5 ms·
Why is everyone so against this? These types of laws tend to be worthless, except in one thing: Preserving incumbents (large banks in this case). Large banks c
by ars 8y ago
Why is everyone so against this? These types of laws tend to be worthless, except in one thing: Preserving incumbents (large banks in this case).
Large banks can easily deal with the law and keep right on going. All it does is make life much harder for smaller banks.
- nielsbot 8y agoMy vague understanding was that Dodd-Frank was a partial restoration of the pre-Clinton era limits on speculation... Is that not correct? In any case I don't understand how that helps preserve incumbents over small banks.
- ars 8y agoIt does a LOT of stuff. Some good, some just paperwork. It's the paperwork part I'm talking about. But it's such a large act that without knowing which parts were repealed it's very hard to discuss.
- mtgx 8y agoYes, this. Perhaps some of the Dodd-Frank reversal will indeed be good for smaller banks, but my guess without reading the bill is that they also removed a lot of the stuff that only affected the big banks or simply regulated the worst behavior that banks can have, like say over-charging customers on fees and stuff like that.
- lallysingh 8y agoJust a note: paperwork is usually just data on disk now. Maybe a database or 10, or just a bunch of logs. But generally not as bureaucratically onerous as one envisions a ton of actual paperwork. A virtual paper trail isn't a bad thing when you've got to (a) manage risks based on decisions made by these processes and (b) make sure you're obeying the law.
- pzone 8y agoNo, Dodd-Frank is in fact bureaucratically onerous. The cost of paperwork has nothing to do with whether or not the documents are actually on paper.
- klipt 8y agoData science is hard and requires lots of data. It's still useful to have that data.
- simonh 8y agoDodd-Frank is hugely costly. The Government Accountability Office estimates the total cost of the banks to reach compliance at almost $3bn over 5 years.
- Jweb_Guru 8y agoRemind me again what net profit the banking sector had during the same five year period? I know last year alone it was over $48 billion.
- simonh 8y agoAm I surprised that the banks protected from competition by the moat created by Dodd-Frank regulations are highly profitable?
- nielsbot 8y agoare the costs more onerous for smaller banks or are they proportional to bank size?
- haneefmubarak 8y agoI imagine the costs can be somewhat seen along the lines of good old `y = ax + b`, where the coefficient `a` (variable cost) is more or less doable but the term `b` (fixed cost) is high enough that it turns into a non-starter for smaller banks.
- everdev 8y ago> All it does is make life much harder for smaller banks. I don't think that's all it does. That's certainly one polarized way to look at it though. I think the idea is that speculative lending is a race to the bottom that hurts everyone in the long run (banks and consumers), but it's profitable in the short-term. Instead of another boom/bust and repeating 2008, we try to have banks lend responsibly. That does potentially slow economic growth although some would argue it would go to realistic rather than artificial levels. Wether the restrictions on the banks outweigh the protection for consumers is typically the debate.
- Shivetya 8y agoSadly because HN suffers from way too many posters who are irrational when politics intrudes in the discussion. they just stop thinking and off the rails. just reading some of the comments for this story disappoint me to the point I flagged the article because its embarrassing.
- jjoonathan 8y agoFlagging people you disagree with does not further the discussion.