5 ms·
A smartphone isn't an activity; it's a virtual place where activities happen. Kids (and, apparently, opinion-piece writers) don't usually understand this. "My
by derefr 8y ago
A smartphone isn't an activity; it's a virtual place where activities happen. Kids (and, apparently, opinion-piece writers) don't usually understand this.
"My mom is on her phone too much!" could actually mean any/all of:
• my mom is a workaholic
• my mom is always chatting with her friends she had to move away from to give me a better place to live
• my mom is flirting on Tinder with my stepfather-to-be
• my mom is tired from work and zones out watching Youtube videos
• my mom is "addicted" to knowing what celebrities are up to so she has water-cooler conversation to share
• my mom is in a self-perpetuating fear spiral, feeding herself every horrible news story she can find even though she hates the feeling of reading them, and should probably see a therapist
• my mom is addicted to showing off on Facebook
• my mom likes reading books
Every one of these activities existed before smartphones; they just occurred in different places/formats.
You'd buy tabloids for the celebrity news; you'd watch the nightly news on cable; you'd flirt in bars; you'd travel to visit friends, or have long, nightly telephone calls with them; and you'd keep up with the real Joneses next-door instead of keeping up with the virtual Joneses on Facebook. And you'd be a workaholic by always being at the office, rather than by being home but inattentive.
- Tepix 8y agoPeople are addicted to their phones. It's a fact. Many apps are designed to be addictive, which doesn't help.
- vis52 8y agoWhat Sean Parker says about the whole thing: He explained that when Facebook was being developed the objective was: “How do we consume as much of your time and conscious attention as possible?” It was this mindset that led to the creation of features such as the “like” button that would give users “a little dopamine hit” to encourage them to upload more content. “It’s a social-validation feedback loop … exactly the kind of thing that a hacker like myself would come up with, because you’re exploiting a vulnerability in human psychology.”
- Apocryphon 8y ago"We lived on farms, then we lived in cities, and now we're going to live on the internet." - Justin Timberlake
- scintill76 8y agoI'm nitpicking a bit, but unless you know that was actually written by JT, I think you should attribute it to The Social Network movie, not to JT.
- netsharc 8y agoPeople attribute the "I don't know who you are. I don't know what you want..." line from "Taken" to Liam Neeson. I'm sorry, but it's a character played by Liam Neeson who said that! Seems reality and fiction is getting more and more mixed up... especially if you have Ted or Deadpool showing up to talk shows (then again, this isn't a new thing is it, Bugs Bunny showed up on a talk show in the 1990's).
- Apocryphon 8y agoI just thought it would be funny to put Timberlake on the quote since Sean Parker never said it and it's less fun to credit Sorkin.
- derefr 8y ago> It's a fact. You can do a study that proves that someone is "addicted to their phone" just like you can do a study that proves that someone is "addicted to using their car." That doesn't say much about why, so it's kind of a useless "fact." Theoretically, you can be addicted to the process of using your phone, just like you can be addicted to driving, but I kind of doubt that that's what's driving the majority of what people refer to as "smartphone addiction." More likely, they're addicted to specific activities that happen to exist on phones. Remove the phone, and they'd still be addicted to those activities; they'd just be doing them somehow else. Escapists gonna escape; socializers gonna socialize; etc. Facebook or Instagram might be a superstimulus for pulling in a particular kind of competitive narcissists, but I have no doubt that such people would still be trying to show off how great their lives whether the apps were there or not. They just might not feel as much of a reward for doing so—because fewer people would be paying attention—so they might feel a sense of ennui (from this drive of theirs going unfulfilled), rather than a sense of dependence (from it going intermittently fulfilled.)
- mediaman 8y agoThe phone has a transformational effect on those activities. By modifying the pursuit of that activity in a number of ways, the activities become more addictive. It is more frictionless to begin them, reward is provided more instantly, and new ways to gamify the activity increase the dopamine response. To say it is not the phone is true, in the sense that the phone on its own is not terribly addictive solely as a physical object. But the distinction is somewhat pointless when it has a large "addictiveness coefficient" to other activities.
- derefr 8y agoA smartphone might well be a multiplier for addictive activities, but treating it as the object-of-hatred carries a risk of throwing the baby out with the bath-water. Hate Facebook, if you like. Hate news services with apps. Hate the addictive ecosystems. But hating the phone means biasing yourself even against phones with no addictive apps installed on them. It means fomenting a movement to get away from "smarts" in phones altogether, resulting in things like https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/3/1/17066494/light-phone-2-ultra-minimalist-cellphone-indiegogo-crowdfunding https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/3/1/17066494/li.... "Dumb smartphones" are a cute idea, but also a reactionary one; rather than just curating an apps marketplace to disallow these addictive activities, they entirely preclude this thing in your pocket from being a portable Turing machine, capable of achieving whatever functionalities you might want/need it to. Consider an alternate world to our own, where we had had an established+successful smartphone-luddist movement for the last 5-10 years, most phones looked like the Light Phone, and you'd be breaking social norms to have a "full-fat" smartphone. Would these exist? • ride-sharing apps • WordLens (and its incarnation in Google Translate) • password managers and TOTP 2FA (and mobile cryptocurrency wallets, if you like) • podcasts • maps with buildings and travel-times on them, and solid public-transit routing models • competent voice-recognition (and thus the leaps-and-bounds-better accessibility for blind users we have today) • the eBook ecosystem • DSLR-quality phone cameras • VoIP apps (and thus, the commoditization of cellular providers) • streaming video-service mobile apps (and thus, demand for 4G cellular infrastructure) All of these things are—at least in my opinion—unalloyed goods. None of them are addictive (or are addictive only to the background level of addiction we've already culturally come to terms with in entertainment products); they're just things that allow your smartphone to be the solution to a problem you've already set out to solve. But, if we spin smartphones themselves as a cultural net-negative, I don't expect we'll see many more of these utility-type innovations.
- socialist_coder 8y agoI think you're missing the point here. There are many times when a parent should be giving their attention to their child, but they aren't because their attention is on their phone. The specific activity they're doing on their phone doesn't matter. Before, you could still do these activities instead of focusing on your child, but the way that manifested itself was completely different. A parent going to the bar after work is different than a parent being at home but ignoring their child because they would rather look at their phone. In the first case, there is a clear line between when the parent is at home and when the parent is at the bar. And, it is fairly obvious if the parent is spending too much time at the bar and not enough time at home. In the smartphone situation, the parent can now be on their phone literally 100% of the time they're at home. The child has no idea if their parent is ready to focus on them, or is going to be distracted by the phone. And, it's not obvious at all if the parent is spending too much time on the phone. Therefore, from the perspective of the child, replacing the old activities with a smartphone activity is much much worse.
- derefr 8y agoI don't see how the focus on "the way that manifested itself" is at all relevant. My point is: bad parenting is bad parenting. As far as I know, smartphones haven't created bad parenting, or other social ills. They've just made it less legible, because now both the healthy activities and the unhealthy ones just look like "using your phone" to external observers. If the point is to figure out whether someone is a good parent, measuring "time spent on smartphone" will give completely useless answers, and so judging a parent for spending a lot of time on their smartphone at home is simply wrongheaded. You have to ignore the phone (the medium), and look at what they're actually doing (the activity.) Fun fact: some parents do much of their communication with their children through their phone. Non-deaf parents of deaf children will often text more than they sign.
- dasil003 8y agoIt's relevant in the sense that smart phones enable bad parenting on an unprecedented level.
- benatkin 8y agoThat's a very good way of putting it. It makes going to one of these places instantly possible. Or, if you like, escaping to one of these places.
- trhway 8y ago>You'd buy tabloids for the celebrity news; you'd watch the nightly news on cable; you'd flirt in bars; you'd travel to visit friends, or have long, nightly telephone calls with them; and you'd keep up with the real Joneses next-door instead of keeping up with the virtual Joneses on Facebook. And you'd be a workaholic by always being at the office, rather than by being home but inattentive. all those have significant higher friction and time/effort required than smartphone based equivalent. Instant gratification is extremely important factor in the enforcement of addiction. It is like gambling addiction by playing weekly state lottery vs. playing slot machine or roulette in casino.
- rdiddly 8y agoThe difference is that before, you would've been called out as some species of asshole if you suddenly wandered out of, let's say a conversation, to go do one of those things. But for some reason people seem to think the phone endows them with the ability to do two things at once. Sure, the phone does its thing, but your own powers haven't increased even slightly. If people could see themselves from outside, they'd see just how good at multi-tasking they are. Namely they'd watch themselves doing a whole host of things absently and shittily... including but not limited to parenting. One thing at a time is plenty if you've a mind toward mastering that moment and living it. PS I don't believe any of the people quoted saying "Wow really opens your eyes huh, a lesson for us all" are going to change one iota!
- derefr 8y agoNow this is a salient point, I think. We train ourselves to whip out our phones when there's even a minute of "unusable" time. We use our phones while waiting in line, while on the bus, while on the toilet, etc. We condition ourselves that you respond to being a little bit bored by pulling out your phone. And so, if you're a little bit bored while talking to someone? Oops, you've just pulled out your phone. I do that. I catch myself doing it, though, and sheepishly put it away, pretending I was just checking the time. It requires a bit of self-awareness, though, and that decreases when people are tired and under stress. I would expect that people who would previously just be "zoning out" are now "phoning out." (On the other hand, you know what seems to be a novel piece of social etiquette that I entirely approve of? People whipping out their phones while eating. Not while waiting for their food—while actually putting the food in their mouths. There's seemingly no longer a social norm about "not talking with your mouth full", so people try to carry on a conversation while also getting food stuffed into their food-holes, and neither one goes as well. Presenting yourself as slightly distracted [by, say, an "interesting" article on your phone] decreases the social pressure on everyone else to talk. It's a social-engineering "hack", that seems to be rapidly approaching an established convention.)
- everdrive 8y agoI appreciate the point you're making, but the truth is probably closer to "my mom likes some portion of the activities above, but is addicted to switching between them, getting notifications, and she doesn't known how to moderate her behavior."
- jdietrich 8y agoAs technologists, we have to acknowledge responsibility for the effects our inventions have on society. We wield an immensely powerful set of tools with a uniquely broad reach. We have a duty to build a better world, rather than just chasing engagement metrics. We can only deal with that responsibility if we think deeply about the human instincts, urges and needs that our technology interacts with. We need to reflect on the strengths and vulnerabilities of the mammalian brain. We cannot be glib or facile, we cannot just say "put your phone down", we cannot just blame the users or a handful of huge multinationals. We need to ask ourselves honestly whether we are making salad or junk food, whether we are making medicine or cigarettes. We need to ask that question often - when we are planning an MVP, when we are adding a feature, when we are gamifying a metric. Is this function call exploitative? Does this for loop enrich the world?