3 ms·
It all has to do with education. Educated people are naturally more skeptical of their media and what the sources are. Before social media, it was admitted a
by jedberg 9y ago
It all has to do with education. Educated people are naturally more skeptical of their media and what the sources are.
Before social media, it was admitted a lot harder for unreliable sources to get an audience, so that skepticism was less critical.
But I think it will come back. Education is the antidote to social media news. Deity willing, the next government will see that and push for better education.
- bproven 9y agoExactly - also increasing focus on critical thinking skills.
- mantas 9y agoWhich may only make them question mainstream media. Hopefully it'd make social media more reliable.
- bachbach 9y ago> Educated people are naturally more skeptical of their media and what the sources are. I have not found that to be the case and I think you should scrutinize that assumption very carefully. Perhaps a majority of intellectuals in the West thought the Soviet Union was a step forward - again and again it's the 'smart' people who get the big things wrong.
- majewsky 9y ago> Perhaps a majority of intellectuals in the West thought the Soviet Union was a step forward I wasn't there at the time, so I have no way of knowing, but this smells like hindsight bias.
- repolfx 9y agoNo. It was obvious at the time that the USSR was bad news. George Orwell was writing about the dystopian nature of Soviet society in 1948. It had become obvious decades earlier that the Russian revolution had gone horribly wrong, after western powers realised that Soviet lumber exports were coming from forced labour camps. And the fact that a Russian revolution would go wrong in this way was obvious even at the turn of the century. Lenin was put on a train in Switzerland and sent back to Russia specifically to cause chaos. Going even further back, it was a constant frustration of Marx that the working classes in the UK (where he lived) stubbornly refused to rise in violent revolution. His ideology was well discussed in his own time but somehow actual working people were too smart to believe in it. Only intellectuals far removed from the real lower classes thought his theories were good. tl;dr it's widely known that academics and other intellectuals couldn't accept the disastrous nature of communism long after supposedly more "stupid" people had fully understood the nature of Marxist ideology. Even shorter tl;dr - education often seems to make people dumber in important ways, not smarter.
- mantas 9y agoAt the same time education is encouraging people to not trust the mainstream. There's a lot of reasons for that, thanks to tabloids and seemingly credible papers going bananas once in a while. So educated people do their own research. Which sometimes goes wrong. For example, a lot of conspiracy theorists are educated people. Their research just took an interesting turn at one point or another. @bachbach's example of pro-Soviet intellectuals is a good one as well. There was a similar downtown on the other side of the wall too. Quite a few anti-soviet dissidents turned into conspiracy theorists later on. In both cases, people were happy to rebel and look for alternatives and their education did help them. But eventually their curiosity took them too far.
- jesseendahl 9y agoTruly effective education involves teaching people how to do their research in a way that stresses objectivity and apply a high degree of scrutiny to any argument. It gives people a toolkit for critical thinking, and how to assess the quality of one argument against another. We don't just need education, we education that places a renewed emphasis on critical thinking skills. This is an interesting article on this topic: http://www.apa.org/ed/precollege/ptn/2017/05/fake-news.aspx http://www.apa.org/ed/precollege/ptn/2017/05/fake-news.aspx
- mantas 9y agoYup. But some people think that education would make people flock back to mainstream media and listening to talking heads. Which is not going to happen. And that's good. Once you start evaluating arguments and doing your own research, a lot of difference opinions emerge. Which sometimes are labeled as fake news, even though they're not truly fake. If everyone did assess all news, most crazy fake news would be gone. Which is awesome. But many of non-mainstream opinions that technically are not fake would survive. Which is good too in my books, but some people wouldn't agree.
- jonbarker 9y agoThe tech platform companies are all competing for mindshare in the education market as well. In fact, a FB apologist once went so far as to suggest that the best antidote to FB is readily available FB in classrooms; this way students will learn to be less distracted by it. The problem with this is that even the mere availability of the resource is a source of distraction.