4 ms·
I don't know why you got downvoted. I've toyed with the idea of doing a popular subway improvement project where we'd make battery-powered devices (arduino, rp
by cryptonector 8y ago
I don't know why you got downvoted.
I've toyed with the idea of doing a popular subway improvement project where we'd make battery-powered devices (arduino, rpi, whatever -- the biggest cost irl would be labor) to plant on subway cars and stations for tracking trains. A proof of concept could be done with just a few tens of such devices. They'd use the subway wifi to transmit train locations.
Of course, there are complications. There's no such thing as a head train car -- these things get mixed and matched. So ensuring that every train has such a device might mean ensuring that every car has one or that every train gets a car that has one, and this seems difficult. But even so, this could cost just in the millions done right.
- stephen_g 8y agoObviously the price tag for the NY system is crazy, but honestly so is what you guys are proposing... It's almost completely impossible to certify a safety critical system with WiFi and Arduino/RPi. This kind of engineering is a whole different ball game, and for good reason (train crashes and derailments are really not pretty). For an informational system (i.e. telling passengers how long trains are away or for statistics gathering), sure. You could absolutely do that like you say. But as soon as it involves controlling the train or anything to do with signalling, it just can't be done like that.