4 ms·
Ask HN: How did Perl avoid the "Slow" label?
How is it that a scripting language like Perl avoided the "Slow" label when other languages with faster implementations couldn't? What did Perl do right or wrong with PR to accomplish this?
- billturner 16y agoMy guess is that Perl has been silently chugging along in the background, while Ruby (with Rails) and Python (with Django) popped into the spotlight under higher scrutiny. Perl hasn't had a popular framework that has built as large a community of users (and detractors) as any other. They do have frameworks (like Catalyst), but nothing that has gathered as much attention.
- _delirium 16y agoPerl was pitched initially as a replacement for shell-scripting + sed + awk; if you take that as a baseline, Perl is usually much faster. Many of the other "slow" languages seem to pitch themselves as competitors in wider spaces. The text-processing focus, especially early on, might also be a factor, because if you're mainly banging data through regexes, it's pretty fast. The super-fancy regexes-that-are-more-than-regular do have degenerate cases, but they're fast in a wide range of cases, and in my comparisons usually beat sed.
- gdl 16y agoIt all depends what you're comparing it against, and how you're using it. Keep in mind that Perl was originally created to fit a text processing and shell scripting niche, in which it is tuned to perform quite nicely. I've heard it claimed that its regex engine is likely the fastest you'll find anywhere. These days its reputation is mainly in the above, and as a glue language. It's simply not used as much for large standalone applications where people would really notice the speed issue, in comparison to something like Java (which is what comes to mind for me as at least at one time having the "slow" reputation). And although it might not apply in the distant past, CPAN is large enough now that for any conceivable resource-intensive task, there will be a modules available to wrap an appropriate C library.
- joeycfan 16y agoI think that perl did such wonderful things that no on cared if it was a wee bit slow - also it's been optimized a LOT, and isn't slow anymore. (and still does wonderful things)