4 ms·
I think the split you draw between people looking at Bitcoin-the-real-thing and people adoring the machinery is an excellent one. If you look at the original p
by wpietri 8y ago
I think the split you draw between people looking at Bitcoin-the-real-thing and people adoring the machinery is an excellent one.
If you look at the original paper, it's pretty clear that Bitcoin was meant to be peer-to-peer electronic cash: https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
In practice, it has failed at this aim. I don't think that was necessarily so; plenty of things start out rough and become more useful over time. But the mechanics-adorers I've talked with seemed willfully blind to all the practical issues. We can't fix problems we refuse to see, so Bitcoin has preserved its machinery at the expense of fulfilling its vision.
- nicky0 8y agoHow would you change the machinery?
- wpietri 8y agoPersonally, I wouldn't. Most people don't want digital cash for the same reasons they don't use real cash: your risk of theft is higher, it's not as convenient to use, transactions can't be reversed, and you lose a lot of buyer protections. I use technology to solve problems for people. The few niches Bitcoin has found (e.g., speculation, money laundering, ransoms, light drug crime) are not really what I would call solving problems for people.
- GuthL 8y agoYour personal opinion on cash is irrelevant to the subject. Cash has property you say you don't want. Some people might and do want them. Just have a look at what the relationship between Germans and cash. Bitcoin has property similar to cash to many extend. It was not technically possible before its invention and as such as it is a real intrinsect value (dont ask me to quantify it)
- wpietri 8y agoIt wasn't my personal opinion. In the US, the use of cash is below half of personal transactions and has been declining for years; most countries are similar. I personally am more like the Germans here, but I recognize that I'm an outlier. Regardless, your point doesn't make a lot of sense, because many Germans surveyed on this say they use cash because it gives them better control over spending and more clarity as to where their money goes. Bitcoin is in no way superior to a debit card in that regard. The value of new possibility isn't really intrinsic; you measure it through seeing if people actually use it. With Bitcoin they mostly don't, which suggests that it is at best more useful to a small slice of people.
- dnautics 8y agoIn practice, Airbnb has failed at its aim of providing airbed style accommodations for conference goers.
- cheschire 8y agoAirbnb is a service, where bitcoin is a commodity. I don't mean to imply you are wrong. I simply mean that there may be an even more interesting parallel out there where a commodity is no longer being used in its originally intended way which may support bitcoin's evolution of purpose.
- aje403 8y agoAirbnb is a service. Bitcoin is a commodity in the same way online poker chips are a commodity
- optimuspaul 8y agoHow is bitcoin a commodity? I think you give it too much credit to elevate it to that status.
- this_user 8y agoIt's structure and behaviour much more resembles a commodity than it does any other asset class; it is basically digital gold. The CFTC agrees and considers itself the responsible regulator.
- wpietri 8y agoWith the important distinction that it's not an economically useful commodity. Sure, the CFTC regulated it, because their remit is one of the broadest. So you could call it a commodity by default. But it's not like you could make jewelry or breakfast cereal from Bitcoins in the same way you could use commodities like gold or wheat. So it's arguably more like a gambling instrument than any real commodity. Really, though, I think the closest financial match is a private currency: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_currency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_currency These are illegal in most places because they historically have caused a lot of problems without much in the way of redeeming value: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banking_in_the_United_States#1837%E2%80%931863:_%22Free_Banking%22_Era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banking_in_the_United_States#1...