3 ms·
It's not "doing nothing". It's legally pledging the money for use on charitable purposes, rather than buying mansions or yachts. And they only get a tax break o
by icebraining 8y ago
It's not "doing nothing". It's legally pledging the money for use on charitable purposes, rather than buying mansions or yachts. And they only get a tax break on that money.
- pmoriarty 8y agoThat pledge is worthless if that money never actually gets spent, which is apparently just what's happening with a lot of these "charities". In those cases the pledges help no one except rich donors, who get tax breaks.
- icebraining 8y agoEven if the money is never spent, those rich donors are still worse off than if they had kept the money. So I have to wonder what you think is their goal.
- Retric 8y agoI am not convinced that's always true. They are double dipping on tax breaks. If you invest 1$ and it's worth 1,001$ you would normally pay taxes on that of 15% federal + state. However, if you 'donate' it you get to take a deduction on other incomes for the full 1,001$ and those incomes could be taxed at 39.6% federal + state. So it costs you 850$ - state taxes to save 397$ + state taxes. California is 13.3% so I am not 100% but I think that works to spending 717 to save 530$ net cost 187$. So, the question is can you make back more than 187$ from a 1,001$ donation. Our president for example would host charitable events at his golf courses which could likely cross that threshold. But, political donations seem like a good option also work, even just employing family is a classic. PS: If the numbers are a little different aka you are taxed at 39.9% not 15%, then it's a clear net gain. Other possibility is something which is nominally worth X, but you would have trouble liquidating for the full value.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 8y agotake a deduction on other incomes Wait, how so? As far as I know, the deduction is only applied to the donated amount, not to any other income. Also, political contributions are not tax deductible.
- toast0 8y agoWhen you donate appreciated capital property (ex: stock) held for over a year, you get two benefits: a) a deduction for the fair market value of the capital property, which counts against ordinary income first, and then capital gains if your allowable donation is larger than your ordinary income b) you don't recognize income for any capital gains on the donated property If you're donating stock with a very low basis, this is a pretty big bonus vs selling the stock and donating cash. It also comes in handy if you donate stock you've held for a long time with a lot of corporate actions and it's hard to calculate the basis (for example AT&T shares originally purchased in the 70s would be a lot of work to track down a basis for, if you donate it, or pass it through your estate, you don't have to determine the basis)
- MichaelDickens 8y agoYou cannot make the required $187 from your donation if you let it sit in a DAF forever, which is the behavior the article is questioning.
- Retric 8y agoOps, I though the Johnson Amendment had been repealed, but did not realize it failed.
- pge 8y agoand the manager of the DAF who gets a percentage of the assets each year...