2 ms·
There are many places where lying is against the rules - and proving that an incorrect statement is a lie is equally impossible in all of them. As a result it's
by whatshisface 9y ago
There are many places where lying is against the rules - and proving that an incorrect statement is a lie is equally impossible in all of them. As a result it's protected speech in practice. (The courts could make it easier to convict, they have chosen this standard of evidence for a reason.)
- adrianratnapala 9y agoBut I wonder about double standards. If Joe Bloggs tells something false to a federal agency his best defense is probably that the agency doesn't notice / doesn't care. Ordinary folks probably wouldn't stand a chance if it came to court.
- sjy 9y agoHow is lying different to any other crime of intent in this regard?
- whatshisface 9y agoIt's possible that other crimes of intent are also unenforceable. If the law says, "between two identical actions and circumstances, you are in violation for the one with bad intent," then lawyers will probably be able to prevent any conviction (outside of someone getting on the news and announcing their hatred for humanity!). If the law says, "because we want to discourage this intent, this specific action is illegal under these circumstances," then it will work the same way as any other criminal law (it will be possible to assemble evidence and get prosecutions even against skilled defenses.)
- sjy 9y agoPeople do get convicted of murder and perjury, though.