3 ms·
Can I revoke that consent after I gave it as easily as I made it? It seems not, this would be a violation next week. Article 7, part 3.4 "It shall be as easy to
by PeterisP 8y ago
Can I revoke that consent after I gave it as easily as I made it? It seems not, this would be a violation next week. Article 7, part 3.4 "It shall be as easy to withdraw as to give consent." is as literally clear as it can get - not possible to withdraw consent, not easy to withdraw consent, but as easy. Counting clicks required and the size of font used for links are likely to be used as criteria.
Their current privacy policy and cookie policy linked there doesn't mention how can I withdraw this consent, so it violates the information requirement of Article 12. It does mention that browsers can be used to block cookies (which violates the "as easy" part) but says nothing about the ".. and other tracking technologies." sentence of their "consent" window.
Futhermore, a popup window that occupies half of my phone's screen is intrusive. It's not sufficient to, as you say, "You can still use the core functionality of the site without accepting" - Recital 32 (https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-32/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-32/) states "the request must be clear, concise and not unnecessarily disruptive to the use of the service for which it is provided.", so it seems that this request may violate the requirements.
- simonbarker87 8y agoTo be fair I am yet to see any implementation of giving consent that enables people to revoke it as easily. There should be a link in the privacy policy that revoked access with a click for whatever tracking platform the site is using, without having another bar that hovers all the time with those links in I doubt you will find easier than that.
- PeterisP 8y agoThis is generally not a problem for any genuinely opt-in features - I went to a particular place to opt-in because I wanted to, and I can go to the same place to opt-out afterwards. It's a bit different in situations where I don't really want it but the service provider does; but these are the intended target of this legislation. One could argue that this is a useful criteria for UI evaluation - if the site feels that it's unreasonable to dangle a banner "Opt-out of tracking NOW!!!" to everyone forever, then perhaps it should be considered exactly just as unreasonable to dangle an identical banner "Opt-in to tracking NOW!!!" in front of everybody until they accept. If you don't want to do the opt-out banner, then you could be forbidden to show the opt-in banner. So even a very literal interpretation of this may make some sense.