3 ms·
you have to be careful, many experimentally verified observations could have been called quackery, too (an electric current has an effect on a magnet only if it
by dnautics 8y ago
you have to be careful, many experimentally verified observations could have been called quackery, too (an electric current has an effect on a magnet only if it's out of the plane of the magnet? QUACKERY!) If you go to biology and biochemistry, there's plenty of things that still have zero (or very tenuous) basis in underlying theory that are observationally verified (lots of sweet-tasting compounds, basically all anaesthetics, tylenol, e.g.)
- varjag 8y agoActually no you don't have to, if the claim breaks some fundamental property like conservation of energy or momentum. Tremendous skepticism is most warranted.
- dnautics 8y agoAtomic fission breaks the 'fundamental property' of 'conservation of energy', hence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_binding_energy#Mass_defect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_binding_energy#Mass_de... and E = mc^2
- magicalhippo 8y agoThe energy released was put into the atom when it was created through fusion.
- Turing_Machine 8y agoOf course, but acknowledging that required that the supposedly immutable "laws of physics" be rewritten.
- magicalhippo 8y agoThat makes no sense to me. Which laws rewritten how?
- Turing_Machine 8y agoIt used to be called the "Law of Conservation of Mass". Now it's called the "Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy".
- ben_w 8y agoExcept it happened the other way around: E=mc^2 was 1905, people only had the means to test for that mass difference after the discovery of the neutron in 1932. They hypothesised earlier than that, of course, but the experiments followed updated laws nearly 30 years after the new laws had become necessary because of lots of previous experiments showing Newtonian physics was wrong. And sure, GR will be replaced with something else (it predicts but cannot fully describe black hole interiors), but… …but expecting that upgrade, whatever it might be, to have the ability to defy known conservation laws in a measurable way in a device made of quarks and electrons, is akin to thinking one possible refinement to the shape of the Earth (curved, sphere, oblate spheroid, …) is the existence of a 29 mile long tunnel connecting Hawaii to Moscow. Any new physics will almost certainly involve things we can only just build at this point, not stuff like the EM drive which we could’ve built by accident from WW2 onwards.
- mulmen 8y agoWhat's your definition of quackery? I have always thought of it as a claim in the absence of experimental evidence.
- dnautics 8y agothe em drive had experimental evidence, albeit very tenuous/questionable. Large amounts of skepticism were warranted, but IMO the real world rightly demanded further investigation because that decision should be based on "expected yield" - think "how likely do we think it's real" * "how awesome would it be if it's true".
- roywiggins 8y ago"I have developed a device that creates a pocket universe with TREE(3) conscious beings living productive, happy lives, and we can go talk to them!" This is very unlikely, but is it so unlikely that multiplying the awesomeness (which is beyond astronomical) that the expected yield isn't also too large not to take it seriously? Or do you have to just round down to zero likelihood at some point.
- mojomark 8y agoThe underlying principles of the EM druve are very straight forward, easy to understand, and don't violate any laws of physics. The momentum and energy of photons emitted from the antenna (or any antenna) do not exert a reverse force on the antenna or EM drive. All that's occuring is orbial ANGULAR momentum/energy are transferring from the excited atoms in the antenna into generated photons. The exited atom lose energy/momentum as they release photons, the photons ofcourse gain energy/momentum and ultimately transfer it again to a surface on the drive. Photons are not classical and do not "launch" themselves of of an emission surface. (see more detailed response below) No mystery, no quackery, just basic physics.