4 ms·
It's so unproductive the way we make "personal responsibility" vs "victimhood" a binary choice. You can either be a conservative, and be disallowed from ever su
by _bxg1 8y ago
It's so unproductive the way we make "personal responsibility" vs "victimhood" a binary choice. You can either be a conservative, and be disallowed from ever suggesting that something about your circumstances might be the slightest bit unfair, or you can be a liberal, and be disallowed from ever suggesting that anyone should try and take responsibility for their lives.
Everyone should try to be personally responsible to the best of their capacity. And sometimes, systems really are unfair and really need to be changed. It's not just one or the other.
Tribalism applied to worldview is the greatest casualty of the American political sphere.
- LyndsySimon 8y agoIt may be unproductive - and for what it's worth, I agree - but it also highlights a core difference of ideology. Call it individualism versus collectivism, personal responsibility versus victimhood, or whatever else you want to apply to it; the fact remains that conservatives virtue signal by claiming responsibility while liberals virtue signal by assigning victimhood, regardless of whether either of those things are strictly true.
- _bxg1 8y agoThe point is that all of those versus-es you listed are a) spectrums, and b) situational. The latter is more relevant, I think. Always picking personal responsibility or always picking victimhood because "that's your ideology" is like always using a hammer or always using a screwdriver because "that's your tool".
- yayadarsh 8y ago100% agree. This type of dualistic thinking is one of the reasons common political discourse in the US is so unproductive. There are (almost) no simple black/white answers to anything, and the devil is usually in the (grey) details.