3 ms·
This reasoning sounds silly. There are plenty of people who don't remember much of anything from geography, history, spelling, geometry, algebra, etc, either, s
by majormajor 8y ago
This reasoning sounds silly. There are plenty of people who don't remember much of anything from geography, history, spelling, geometry, algebra, etc, either, so should we simply get rid of 90% of school?
Or is there a purpose served by this stuff even if it doesn't lead to long-term recall?
For instance, exposure to a broad range of things so you can find your interests and speak more intelligently about at least some of them, in the future (even if that just means remembering what to look up that you realize you forgot). Or just learning how to study various different types of things in the first place, so that when you do need to get serious about something, you aren't hopeless.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoThe person being quoted (Bryan Caplan) does actually make similar claims to what you're saying. His claim is that most people use very little of what they learn in school and that the main thing that school does is show you're smart because you were able to graduate. So instead of making kids waste time learning stuff they're just going to forget (or never really learn as in the case of foreign languages), we should strip down the school curriculum and only teach them things relevant to their future life.
- majormajor 8y agoI think that learning to study stuff - especially when it's not obviously relevant or interesting at first - is incredibly relevant to later in life. I also don't think we'd be great at predicting the 10% that's "most relevant" for any given person. It's like the "reinventing Excel" problem - everyone only uses 10%, but everyone uses a different 10%. I think we should try to shorten the school curriculum - give some more purpose to people's ages 15-20 years, instead of filling it up with busywork while they're at their most restless and energetic - but not reduce it's breadth at all. Cramming extracurriculurs into every hour of the day to fill up time to tick boxes for a college application is a much bigger problem than foreign language classes, in my mind.