13 ms·
OS X is as old as the classic Mac OS was when it came out
- FPGAhacker 9y agoI see a lot of posts about updating / innovating the OS that mainly have to do with the GUI and app frameworks. Fair enough. Personally, I wish they would just quit innovating for a while and FIX THE DAMN BUGS. I am far more upset by a feature that doesn't work right, than I am an absent feature.
- elcritch 9y agoAgreed on that. A few daily bugs have crept up on my MacBook, nowhere near what I’m getting on KDD/Plasma but not nearly as stable as OS X of the past. Especially data syncing, that kills the battery. I wish they’d drop the whole Swift thing too and work on fixing all the frameworks to make them solid and not splintering the dev communities.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoI agree with this, but also think that OS's largely don't need more features. In fact, they could do with significantly fewer in my opinion. The value of a Desktop OS is that it is a personal tool to manage workflows and acts as a stable platform for developers to target. It should do as close to the bare minimum as it can to make that possible. Give me simple tools, let me put them together in a way that works for what I'm doing. Don't try to make it "easy" by guessing at what my workflow is because you'll be wrong and just get in the way.
- eire1130 9y agoI strongly dislike the mac OS. I only use the system because a.) Duel booting systems are a real pita (oh, let me boost to windows so I can look at that spreadsheet in a excel). And b.) Macs are powerful and light. I spend 1hr plus on the subway, so that's important. If windows had a sensible terminal environment and real package manager and i could use that, great. And not some hacky workaround. And no, powershell is not sensible. I do like mint and ubuntu, but office productivity software is on linux terrible on linux envs imo.
- alsocasey 9y agoPersonally, Bash on Ubuntu on Windows is a fine solution for my most common use cases.
- jgh 9y agoI'm not sure why the article is speculating about a "seismic" change. Apple (and Microsoft and Google have followed) has established a pattern for their OS evolution: yearly incremental updates.
- jedberg 9y agoThey had established that same pattern before too, until they released MacOS X and created a seismic change. What the author is saying is that we should be coming up on a new chip for the Mac pretty soon, and if history is any guide, we may also be upon a brand new OS. That being said, I don't think we'll see seismic shift, unless you count the possible unification of iOS and MacOS a seismic shift.
- drb91 9y ago> we should be coming up on a new chip for the Mac pretty soon, and if history is any guide, we may also be upon a brand new OS. If anything, I would interpret this to mean that a new OS is further off than the chip--the transition from 68k to PPC was not accompanied by a major OS change; that came with OSX several years later. Same with the transition from PPC to x86: snow leopard was notoriously "boring", and we're still on an os distinctly similar to snow leopard. Meanwhile, both iOS and ARM were borne out of necessity. I'm not sure how to figure them into predictions of the future here.
- linguae 9y agoIt's possible for a hypothetical transition from x86 to a new architecture to be accompanied with an OS change. Had Pink/Taligent been completed as originally planned, then the transition from the 68k to the PowerPC would have been accompanied by a transition from System 7 to Pink/Taligent. Part of the reason that IBM got involved with the development of Taligent was the AIM (Apple/IBM/Motorola) alliance, which was formed in 1991 and led to the PowerPC transition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taligent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taligent Unfortunately the development efforts of Taligent failed, which led to the equally-doomed Copland project, which led to Apple's purchase of NeXT. This saga lasted around a decade.
- thecosas 9y agoBefore anyone jumps on this claim, from the article: Now, there are plenty of caveats: There was a Mac OS X public beta. The funeral for Mac OS 9 wasn’t held until 2002. Classic Mode continued to function within Mac OS X until it was removed in Mac OS X 10.5 Leopard.
- itomato 9y agoApple II lived 5966 days, not including the IIe card for LC, which extends the lifespan to 6543 days. Carbon lived until July 24, 2012. Including it as an "LTS" facility, Classic Mac OS lived 10,395 days. By comparison Win NT (if you include Windows 10 as I do) is 9083 days old and counting.
- jedberg 9y agoThe part of this I found most interesting was the link to the funeral for OS 9. I missed that when it actually happened. [0] https://www.macworld.com/article/1001445/06wwdc.html https://www.macworld.com/article/1001445/06wwdc.html
- _bxg1 9y agoI would honestly love to see a ground-up rebuild, but not the kind that would probably happen. OSX is getting creaky; it seems like it's had an increasing number of integral bugs lately, and the "redesign" that came with Yosemite felt more like a rushed coat of paint than a substantial rethink of the UX. Here's what I'd like to see: a fresh desktop OS that actually innovates in the space. Desktop UX innovation has slowed drastically in the smartphone age, and for Apple it's come to a screeching halt (Windows - dare I say - is now the leader in desktop innovation). The fact that OSX is the only modern desktop OS that doesn't have window snapping out of the box is simply shameful. Even Ubuntu has it now, without any Gnome extensions. Despite all this, OSX still has a huge foothold as the developer platform of choice - especially for web - because of its combination of quality hardware, Unix-ness, and relative stability (though all of those are becoming harder and harder points to defend). Apple should take advantage of this and throw power users a bone. We've been waiting for years on end. Stop working on useless things like the Touch Bar and start rethinking what a desktop operating system can be in 2018. Unfortunately, what would probably happen if they built a new desktop OS is iOS with mouse and keyboard support, and developers would leave in droves.
- virmundi 9y agoFix the terrible memory subsystem. There is no need to swap on a 16 GB laptop! Especially when Apple solders the drive to board! That leads to premature ware on the board and me having to spend 600$! My Linux machine is perfectly fine running 2 Eclipse IDEs, 3 docker containers and four Spring Boot Services. No swapping. Since macOS disabled overriding the memory configuration, my laptop swaps merely running Safari ( less than 10 tabs), and VSCode for Cordova all with 16 GB.
- _bxg1 9y agoI've read that there are reasons to use swap other than just as "RAM overflow"
- drb91 9y agoI don't think that the obvious problems with OS X (macOS, whatever) are with the UX, though. Sure, there are problems on that front, but I don't think they're the major pain points people deal with on a daily basis. Meanwhile, user-controllable per-process (or per-app) sandboxing would provide tangible benefit to all of us. This means, easy controls for accessing filesystem, network, cpu, gpu, memory, peripherals, and other processes. Most of these controls exist, but in ways that don't map well to the desktop environment. How do I see what that adobe agent is doing? Sure, I can buy Little Snitch, but this should really be built into the OS. Too much of the UNIX model is designed to secure a user's information from other users, which simply isn't a massive concern these days when we often have dedicated workstations and have issues trusting the processes we run as our own user. What if I suspect my TODO list has a built-in bitcoin miner? I should be able to limit its use of the CPU and GPU. Meanwhile, my editor still needs to read the configs of all my sandboxed apps, and whatever else I want it to access. This isn't necessarily an easy problem, but it's one I have confidence Apple could tackle, especially with mobile paving the way already. All this time, docker has been innovating on the sandboxing, with mostly positive results. Android, I believe, runs each process as its own user, leveraging the existing UNIX controls better. I'm not sure what precisely iOS does, but it's locked down well enough to cause me immense frustration building stuff for my phone--not exactly what I'd like to see on the desktop, but they clearly have the ability to provide many of the controls I am looking for on the desktop. I'm sure this would result in an improved UX as a result, TBH. If not, Google is coming down the road with Fuschia.
- sarreph 9y agoWhat's the sentiment on OS X being rechristened macOS? Doesn't this count as a sort've era 2.5?
- elif 9y agoyea this headline confused me, because 99% of the world still says OSX when they mean MacOS (by Apple definition).
- microtherion 9y agoOS X used to be Mac OS X. Branding does not matter a whole lot for the underlying technology. I feel that there was a pretty big technological change between "Rhapsody" and "Mac OS X", but the other name changes were not accompanied by comparable changes.
- scruffyherder 8y agoThere was a big change between Rhapsody & OS X. The mach part was upgraded from 2.5 to 3.0 and the BSD part was rapidly being update. The other addition was the new driver abstraction library as NeXTSTEP/OPENSTEP on i386 used Objective C, while OS X uses C++. I don't think the code ever really sat that dormant, as they were working on 88000 based machines for the NeXTRISC before that was canceled, and sold off to Cannon who eventually shipped a dual PowerPC 601 machine based on the NeXT design that at the time was to include dual 88010's. There clearly had been some work on PowerPC back when it was first announced as some early code made mention of a MC98601 aka the first gen PowerPC.
- aequitas 9y agoI for one really like this rename for search reasons. Now it is a single unambiguous word: macos. Where before people used the variations: osx, os x, mac os x. Depending on how smart the search engine was you would either get to few or to many results, eg: github issue search. Some search engines even ignore 3 letter words altogether. It will take a while of course for everyone to adopt the new name in their writing.
- originalsimba 9y agoAnd yet somehow Microsoft is still drowning in proprietary hell. Progress in personal computing is not about competition, the way it is in free market capitalism (which is all the MBAs understand). Progress in computing is about brainstorming and evolving the "Best way to do it" and then everyone adopts that until a superior model is discovered. Presently that's POSIX and *nix. It's too bad Microsoft is run by MBAs.
- thought_alarm 9y agoMy first OS X machine was an iBook G4 purchased in 2005. At the time I was rather tickled that, out of the box, it was still able to run (some) 17 year old classic Mac OS software from 1988. Today I have software on my machine that's barely 5 years old and will stop working when 32-bit support is dropped. It will be the largest backward-compatibility purge in Mac history.
- pier25 9y agoI don't care about innovation on macOS. I just want it to be as fast and bug free as possible. I have minor gripes with it, such as new installed apps changing the file icons, but in general most features introduced since Snow Leopard have been mostly noise for me.
- qop 9y agoThat took a moment to parse, but what a neat observation. I've always admired apple from afar. I wish they cared More about lower rung use cases. If apple came out with something to compete with chromebooks, maybe $500-600 range, I'd be the first in those ridiculous lines. Tangent: what's the outlook for swift on the server? Is that work group doing any work lately? Hell I heard swift was investigating memory safety as a future feature, is that still a thing? I think with some of their software talent, swift could really make a strong case for swift>rust in learnability if it could make the same claims about safety and correctness. Why do the coolest things always get so fucked up? The swift website is absolutely littered with old code that doesn't work, or at least it was the last time I bothered to investigate it. They're sitting on such an absurd amount of cash, they oughtta do that Think Different thing and shake the scene up a bit more. The wait-for-google-and-then-fix-whatever-they-fuckup is getting stale. I guess they don't care what I think since I'm not really an apple customer. But still. Oh apple. Someday.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIf apple came out with something to compete with chromebooks, maybe $500-600 range I hope they don't, companies with declining margins look to make it up in other ways that aren't always in the customers interest.
- nkristoffersen 9y agoI think from Apple's perspective the iPad is the $500-$600 Chromebook competitor suitable for everyone. People have different opinions on the actually usefulness but Apple has been pretty clear saying the iPad is 'the future PC'. Regarding swift on server, I think this could be fun. Will try it some day https://vapor.codes/ https://vapor.codes/
- trimbo 9y agoThe NeXTStep years don't count?
- kbob 9y agoNor the CMU Mach years, nor the ancient Unix years?
- trimbo 9y agoHm, well the way I think of it is, MacOS X 1.0 is to NeXTStep as Windows XP is to Windows NT. Both were releases on a decade-plus-old codebase, and had features (Carbon, e.g.) aimed at migrating legacy users from DOS and Mac. IIRC, it did have some differences that made it incompatible with NeXTstep (like DPDF), but I remember getting it and thinking it's basically the same OS with some Mac emulation and a different skin.
- peatmoss 9y agoI played around on a NeXT cube last weekend at the Living Computer Museum and was reminded just how NeXT-like macOS is. I mean, I’ve played with NeXT in the past, and was aware of the continuity since the beginning, but playing with a NeXT in 2018 is uncanny. Of the noticeable UX changes in macOS, I’m not sure how many have been for the better. I’ve long been bummed out that there’s never been an open NeXT clone gain traction. GNUStep, Etoile (built on GNUStep), and Cocotron all tried to recreate the magic, but languished in obscurity. Back when Apple’s fortunes were down, betting on GNUStep would have been a decidedly quirky decision. But having the benefit of hindsight, I am convinced that had GNUStep been ready to ride Apple’s ride back to glory, we’d have a greater Linux user experience today, where popular software was a recompile away from running on both macOS and GNUStep.
- itomato 9y agoApple didn't exactly make it easy with all the changes and replacements to Core libraries. Keeping pace with Apple seems impossible, given the glacial pace of the improvement and development of ProjectCenter and GORM. It's not dead, in any case.
- gnl 9y agoI would love to have some sort of L(onger)TS release. I'm perfectly happy with how my system is set up, everything just works, I don't need new features and I'm dreading the next upgrade forced on me by the loosely defined (or not at all really) and rather short EOL cycles.
- makecheck 9y agoThe core OS needs to improve at a faster rate and OS-specific features need top billing. We tend to see mostly application-level improvements touted as top-10 OS features (enough about Safari and Photos!). Concurrently, the environment provided to developers ranges from stagnating to degrading. The solution to both problems is exactly the same: separate and silo bundled-app development away from the OS and make sure they dogfood the entire process, right down to having to use the EXTERNAL bug reporting system and Apple’s external tools for App Store updates, etc. Then, give the internal app teams at Apple massive superpowers in terms of prioritizing changes to developer tools. Overnight, those ridiculous bugs in Xcode would go away, App Store submissions would be less bureaucratic with superior tools, bugs would be responded to, APIs would be more sensible, etc.