3 ms·
This is a ridiculous article. Rekognition has been available for over a year, and I've been using it for that whole year. I've even integrated it into my own
by jedberg 9y ago
This is a ridiculous article. Rekognition has been available for over a year, and I've been using it for that whole year. I've even integrated it into my own home security camera.
Amazon is selling it to law enforcement, but it's not like LE get special service that no one else does. Amazon built a generic facial recognition system, and it works pretty well. Even if they weren't pushing towards the police and government, they tech is out there. Those groups could have used it on their own.
- sebringj 9y agoI'm not sure I follow because your home security system, correct me, is only near your home, not connected to millions of people collectively that are mechanical turked unwillingly. Them apples aren't oranges.
- jedberg 9y agoI'm just saying that this technology is available for everyone, even in a security context. It's not like they build this just for LE.
- sebringj 9y agoRight valid true. Its just that it's scary if someone has tons of money and users and AI etc etc that has this capability and misuses it on a massive scale kind of how big data only works when its big. No one cares that my localhost website has root access to my machine for example but maybe that's a silly point but I think you get what I'm saying, kind of like the tree falling in the forest... take your pick of metaphors.
- trumped 9y agoThis is a ridiculous comment... Because it has been available doesnt make it any better...
- jedberg 9y agoExcept that the article is paining it as if it's this crazy new thing and the government and Amazon must be stopped in their collaboration to turn America into a police state. When in reality it's just a service that's been around for a while that offers a technology that other people have, and was available to law enforcement long before Amazon started selling it to them. What is the news here? That Amazon sells their products to the government?
- fcarraldo 9y agoThere is plenty of technology available to private citizens and companies that cannot be freely used by government entities, unchecked, on a massive scale. The news is that the government wants to use a new technology that is rife for abuse, which currently has no regulation when used by law enforcement, and Amazon wants to sell it to them. Amazon might be a bogeyman here, but calling out the potential for abuse by governments of new tech is a primary function of the press in a modern free society.