5 ms·
Making speech illegal is very dangerous ground, so while I agree that this looks suspicious I'm in the end happy that "don't lie to Congress" is being handled w
by whatshisface 9y ago
Making speech illegal is very dangerous ground, so while I agree that this looks suspicious I'm in the end happy that "don't lie to Congress" is being handled with soft gloves. There is also an abuse potential in accusing people of lying, that this lax enforcement reduces.
/cynical/ if you could get easily prosecuted from telling Congress "incorrect" information, it might be predominantly used against lone whistleblowers who had ended up on the loosing side of a very effective information squashing campaign. That's just one example of how such a law could be abused if it was over-enforced. /end cynical/
- jrs95 9y agoIf you aren’t a D.C. insider you will be persecuted for this. But if you are, and especially if you can claim to have something to do with “national security” it seems like you can basically get away with doing whatever the hell you’d like.
- dbasedweeb 9y agoHolding perjury to account isn’t a free speech issue goddamn it.
- archgoon 9y agoDid Wray know the information he was presenting was false? That's the standard for perjury. Edit: if you're making a more general point, point cheerfully granted. :)
- arca_vorago 9y agoI can't believe this even has to be said... I wonder if he takes the same positon on the Clapper perjury, for example? Astoundingly shameful.
- whatshisface 9y agoJames Clapper is strong evidence of the point: "don't lie" laws are predominantly used against the (non-powerful) innocent because the difficulty of proving anything means the executors of the law have too much impunity. If Clapper had gotten convicted, it would have been reasonable to suggest that the law worked. As it stands it doesn't work, but it still introduces the risk of abuse. The head of the NSA and Joe Nobody should be under the same laws. It's not practical to prove that someone is lying as opposed to making a mistake if they are careful in their wording (and have good legal counsel), so there is only one thing left to do. If congressional perjury laws were repealed, the only effect would be making the level of scrutiny that is necessary now obvious (in addition to protecting people from false accusations.) In a world where disingenuous speech can accomplish everything lying can, laws against lying are winking security theatre.
- sooheon 9y agoHow does anyone in this whole goddamn rotten system even pretend to serve justice anymore. Laws are literally being used selectively to persecute the weak, and look the other way for the powerful.
- saagarjha 9y agoLying to the federal government or while you're on trial is not protected under free speech, as far as I'm aware.
- whatshisface 9y agoThere are many places where lying is against the rules - and proving that an incorrect statement is a lie is equally impossible in all of them. As a result it's protected speech in practice. (The courts could make it easier to convict, they have chosen this standard of evidence for a reason.)
- adrianratnapala 9y agoBut I wonder about double standards. If Joe Bloggs tells something false to a federal agency his best defense is probably that the agency doesn't notice / doesn't care. Ordinary folks probably wouldn't stand a chance if it came to court.
- sjy 9y agoHow is lying different to any other crime of intent in this regard?
- whatshisface 9y agoIt's possible that other crimes of intent are also unenforceable. If the law says, "between two identical actions and circumstances, you are in violation for the one with bad intent," then lawyers will probably be able to prevent any conviction (outside of someone getting on the news and announcing their hatred for humanity!). If the law says, "because we want to discourage this intent, this specific action is illegal under these circumstances," then it will work the same way as any other criminal law (it will be possible to assemble evidence and get prosecutions even against skilled defenses.)
- sjy 9y agoPeople do get convicted of murder and perjury, though.
- itronitron 9y agoI would expect that someone in his position would know all the strategies for qualifying their statements, 'based on our current understanding to the best of my knowledge' etc.