8 ms·
I would honestly love to see a ground-up rebuild, but not the kind that would probably happen. OSX is getting creaky; it seems like it's had an increasing numbe
by _bxg1 8y ago
I would honestly love to see a ground-up rebuild, but not the kind that would probably happen. OSX is getting creaky; it seems like it's had an increasing number of integral bugs lately, and the "redesign" that came with Yosemite felt more like a rushed coat of paint than a substantial rethink of the UX.
Here's what I'd like to see: a fresh desktop OS that actually innovates in the space. Desktop UX innovation has slowed drastically in the smartphone age, and for Apple it's come to a screeching halt (Windows - dare I say - is now the leader in desktop innovation). The fact that OSX is the only modern desktop OS that doesn't have window snapping out of the box is simply shameful. Even Ubuntu has it now, without any Gnome extensions.
Despite all this, OSX still has a huge foothold as the developer platform of choice - especially for web - because of its combination of quality hardware, Unix-ness, and relative stability (though all of those are becoming harder and harder points to defend). Apple should take advantage of this and throw power users a bone. We've been waiting for years on end. Stop working on useless things like the Touch Bar and start rethinking what a desktop operating system can be in 2018.
Unfortunately, what would probably happen if they built a new desktop OS is iOS with mouse and keyboard support, and developers would leave in droves.
- virmundi 8y agoFix the terrible memory subsystem. There is no need to swap on a 16 GB laptop! Especially when Apple solders the drive to board! That leads to premature ware on the board and me having to spend 600$! My Linux machine is perfectly fine running 2 Eclipse IDEs, 3 docker containers and four Spring Boot Services. No swapping. Since macOS disabled overriding the memory configuration, my laptop swaps merely running Safari ( less than 10 tabs), and VSCode for Cordova all with 16 GB.
- _bxg1 8y agoI've read that there are reasons to use swap other than just as "RAM overflow"
- drb91 8y agoI don't think that the obvious problems with OS X (macOS, whatever) are with the UX, though. Sure, there are problems on that front, but I don't think they're the major pain points people deal with on a daily basis. Meanwhile, user-controllable per-process (or per-app) sandboxing would provide tangible benefit to all of us. This means, easy controls for accessing filesystem, network, cpu, gpu, memory, peripherals, and other processes. Most of these controls exist, but in ways that don't map well to the desktop environment. How do I see what that adobe agent is doing? Sure, I can buy Little Snitch, but this should really be built into the OS. Too much of the UNIX model is designed to secure a user's information from other users, which simply isn't a massive concern these days when we often have dedicated workstations and have issues trusting the processes we run as our own user. What if I suspect my TODO list has a built-in bitcoin miner? I should be able to limit its use of the CPU and GPU. Meanwhile, my editor still needs to read the configs of all my sandboxed apps, and whatever else I want it to access. This isn't necessarily an easy problem, but it's one I have confidence Apple could tackle, especially with mobile paving the way already. All this time, docker has been innovating on the sandboxing, with mostly positive results. Android, I believe, runs each process as its own user, leveraging the existing UNIX controls better. I'm not sure what precisely iOS does, but it's locked down well enough to cause me immense frustration building stuff for my phone--not exactly what I'd like to see on the desktop, but they clearly have the ability to provide many of the controls I am looking for on the desktop. I'm sure this would result in an improved UX as a result, TBH. If not, Google is coming down the road with Fuschia.
- _bxg1 8y agoYeah, some (arguably most) of the missing features/core problems are due to the fact that OSX has been all-but-ignored by Apple for half a decade, but some of them are just due to the fact that the UNIX paradigms are becoming outdated. Google is trying to solve the latter problem with Fuschia, you're right, which is interesting. But so far that OS's UX also looks like it's primarily mobile-focused, even if it's designed to be adaptable to desktops too. I think OSX's UX problems are mainly in the first category - Apple just doesn't care. Windows introduced snapping in Windows 7, nearly ten years ago. It is extremely useful and seems pretty easy to implement. As you say, you can always get a third-party application like the (fantastic) BetterTouchTool. But you shouldn't have to do that for something so fundamental. The very least Apple could be bothered to do is keep up.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- __sr__ 8y agoMicrosoft brought their essentials — kernel, filesystem, API etc. — up to scratch in mid 2000s. Vista and and 8 may not have been successful, but they played an important role in the evolution of Windows and Microsoft is now reaping the rewards in the form of Windows 10 — an OS which was dubbed as horribly unstable at launch and yet has become rock solid with updates — except for some unfortunate decisions like forced updates, privacy concerns, ads etc. Apple did something similar when they switched from Classic Mac OS to Mac OS X - a transition which helped them stay alive and eventually bounce back when almost every one had given up on them. The transition indirectly led them the ultimate success of iOS and iPhone. Microsoft was left behind in the smartphone race because they were late to the transition — the smartphone revolution started when they were still going through it and they were caught empty handed. They had nothing to show when they desperately needed an OS for smartphones. Had they launched the equivalent of Windows Phone 8 in 2009 or 2010, the history may have been very different from the one we know. But the world has come full cycle, while the Microsoft Windows ecosystem is still relatively young and can probably keep going for another decade or two, Apple’s OS is starting to show its age. It’s not just the age of macOS — it is much older then that. Apple finally decided to overhaul their filesystem, but other things like the kernel, the API etc. still need the treatment.
- _bxg1 8y agoInteresting theory; I didn't know all that history. Still, it's not just that OSX hasn't seen an overhaul in a while, it's that it hasn't even been getting incremental improvements outside of mission-critical bug fixes.
- gsnedders 8y ago> Apple finally decided to overhaul their filesystem, but other things like the kernel, the API etc. still need the treatment. And a large proportion of the kernel and APIs very obviously go all the way back to early NeXT days; they're really as old as WinNT is.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoOlder, actually... NeXT 1.0 was released in 1989; first version of NT shipped in 1993.
- digi_owl 8y agoI am honestly not sure these things needs to change. At least not until we have input systems that are superior to keyboard and mouse (and no, touch screen so far is not).
- reaperducer 8y agoAll I want for Christmas is macOS to stop showing me the SPOD whenever an external hard drive spins up. Reminds me of DOS days.
- _bxg1 8y agoDon't even get me started on the SMB client. I have to use it at work and it has lovely features like: - Peppering the network drive with trash files containing OSX-specific metadata - Failing to reconnect when the computer goes to sleep, except not really because it thinks the drive is still there, but you have to go through the connection process all over again before you can actually use it. - Getting out of sync with the file server and keeping the local copies of some files under slightly-different-names. But you can't see the real ones either, even after you reconnect. So all of your path references just break. etc. etc. etc.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoI was just thinking today it'd be nice if there was some kind of gitignore for SMB uploads to prevent Thumbs.db, Desktop.ini, and .DS_Store from ever uploading. I put a cron script on our work server to delete them periodically but that's the best thing I can find.
- reaperducer 8y ago> Peppering the network drive with trash files containing OSX-specific metadata There's an app that will automatically clean those up. Unfortunately, I can't remember the name of it right now. Hopefully it'll pop up on Google for you, if you're interested.
- stefanfisk 8y ago`defaults write com.apple.desktopservices DSDontWriteNetworkStores TRUE` should solve the first issue at least.
- jjoonathan 8y agoIn one of the OSX release keynotes, Steve Jobs said "with this OS we have set ourselves up for the next 20 years." That was 20 years ago. He was spot on. The real questions are whether or not present-day Apple administration has enough vision to (want to) carry out an OS migration and, as you mention, whether or not the vision is any good.
- falcon620 8y agoApple have basically spent the minimal amount of resources on Mac portables the past few years. We should all get the picture and migrate elsewhere, I'm afraid. Windows laptops are looking more and more appealing...
- _bxg1 8y agoWindows is looking more and more appealing, at least. Maybe Apple will just say to-hell-with-it and start selling MacBooks with Windows preinstalled. If Microsoft got the Linux subsystem fleshed out, I'd buy one.
- ProfessorLayton 8y agoI agree that OSX is pretty creaky in certain areas, particularly the Finder for me. A spotty SMB/AFP connection should not lockup a system, and yet has remained a nightmare for as long as I can remember. Sadly, Apple has scared me off their legacy software rewrites with their rewrite of iTunes and High Sierra. The releases were either disastrously sloppy (High Sierra) or a complete letdown (iTunes remains hot garbage). Removing iTunes' persistent nav bar + tying it to Apple Music on Mac makes it one of the worst pieces of software I interact with on a daily basis. I don't want OSX to suffer the same fate. http://web.archive.org/web/20130301120749/http://www.apple.com/itunes/whats-new/ http://web.archive.org/web/20130301120749/http://www.apple.c...
- _bxg1 8y agoTo be fair, iTunes has been hot garbage for as long as I can remember
- cimmanom 8y agoIn 2002 it was straight up amazing.
- iambateman 8y agoI just want to hammer home how correct you are. I remember thinking in 2006: "all audio consumption applications eventually go to shit. When will iTunes go?" 12 years later, the application is a nightmare to use while Spotify is a joy. I have my fingers crossed that Spotify remains usable, because I don't see them making huge business model shifts.
- FPGAhacker 8y agospeaking of AFP, since apple is dumping their routers, does that mean time machine is going away? I imagine remote time machine will and we'll just have local snapshots.
- giobox 8y ago
- marssaxman 8y agoWhat is "window snapping"? If it's that thing Ubuntu does where accidentally dragging a window too close to one of the edges makes it spontaneously take over the whole screen, I'm glad OS X doesn't do that.
- _bxg1 8y agoIt's being able to automatically resize a window to one half of the screen or the other. Typically this can be done by dragging it to the sides, or by a keyboard shortcut (usually Windows Key + Left/Right Arrow). No doubt it would be easy to provide a disable option; just because it annoys you doesn't mean it shouldn't be implemented.
- brian-armstrong 8y agoI'd much rather Apple just buy Divvy and integrate that. It's more flexible and much less prone to error.
- radley 8y agoYou're overlooking Chrome OS (with open source equivalent Chromium OS). While it might not be ready for pro-level production, it certainly is a revolutionary lightweight OS that's gaining more and more traction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrome_OS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrome_OS
- _bxg1 8y agoI'm well aware of Chrome OS. It's great for casual use, but to my knowledge it's really not a reasonable development platform. Generally speaking, developers want/need: - A fully-accessible file system - A bash command line - Tool support. Repositories, code runtimes, compilers, IDE's, etc. I know there are some all-in-one web-based IDE's that you can work in, which are interesting, but I've yet to see one that could act as a full replacement for professional, native tools. And most of those don't support anything other than web development.
- exelius 8y agoWith all the new IAC stuff coming out, expect big companies to move the web IDE route over the next 10 years. Even if it’s less functional, they will push it out. I have several clients really interested in it; not least because in combination with a serverless architecture, it makes end-to-end security really easy.
- orangecat 8y agoThis should help: https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/5/8/17318340/chrome-os-update-new-features-linux-apps-google-io-2018 https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/5/8/17318340/ch...
- code_duck 8y agoAs far as Ubuntu supporting window snapping, it’s worth noting that Linux has supported every conceivable window management feature for years, including some that have never come anywhere near Windows or Mac, like tiling window managers. making window management entirely modular. Every WM or desktop combo in Linux has other features I find highly convenient which are strangely missing from Mac and Windows, such as a drag modifier key for windows, which allows you to move a window when the title bar is off screen. I prefer features like windowshading to minimization, too, and it is simple to configure Linux to do that, unlike Mac or Windows. I don’t use the feature, but would surprised if window-snap-to-borders wasn’t supported as far back as KDE 1.3 or WindowMaker .92.
- _bxg1 8y agoSure, but I don't think it was available out of the box for Ubuntu until recently (I could be wrong), and I also think Windows 7 invented snap-to-sides (could be wrong on this too). Linux has always been the OS where you can do just about anything you want with enough research and effort, but it still matters what the most mainstream distro offers out of the box at any given time.
- code_duck 8y agoI do believe that WM feature was available long before Windows 7... I recall similar options in many WMs as well as apps like Gimp, called sticky edges, edge attraction, snap-to-borders, and so forth. It seems like a fairly apparent idea to assist window placement, and i’d be surprised if it hasn’t been around in some form since the 80s. Linux is highly extensible and modular, so it’s hard to say what it provides ‘out of the box’, even a given distro. For almost any distro, it’s very simple to start using a different WM (literally 3 steps). I suppose it’s true that for the majority of users, what the defaults are is more important than an option merely being available as most people will never even read the settings menus.
- pjmlp 8y agoMy favorite feature, minimize to title bar, seems to be left for Window Maker and KDE, everyone else apparently has dropped it.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoGiven the decline of the desktop software market, I'm not sure a radical redesign makes sense for Apple. Looking at Apple's lineup, what's driving sales seems to be the end user market, and it's not clear to me Apple wants to be in the Pro market anymore. In any case, the Pro market is about delivering workhorses for running (Adobe et al) software, so a radical redesign will probably result in Adobe et al stopping to produce Mac OS software alltogether. The maturity of the desktop software "market" is also evident in Linux. Ubuntu has recently choosen the venerable X.org rather than wayland for its LTS release over compatibility and stability concerns. I'd say that's a reasonable choice; after all, you're using Linux for apps that have been in the making for over 20 years, such as Inkscape, Krita, Gimp, Blender, etc. I'm also not sure what Docker and sandboxing brings to the table (except for developers). Desktop workflows are organized around open file formats and clipboard cut/paste. So I agree future Apple products will focus on iOS. There's simply so much more money to be made there.
- _bxg1 8y agoDevelopers have to have an OS to work from, no matter how much end-user usage shifts to mobile. Otherwise there would be no apps for those other platforms. Apple may well get out of the developer game, which seems like a dumb idea given their market share, but I'm neither a finance expert nor an Apple executive, so maybe that's just how the numbers play out. Microsoft is making a decent-sized push in this space lately, with the Linux subsystem, Visual Studio Code, etc. So I would guess they'll end up taking Apple's market share, which is a bit of a shame as far as I'm concerned.
- pjmlp 8y agoMicrosoft learned, thanks to OS X, that most developers don't really want a UNIX, they are more than happy with a POSIX compatible layer for bash, awk, perl, C.... I bet if they had kept the original POSIX personality and improved it throughout the years, many devs would have not looked elsewhere.
- pier25 8y agoA huge point in favor of macOS is the quality of its ecosystem. I only noticed this a couple of years ago when I tried to switch to Windows. When trying to find replacements for apps I use daily either there was nothing that had the functionality I wanted or what I found was just terrible. I found tons of win32 crap, or apps that didn't support scaling properly. Even software from Adobe... Some examples: Alfred, iStatMenus, Karabiner, BetterTouchTool, etc. After a couple of days and a buggy experience with a Surface Book 1 I returned it and bought a MBP.
- _bxg1 8y agoAll the more reason for Apple not to let that ecosystem burn to the ground, just because they're making lots of money from iOS.
- theSpaceOctopus 8y agoI feel the same way. Also, the integration between Apple hardware is great. I have Macs, an iPhone and an iPad and everything works ridiculously well together. I’ve contemplated switching to Linux for a while, and keep a laptop with Fedora installed, but every time I seriously consider it I picture losing those key applications and the tight integration with my other devices and I can’t justify it.
- romwell 8y ago>A huge point in favor of macOS is the quality of its ecosystem. A huge point in favor of Windows is the diversity of its ecosystem. And what's wrong with Win32 per se that you'd discount it as crap? Not everything needs to be 64-bit (and since on Windows the only compelling reason is >4GB RAM usage - it shouldn't).
- snowwrestler 8y agoA ground-up rewrite for... window snapping? :-) I joke, but it's important to remember just how far behind Windows in basic operating system architecture Mac OS 9 was when Apple launched OS X. Apple absolutely had to replace Mac OS from the ground up. It had no choice. Is macOS (the artist formerly known as OS X) in the same position today? I would argue no. Most of the "problems" with macOS are either UI complaints like window snapping, or ugly bugs--which are more likely the result of development workflow issues than fundamental shortcomings in the technology of the OS. When Microsoft made the big shift to address their security issues, it was mostly a sea change in how they developed Windows, not a ground-up rewrite of Windows.
- __sr__ 8y ago> A ground-up rewrite for... window snapping? :-) No, but it does need to be brought on par with the state of the art in UNIX world — things like process sandboxing, container support, process limits (like cgroups), a modern development environment (like .net is for Windows), better package management (App Store is a bad joke), cross platform development between for iOS and macOS, stability, performance enhancements etc. In fact, I am OK with the UI — it could do with some modernisation and new features, but for the most part, it is very usable. And the tooling could definitely do with an upgrade. They are still using an ancient version of bash, for example. If they can’t use newer bash because of GPL, they could write their own shell, for example. The fact that something like Homebrew is the go to package manager tells the story of a major gap.
- _bxg1 8y agoMaybe the needed changes could be made without a total rewrite - I'm a web developer, not a systems developer - but they can't be made without a major shift in attitude on Apple's part, and they do go deeper than the UX, as other people here have elaborated on
- spartanatreyu 8y agoI made a window snapping script for macOS using the open source utility hammerspoon. It supports keyboard and mouse snapping for windows with fullscreen, half screen, quarter screen and center presets. I'll leave my old comment about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12097859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12097859 And a link to the script here: https://gist.github.com/spartanatreyu/850788a0441e1c5565668a35ed9a1dfc https://gist.github.com/spartanatreyu/850788a0441e1c5565668a...
- PascLeRasc 8y agoI personally disagree. OS X, even older versions, is to me worlds ahead of Windows 7/10. I love the menu bar at the top for application-specific menus, the tabbed file manager, Spotlight is the best system-wide search compared to Windows or any third-party Windows tools. Devices like audio interfaces and printers are so much easier to get working than on Windows. The system preferences menu is a lot cleaner and easier to navigate than control panel (you have to enable Small Icons or Large Icons to get to different parts!). I'm very happy with OS X and I hope for the near future they just work on the occasional bugs and improving hardware performance within it. I will agree that window snapping should be native. Still, the three dots is overall more consistent and visually nicer to me than Windows' min/max/close.
- pfranz 8y agoI think the menu bar at the top served macOS well over the years, but I think menus on the window are a better solution now that multi monitor and high resolution monitors are so common. Having it at the top of your primary monitor just ruins Fitt's law. It may be because of how I use a computer, but I only use Spotlight as an application launcher. Because it's there I will type stuff in the "Search" box in Finder, expecting to filter on the filename of the current folder--instead it it searches "This Mac" and my results are variable names from open source code I've downloaded. Since it also omits results from System files and preferences, like ~/Library, I often use good old locate in a Terminal. Windows Control Panel is an unholy mess. macOS' Preference Pane search, as well as searching for menu items under Help inside any app, is a godsend.
- SentientNo4 8y ago> Because it's there I will type stuff in the "Search" box in Finder, expecting to filter on the filename of the current folder--instead it it searches "This Mac" http://osxdaily.com/2013/03/12/change-finder-search-to-look-in-current-folder-rather-than-everywhere-in-mac-os-x/ http://osxdaily.com/2013/03/12/change-finder-search-to-look-...
- Tsiklon 8y agoA neat function of OS X's menu bar is that all menu bars in other displays are slightly greyed out if it's not got the in focus application displayed. There is a 'Primary Monitor' setting - this determines the window presenting the Dock and can be changed by clicking and dragging the 'menu bar' idiom between windows in the 'Arrangement' tab in the 'Displays' preference pane
- ksec 8y agoI think Apple do plan to rewrite some or large part of macOS. The problem is they surely want to do it in Swift, but Swift is no where near ready or stable enough for that use. Swift 5 were suppose to get ABI stability, may be that will be announced in WWDC.
- pjmlp 8y agoThey already rewrote launchd and the Dock last year.
- wool_gather 8y agoI don't disbelieve you, but do you have a reference for this? `nm /sbin/launchd` doesn't show anything that looks like Swift. Searching ASCII WWDC turns up nothing. All I can find is you saying it a couple of times here on Hacker News. :)
- pjmlp 8y agoWhat is new in Swift, WWDC 2017. Later I can cross-check it.
- wool_gather 8y agoThanks, I'll take a look.
- pjmlp 8y agoSorry it appears to be the wrong one. I will need to track down the talk.
- pjmlp 8y ago> Despite all this, OSX still has a huge foothold as the developer platform of choice In North America yes, in Europe it never really took off outside the first level countries. I only touch Apple devices for iOS development, and they are shared as part of a company pool. And I bet African, Asian and South American developers would share a similar opinion.
- amatheus 8y agoWell, to each their own, the last thing I would want is a rewrite that innovates. You can already get that with Windows or the myriad Linux desktops, and I don't think the result is particularly enticing: having all your things being moved around endlessly as new trends come and go. When Apple decided to innovate in the space, they made iOS. Now you could that's not a desktop OS but the thing is, I don't think they care about this desktop/whatever distinction, these are all computing devices, with different use cases. Meanwhile, Windows, the leader in desktop innovation, tried everything at once, pretending to be a mobile device with full screen windows, then reverting it, removing and adding back the start menu, changing the look and feel to Metro and now Fluent, and even in the technology front there is constant churn. That may be innovative but I definitely don't want to be in the midst of all this innovation in my work computer.