3 ms·
California high-speed rail has not exploded 5x. When originally approved in 2008 the estimate was $40 billion.[1] The 2018 estimate for both phases is, I think
by wahern 8y ago
California high-speed rail has not exploded 5x.
When originally approved in 2008 the estimate was $40 billion.[1] The 2018 estimate for both phases is, I think, roughly $100 - $120 billion (low and high).[2] That's 2.5x - 3x.[3] These numbers are actually in line with opposition figures[4], and for other reasons it's reasonable to expect these are solid upper limits unless people continue to sabotage the project.
It's also worth pointing out that $120 billion is still significantly less than estimated costs for the alternative of expanding the highways and airports--$156-186 billion.[5] Note that those alternative costs are likely optimistic like the original HSR costs, particularly airport expansion and urban highway expansion.
One of the biggest reasons for the cost inflation is the political opposition. Some of the construction contracts have actually come in significantly under budget.[6] The real killer so far is land acquisition.[7] The authority is effectively trying to bribe farmers with huge payouts (clearly beyond market prices) in order to mitigate political pressure in Sacramento. All the political and legal fighting causes expensive delays. (Time is very costly in construction because there are fixed costs in keeping labor and equipment mobilized, plus huge costs in having to re-orchestrate schedules. Lots of interdependent moving parts.) But political pressure wouldn't be so strong if discourse was more honest and less tribal.
The opposition is creating a self-fulfilling prophecy, particularly with the hyperbole and sabotage. By all means fight for transparency, but civic responsibility means we all need to check ourselves.
[1] https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php/California_Proposition_1A,_High-Speed_Rail_Act_%282008%29 https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php/California_Propositio...
[2] https://sf.curbed.com/2018/1/29/16946576/san-jose-mercury-high-speed-rail-budget https://sf.curbed.com/2018/1/29/16946576/san-jose-mercury-hi... and http://www.hsr.ca.gov/docs/about/business_plans/Draft_2018_Business_Plan.pdf http://www.hsr.ca.gov/docs/about/business_plans/Draft_2018_B...
[3] I think both numbers are year-of-expenditure, which means each sub-project is separately inflation adjusted to the midpoint year of scheduled construction.
[4] https://reason.org/wp-content/uploads/files/california_high_speed_rail_report.pdf https://reason.org/wp-content/uploads/files/california_high_...
[5] http://www.hsr.ca.gov/docs/about/business_plans/BPlan_2012CompareEquivalentCapacity.pdf http://www.hsr.ca.gov/docs/about/business_plans/BPlan_2012Co...
[6] http://www.cahsrblog.com/2013/04/chsra-selects-tutor-perini-zachry-parsons-bid-for-central-valley-section/ http://www.cahsrblog.com/2013/04/chsra-selects-tutor-perini-...
[7] https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/01/17/worst-case-scenario-high-speed-rail-costs-jump-2-8-billion-to-10-6-billion/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/01/17/worst-case-scenario-h...