4 ms·
Officially? The state is always right. In private? I think the government's ever tightening grip is going to explode in their face eventually.
by jandrese 8y ago
Officially? The state is always right.
In private? I think the government's ever tightening grip is going to explode in their face eventually.
- TrainedMonkey 8y agoOr the power of technology will enable them to repeat the message until public believes it. If you repeat something enough people start believing it. Fun exercise, check out persuasive techniques below and count how many of those China (and other governments) are employing en masse. https://www.mindmeister.com/213923097/persuasive-techniques-and-their-examples https://www.mindmeister.com/213923097/persuasive-techniques-...
- jerf 8y agoThe inability to instill belief is not the problem... the ability to instill belief is the problem. You instill belief in the place of social feedback, which breaks people's ability to react to the feedback the system is yielding, like "that's too much money being spent here" and "that's not enough money spent there" and "it turns out that while everyone believes everyone believes that the right answer is X, that in fact nobody believes it" and just an uncountable list of other adjustments societies have to make in order to survive. In a hypothetical world where humans were not subject to social pressure and the corresponding ability of social systems to produce situations where privately everybody knows a thing but nobody is publicly allowed to acknowledge it... well... that's effectively a world on the other side of a singularity from us. Presumably it would have its own pathologies, greater ones for all I know. But it would not have this problem of entire societies riding off the rails because it applied ever stronger powers of social coercion to prevent the society from correctly (without reference to any particular definition of "correct") reacting to the changes that occur over time. It would have to come up with its own new pathologies. This scenario doesn't fail when everybody stops believing in it; it fails, and then everybody stops believing in it. (Peer pressure in the modern world is dangerous, and merely "being pressured to do drugs" is a fairly innocent instance of it, because that only does local harm. When you find yourself unable to speak out about your own beliefs to your own neighbors and friends because of the social costs, it's not just a problem for you, it's a problem for your society.)
- stcredzero 8y agoThis scenario doesn't fail when everybody stops believing in it; it fails, and then everybody stops believing in it. The 21st century 1st world aspirant intelligentsia is in this situation right now. When you find yourself unable to speak out about your own beliefs to your own neighbors and friends because of the social costs, it's not just a problem for you, it's a problem for your society. My "tribe" is trapped in such a bubble. It's intellectually doomed.
- leephillips 8y agoCan you give an example of a belief or opinion that you feel unable to express to other members of your tribe?
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoNot the OP, so I'm not claiming to speak for him, but here are some views I've seen really upset left-leaning people despite having a fair amount of evidence to support them: heterosexual two-parent households are best for raising children, rape is less common now than in the past, unrestricted immigration hurts low-skill workers. I'm not necessarily saying these are all true, but they're at least open for debate, and you will lose friends in some parts of the US for voicing these opinions.
- stcredzero 8y ago1) Many actions of Antifa are immoral, authoritarian, and bad for society. I can write this here on HN, but I've encountered what can only be described as toxicity on other social media and in person. (The most extreme example of this would be someone responding to a wedding invite by calling me a racist.) 2) Homo sapiens is a sexually dimorphic species, which results in some biologically driven differences on average between men and women. Again, I can write this here on HN, but I've encountered what can only be described as extreme toxicity on other social media and in person.
- clairity 8y ago
- stcredzero 8y agoOr the power of technology will enable them to repeat the message until public believes it. If you repeat something enough people start believing it. Fun exercise, check out persuasive techniques below and count This has been true of media since the beginning. It's certainly at play in social media today. It has been glaringly true of print and television media for decades. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoThat is essentially what led to the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Although China's economy functions better and conditions seem to be improving for the average Chinese person, so it's hard to say how it'll play out. Also the Tiananmen Square protests happened 30 years ago and the same government is still in power. So I think chances are good that they'll be able to hold onto power for the foreseeable future. As long as they continue to do well economically at least.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> China's economy functions better China's economy developed under a multi-person single-party system. That has devolved into a dictatorship. I would be cautious about using the last thirty years as a baseline for the next fifty. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deng_Xiaoping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deng_Xiaoping
- kika 8y ago> That is essentially what led to the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Care to elaborate? (full disclosure: I was born and raised in SU and lived in it for 20 years of my life and then another 20 in Russia after the fall). My family were "dissidents", we were under almost constant surveillance since at least 1980 (when I went to the 5th grade) and I can tell that the grip weakened every year until Andropov, who tried to hysterically tighten it, but it didn't work already. In my simplified opinion, it was just the oil price that killed the Soviet Union. It went from $120 in 1980 to $23 in 1986. Soviet Union as any sufficiently developed socialist economy became more and more dependent on the external supply of goods for which it had to get some hard currency. It basically just run out of money and went bankrupt.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoMy understanding is that people within the Soviet Union (including within the Communist Party) saw that conditions in the West were better and became disillusioned with the Soviet system, which enabled Gorbachev to make his reforms. But I wasn't there and only know what I've read so you're probably right that the economy had a larger role than I'm giving it credit for.