11 ms·
How will the GDPR impact machine learning?
- downandout 8y agoCompanies outside of GDPR-land will have a competitive advantage over those inside of it, especially in the area of machine learning. From the article: "...one of the first major distinctions the GDPR makes about ML models is whether they are being deployed autonomously, without a human directly in the decision-making loop. If the answer is yes—as, in practice, will be the case in a huge number of ML models—then that use is likely prohibited by default." If users explicitly consent to it, then it's permitted under GDPR, but what percentage of users are going to do that? Most will be hitting the "decline" button by default on all websites, even if a given application of ML will be beneficial to them. This is a showstopper for most ML in the EU. If you have an ML startup in the EU....either close up shop or move.
- jcims 8y agoIs it true that users can consent their way into it?
- downandout 8y agoYes, there's an exception in the GDPR for explicit consent to ML: The regulation identifies three areas where the use of autonomous decisions is legal: where the processing is necessary for contractual reasons, where it’s separately authorized by another law, or when the data subject has explicitly consented. But, again, nobody's going to consent - after encountering countless permission popups on websites each and every day, most will just be hitting "decline" without reading what is being asked.
- tombone12 8y agoThat's a novel claim, usually security experts are always complaining that people just click "accept" and ignore all the warnings of broken crypto and all that. How foolish they will feel when they realize that all that was missing was putting "GDPR" in the popup and people will automatically stop ignoring warnings!
- downandout 8y agoThe difference is that before, they had to click accept in order to receive whatever service they were trying to obtain. Now they don't. Also, the sheer number of consent dialogs they will encounter will rise exponentially.
- erichocean 8y ago> The difference is that before, they had to click accept in order to receive whatever service they were trying to obtain. Now they don't. This doesn't receive nearly enough attention.
- zerostar07 8y agoall it takes is a celebrity tweet to tell them to click "decline" and it becomes a meme.
- jarfil 8y agoUsers will still have to consent for ML treatment of their data if they want to use ML based services. Base whatever service you offer around it, and they'll have to either accept or get no service. The only ones losing on this are the intermediaries who up to now could slurp whatever data they wanted and sell it to third parties, while now they'll have to offer something of value to the user or get no data.
- jimnotgym 8y agoIf you are using ML to make automated decisions for say insurance risk then you will have to say so explicitly. There is a pay-off for a customer to agree, and that is convenience. If all insurance companies are doing this then a customer will likely have to consent, or not get a fast insurance decision out of hours that they seem to want. I think the big difference under GDPR is that the user will be able to request that the decision is made by a human, but if this is the case they will not get to set up their insurance at 10PM for tomorrow morning like they can in the automated system. It is completely reasonable that a customer would have to wait a couple of days for this. In practice I wonder if insurance companies (for instance) are actually doing a live ML evaluation on customers, or do they just use ML to develop some 'bandings' that they fit you in to? They could still do this of course, because they can use anonymous data to build a model. I don't see where the competitive advantage you mention lies? Yes a company in the US could use ML on US citizens, but not EU ones. Presumably a company in France could set up a server in AWS US-West region and do ML on US citizens, but not EU citizens? Surely it is a matter of where the data-subject lives, not where the company is based?
- downandout 8y agoI don't see where the competitive advantage you mention lies? Well, if you can't perform ML on data about the population that is most accessible to you, you are at a competitive disadvantage to those who can. I can't think of many EU companies that control large amounts of data on US citizens. Though I'm sure they exist, there are many more US companies that would have larger volumes of data on US citizens.
- jimnotgym 8y agoSo you are arguing that US firms operating in the US are in competition with UK firms operating in the UK? I don't see how they are in competition at all?
- downandout 8y agoHumans are humans, regardless of what country they live in. If I have a larger dataset than you, and I can do more things with it, then I can predict human behavior in a given situation better than you can. That gives me a competitive advantage over you. I may be able to then go compete with you in the EU without ever having to violate the ML provisions of GDPR, because I know what humans - whether in the EU or US - will do. Granted, there are some country-specific behaviors that this will not apply to, but then nobody will be finding out what those are in the EU because it's now illegal to do there.
- tw1010 8y agoIf I ignore GDPR for the next year or so, waiting until this all simmers down to a level of abstraction below the surface level I care about, will I be any worse off?
- jcims 8y agoIn the threads like 'Removing Monal from the EU' [1] most folks say you'll get a warning before any enforcement is done. You could try rolling the dice on that. 1 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17095217 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17095217
- Elidrake24 8y agoDepends on the size of the company you're doing work for, really.
- yulaow 8y agoAlso on the type of data. If you are using super sensitive data (eg health profiles/histories of people) you better not risk because you are gonna get hit hard.
- reilly3000 8y agoI think in the larger cultural context, the public at large is getting more aware of and concerned about data collection. If you don’t have large amounts of PII on EU residents then simmer. If you might, don’t be the one they make an example of.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Maybestring 8y agoIf your company is okay with the ethical/legal reality of breaking the law for a year, why not just keep at it?
- zitterbewegung 8y agoI think that Jacques Mattheij has some thoughts about this that you can think about it in the abstractions that he gives. Note that IANAL and YMMV. EDIT: Also Jacques is not a Lawyer either. 1: https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria https://jacquesmattheij.com/gdpr-hysteria
- zerostar07 8y agoDoes GDPR apply to animals too? I mean if its going to be hard to manage human data, perhaps replacing some with monkeys would be OK.
- tombone12 8y agoGDPR applies to "natural persons", which I think mostly excludes animals (I base this on us killing animals all the time and it doesn't count as murder).
- narrator 8y agoChina is not going to care. Their complete obliviousness to privacy has made a lot of their machine learning projects move ahead at a breathtaking pace. I was at a presentation by a Chinese surveillance camera company last year and the amount of automated behaviors they can recognize that allow automatic crime detection, etc. is astounding! All the data processing will probably end up running through China as Chinese courts will ignore any GDPR violation fines for local companies, etc.
- tombone12 8y agoIf EU citizens go to the Chinese to give up their rights they are probably giving their consent, but good luck providing any sort of service to EU citizens without actually having a legal presence inside the union.
- narrator 8y agoThe API call that analyzes what's going on in an image will get sent to China and analyzed there by no-name state owned mega surveillance corp and the result sent back like "35/m/$50k income/55% criminality likelihood/60% likely homosexual/Woman standing next to him is 35% likely to be mistress/subject is currently engaged in 30% flirting behavior 20% shopping for clothes/Target with ad for greek vacation/" and they'll all say it's just a model. Pinky swear there's no personal data that was used to look that up in China.
- henrikschroder 8y agoIt doesn't matter if that lookup is done in China or in the EU or elsewhere. To be compliant a company has to be able to list all third parties that get access to personal data it collects, and what they in turn do with it and further third parties that get access to it. If a company uses a Chinese mega surveillance corp API, they still have to disclose it, and they can't just hide behind a "the computer says no" response if they use the results of that API call to make a business decision. The GDPR gives the data subject the right to know why and how the business decision was made, and gives the subject the right to appeal.
- gerdesj 8y agoWell, you have to hand it to the EU (Brit here): privacy has been legislated for in a way that is absolutely breathtaking. The GDPR is the first decent effort to curb the dreadful abuse of privacy that many massive multi nationals see as their right (omm nom nom data). I am extremely proud to be associated with the GDPR (I'm still a European for now). It is an absolute belter of a set of regulations. If you read it, it is actually pretty concise for a legal thingie. It is also very prescriptive which is pretty odd for a legal thingie. It is up there with the "quietly enjoy your own property" basic right that is sort of enshrined in English Law nowadays (IANAL but a search would tell you what I'm on about). If complying with GDPR is considered a problem then good luck with monetising that weakness.
- cutler 8y agoPity the biggest abusers of our privacy - credit reference agencies - will slip through the net. How this racket can be classified as legitimate interest is beyond me.
- jimnotgym 8y agoLegitimate interest or not, if a UK based credit reference agency loses data in the same way that Equifax, for instance, did I think they will find GDPR has the teeth to deal with them.
- biztos 8y agoBut wouldn't "deal with them" basically mean work with them and give them a lot of help and support while they try to reform their practices and prevent a recurrence, because of course they will demonstrate that none of their screwup was willful?
- cutler 8y agoIt's not breaches that worry me, it's their right to exist in the first place. Credit reference agencies put Facebook in the shade when it comes to abuse of privacy and acting as a law unto themselves.
- 8y ago
- outside2344 8y agoI can't wait to issue denial of service requests to every EU company when it comes into effect. I am going to send a nightmare letter to all of them.
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoIs it possible to cover GDPR requirements with another line in an EULA that specifies consent?
- tombone12 8y agoNo, you have to ask and receive consent explicitly for the processing you want to do, not as part of some larger package.
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoa modal pop-up dialog asking for consent will be required?
- erichocean 8y agoyes, that's the intent of the law
- andrenotgiant 8y agoI want to live in a world where the individual has control over their data, but I don't think GDPR will help create that world. Imagine you are a company that makes $500k+/year off of user data. You are not just going to stop doing it because of GDPR, you are going to spend up to $500k on lawyers figuring out how to get around it.
- gkya 8y agoThat world will come around when a majority of people will understand that running untrusted code on your computer is just madness (i.e. JavaScript). I wish some mainstream browser like Firefox created an easy UI for JS whitelists, and/or a dialog box asking consent for JS execution per FQDN, like it does for location etc. Among the big players, only Google has major reasons to not do such a thing, but FF, IE and Safari can try.