what I choose to share with them. They don't have some magic wand that breaks HTTPS.
- 908087 8y agoActually, they do. It's called Google Analytics, and it exists on a very large portion of the web. TLS isn't going to help protect you when the site you're on is loaded with user tracking and analytics scripts anyway.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis is why Google's pushing HTTPS Everywhere so hard, just like net neutrality: It eliminates Google's competition in collecting and monetizing data about your viewing. Google will claim that they make these moves because they care about your privacy, security, and freedom, but malicious tracking scripts they don't do anything about, because that would close off their own profit scheme.
- icebraining 8y agoWhich competitors will be excluded by the increase in HTTPS? Which companies exactly are relying on the connections being unencrypted, and how are they able to monitor them? And if Google's competitors are spying on HTTP rather than using tracking scripts, why does seemingly every page I visit load tracking scripts from a bunch of companies?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoISPs. HTTPS Everywhere and net neutrality laws are both endeavors designed to mitigate ISPs from providing ad networks and/or collecting data on Internet usage. Of course, Google claims they do this for your benefit, but if it was for your benefit, they'd need to stop doing the same things with tracking scripts. This is how you can tell they are pushing these to reduce competition, not to increase your privacy.
- icebraining 8y agoI can't say I've ever seen Google claim HTTPS was intended to protect my privacy, but fair enough, I forgot that ISPs can do that in the US.
- niftich 8y agoIn one of the major announcements for Chrome, 'Moving towards a more secure web' (2016-09-08) [1], the Chrome Security Team writes: "Chrome currently indicates HTTP connections with a neutral indicator. This doesn't reflect the true lack of security for HTTP connections. When you load a website over HTTP, someone else on the network can look at or modify the site before it gets to you." The word 'modify' is a hyperlink to an article titled 'AT&T Hotspots: Now with Advertising Injection' [2] (ironically, a non-HTTPS site). [1] https://security.googleblog.com/2016/09/moving-towards-more-secure-web.html https://security.googleblog.com/2016/09/moving-towards-more-... [2] http://webpolicy.org/2015/08/25/att-hotspots-now-with-advertising-injection/ http://webpolicy.org/2015/08/25/att-hotspots-now-with-advert...
- sidrajaram 8y ago> unpaid data gathering tool I get free unlimited google searching, gmail, google maps in return. I would pay a hefty amount if they starting charging for those and am happy to trade the use of my fairly benign data usage patterns in return. > starts selling your information to the highest bidder. I am confident they will never ever sell my personal information (not population-level aggregates, but actual raw data with PII) because they will lose their only source of revenue and will soon go bankrupt if they did so.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoYour Facebook data, annually, is worth about $12. Your Google data is probably not worth much more. Most Google employees, if asked a few years ago, would've told you they were confident Google would never participate in something as unethical as the American drone program. They were wrong. Corporations do not have a moral code, they operate on profits. They are effectively psychopaths, and any time you associate a corporation with human traits like ethics or morals, you have misjudged it. And bear in mind: Corporations are not a singular person. You could believe the guy responsible for packing the Google Toolbar in every other installer you downloaded off the Internet will never betray you, but eventually Sundar Pichai will be replaced by someone else, and corporate focus can, and will, change.
- pjmlp 8y agoI guess SV Google fan club is only now slowly realizing they aren't so different than the other corporations they bash against.
- psandersen 8y agoWhich is frustrating, I wouldn't blink at paying that much for Facebook if it meant a genuine ad and tracking free experience. I want to be your customer, not your product. IMHO Europe's GDPR should be mandating that companies are transparent about the value of the data collection and ads and allow users to pay the real cost instead to completely opt out.
- wilsonnb 8y ago