4 ms·
Fta: Signal system? In 2018 why is the conductor doing anything but pressing a "leave station" button? Who is driving the requirements for this?
by exabrial 8y ago
Fta: Signal system? In 2018 why is the conductor doing anything but pressing a "leave station" button? Who is driving the requirements for this?
- hak8or 8y agoMTA union, it's an extremely powerful union. The L line for example is set up to be fully automated, but they are still required to have staff for the train.
- danharaj 8y agoConsidering what odd ball things happen on our trains, I'm glad they're around.
- untog 8y agoThe unions aren't the main reason, it's that the signal system in the NYC subway is decades old and won't allow automated trains. It needs to be upgraded, but that costs money that so far no one has been willing to spend. From what I understand, the L train is one of few that has the necessary upgrades, primarily because it doesn't really intersect with other lines, which makes it a lot easier to deploy. If I recall, the L functions with only one conductor when the other lines use two. I agree that the union could be more progressive and embrace change... but the big problem is money, and consequently, state politics.
- InitialLastName 8y agoThe L would function with no conductors, but it requires two per train to press a "keep the union happy" button every 30 seconds.
- triggercut 8y agoI remember a few years ago reading an article about how in some parts of the NYC system it's impossible to know where the subway car physically is from a central control room. This has other impacts, like not being able to reliably update the forward station on arrival.
- cowmoo728 8y agoYes - at some of the stations the people directing the trains only know when it has left a station, and when it gets to the next one. Some of it is still controlled with vacuum tubes and switchboards. The person featured in this video ruffled quite a few feathers when it was released: https://youtu.be/Mjx3S3UjmnA https://youtu.be/Mjx3S3UjmnA
- petermcneeley 8y agoThe skytrain has never had drivers. Its first section was completed in 1986. "The signalling technology used on all three SkyTrain lines to run trains automatically was originally developed by Alcatel, and loaded from a 3.5" diskette."
- sethhochberg 8y agoIn NYC it isn't a question of whether the technology exists - everybody knows driverless trains have been possible for a long time. Most importantly, most of the lines are using signaling systems installed decades before computerized signaling existed so currently operating them without people is impossible. Much of the current system is so outdated that even the human dispatchers don't know the precise position of any given train without radio contact with the onboard crew. The upgrade project that the article in the link talks about would move towards enabling this at a technical level. Secondly, because the trains _have_ had human drivers and conductors for a century, the union representing them is extremely powerful and there are many political considerations that go into getting humanless train operation. A newer system, which was built fully-automated and never had a motorman or conductor's union in the first place, has it much easier in that regard. Its a classic legacy problem, building anew doesn't involve any of the hassles of upgrading an old system. (None of these problems are unsolvable, and all the fixes are waaaayyy overdue... but these are the cards we're playing with here in NY. There are a ton of entrenched interests and a few decades of technical debt to pay back.)