16 ms·
The point is you pay full price to move; it’s no longer discounted by your marginal tax rate.
by closeparen 8y ago
The point is you pay full price to move; it’s no longer discounted by your marginal tax rate.
- maxerickson 8y agoAnd? It's hardly something to complain about if your effective taxes are lower in the new scheme even without the deduction. (Which is going to be true for an awful lot of the people considering moving away from small towns) Your comment is pretty much a different way of saying what I said in the first sentence of my second paragraph.
- repsilat 8y agoThey're not saying it's "something to complain about". You're arguing against something they didn't say -- the two points, - The tax changes were a net benefit, and - The tax changes make people less likely to move (because the net benefit is lower) are perfectly compatible.
- closeparen 8y agoMoving is now more expensive relative to not moving, so we should expect more people to stay put. The absolute tax burden is irrelevant.
- majormajor 8y agoCouldn't you just as easily spin it the other way? Moving is now feasible because of more total spendable dollars in my pocket, the relative tax savings are irrelevant? I can't speak for everyone, but that maps much more closely to my personal decision-making, which is in terms of absolute dollars, than your formulation.