7 ms·
Why? The surveillance is there. I used this with some personal video surveillance to identify some thieves who were casing driveways to find cars to get into.
by Spooky23 9y ago
Why? The surveillance is there.
I used this with some personal video surveillance to identify some thieves who were casing driveways to find cars to get into. Instead of wasting hours looking at footage, I was able to give the police excerpts that helped them identify the perp. Also, because of the circumstances and footage, they were able to charge him with a more serious crime than petit larceny, which means he won't be back next week.
It's an effective tool. If you're allowed to have a camera, you should be allowed to look at it with whatever means you want.
The reality is that the horse is out of the barn. The Federal government has been doing this type of surveillance either using facial or LPR data on interstate corridors since at least the 90s.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoWhen all they probably needed was a real drug rehab program. Edit: Just saying because almost all petty thievery is committed to get goods to trade for drugs. Edit 2: Also, I'm not saying that this wasn't a good use of home surveillance, or to whatever parent's comment referred, although (s)he is probably wrong that they won't be back next week. I have acquaintances that having got hooked on meth, began stealing cars. Once caught, I thought she'd be put in prison or a drug rehab program. No. She basically served no time because the judge and everyone else know she was just a junky and there was no funding for rehab, and little room in prison.
- kchronic8 9y agoLet me increase your rent so we can pay for said rehab program. If you say no, then you have no right to say anything.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoHa! I would support any tax that pays for real drug rehabs...much cheaper than prison and better chance to fix the real problem.
- FireBeyond 9y agoUnfortunately, knowing our luck it will barely be more than an AA/NA meeting, perhaps with random UA testing, that some contractor charges the government Passages Malibu rates for...
- SubiculumCode 9y agoThis is unfortunately true. Indeed I think it has to include imprisonment during detox and skill training periods (min 1 year)
- kevinh 9y agoYou're assuming that drug rehab programs are a net cost to society.
- syshum 9y agoWhy take 50% of the money used to lock people away in a metal cage and fund the best drug rehab program every conceived by man. I dont think you have any idea how much money is in the prison system today
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mrobot 9y agoOr we could curb the landlords and build some decent real public housing for a lot of people that is not the prison system. Have you considered "hacking" the problem of these landowners who charge too much?
- mfringel 9y agoTwo things: 1. That's a non-sequitur. Drug rehab programs that are part of prison diversion schemes are implicitly a matter of public policy. A single individual writing a single check is meaningless in that context. 2. "Saint or GTFO" is a debate tactic used by the foolish who think their opponent is a bigger fool.
- SubiculumCode 9y ago"Saint or GTFO" As an aside, I have not heard that type of argument paraphrased this way, but it is terribly amusing.
- coenhyde 9y agoAre you aware of how much money it costs society to send someone to prison? A LOT more than a rehab program. - You have direct cost of imprisonment ~$60k a year - The costs of prosecution (no idea what this costs though) - Once someone has been to prison they are much more likely to be involved in crime again, and become a repeat customer of the industrial prison complex - We loose a tax payer - The perp will have no retirement fund, thus the government is on the hook again during retirement years. - Increased insurance costs for everyone else due to a higher crime rate I don't have the time or resources to do an accurate cost estimation but we could do some basic napkin math. Lets say 10 years in prison during their lifetime and a loss of $15k tax per year over a 30 year period (due to time spent in prison and loss of earning potential once they're out). (10 * $60k) + (30 * $15k) = $1,050,000 loss to the State. That's a shit load of money. Crime prevention looks a lot cheaper now doesn't it?
- SubiculumCode 9y agoMany people, unfortunately, want blood and 'justice', not helping hands and forgiveness for thieves. Perhaps if we highlight just how much 'torture' addicts feel as they go off drugs in a rehab hardliners might be convinced to support drub rehab as a fully funded public policy.
- gowld 9y agoYou haven't shown that (successful) rehab costs less.
- mrobot 9y ago"Whatever means you want" just has to not include matching to a database of suspicious people that are not currently under investigation for a real crime. Or to something with a floating definition like "terrorist". Which it won't. Just because Washington County says it's not currently being used for mass surveillance doesn't mean it won't be in the future or for other departments.
- weaksauce 9y agoI know it’s cliche to bring up in these examples but there was an unintended negative outcome to Germany requiring people to register and pay some of their taxes to their church before ww2. The Nazis used that information to collect up and brand Jewish people and ultimately kill them. It is hard to imagine this tech will solely be used for good forever.
- mrobot 9y agoLos Angeles police already use gang databases to fault people for being in the "wrong" part of the city based on their database entry. This stuff is gonna turn into some kinda crazy 21st century internet apartheid.
- gazarsgo 9y agoif only there were a hero among us who could free us from our database driven shackles
- candiodari 9y agoYou don't get the full extent of the damage. You are making the assumption that the government and police departments are the only ones that will do mass-surveillance. You could not be more wrong. Everyone will do mass-surveillance. Everyone. The police is worst, because they will legally use violence against (true AND false) matches, with limited to no recourse for their victims. But the cats' out of the bag. Legal or not, mass surveillance is not going to happen ... It is happening. They will even sell that information on. "Alexa, which bar has the most blonds going into it ?" coming up soon. Or worse: "Alexa, can you tell me who is my daughter's boyfriend with face recognition ?" "That'll be $0.45, buy ? $1 extra if you want to know if they have sex. Included for free with Prime ! Order that instead ?". https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/the-surprising-return-of-the-repo-man/2018/05/15/26fcd30e-4d5a-11e8-af46-b1d6dc0d9bfe_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.b142a7048eb0 https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/the-surprisi...
- syshum 9y agoAhh the old "if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear" defense for mass surveillance. Don't study history much do you? If you believe this will only ever be used to stop thieves and people that victimize others you are naive at an unfathomable level >The Federal government has been doing this type of surveillance either using facial or LPR data on interstate corridors since at least the 90s. lol... You believe that is justification or a defense. The fact that the Federal Government is doing something that people that value privacy oppose does not mean we should allow local law enforcement to do it even more efficiently
- fixermark 9y agoIt does suggest, however, that a slippery-slope argument of "More surveillance plunges us immediately into a 1984-esque dystopia" has a big [citation needed] banner hovering over it though.
- syshum 9y agoI feel we are already in a 1984 Style Surveillance state they are just better at hiding it then the book's government So no I do not think it is "slippery slope" at all, we have already slide down the slope; arriving at the bottom. We long ago surpassed the level of government surveillance I believe is ethical, constitutional, or proper for government if the government having a database filled with everyone Bio metric data they can then use technology to follow, trace, and monitory your every movement is not a "surveillance state" I shutter to think what it would take for you to classify such as system? a Brian implant that reads your every thought?
- Madmallard 9y ago<>
- dbliss 9y agoCan you expand on "literally everyone is worse off", and I'll assume you meant literally in the colloquial sense, as an emphasis. OP gave an example where he was better off. Do you mean that the trade-off is not worth risk/down side?
- ryanlol 9y agoOP gave the example where they felt better because someone got a harsher punishment.
- Spooky23 9y agoNo, I didn’t say that. When you take a GPS from an unlocked car, you get charged with petit larceny, which is an appearance ticket and $50-500 fine. When you get charged with a higher crime, you get a few weeks in jail. In my case, the offender was a known “frequent flyer” who victimized my neighborhood for months, and was arrested 6 times. He was charged with a more serious misdemeanor, and was charged with 30 days in jail. He has not returned. My objective as a citizen is to peacefully enjoy my home. Some lowlife doesn’t have the right to pillage our yards.
- wafflebear 9y agoOnly if you consider privacy as a means to an end rather than a goal by itself. Facial recognition has a negative effect on literally everyone's privacy.
- fixermark 9y agoPrivacy is a means to an end. That end is peace-of-mind. People who have been damaged by random acts of crime may very well find more peace-of-mind sacrificing a bit of privacy to not have those acts repeated on their persons.
- mfringel 9y agoI suspect that total involuntary surveillance is not something the majority of the (United States) populace signed up for. The legal Expectation of Privacy[0] continues to be important, even if there are people who think that it was a legal handwave that only existed due to lack of adequate technology. ---- [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation_of_privacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expectation_of_privacy
- npongratz 9y ago> I suspect that total involuntary surveillance is not something the majority of the (United States) populace signed up for. I certainly agree, but just wait until They/Them/Those start telling us this is part of some sacrosanct "social contract," and those who don't like it can simply leave. Edit: small changes for clarity.
- PostOnce 9y ago> If you dont like it leave people start leaving > wait! dont leave! We're gonna jack up the renounce-your-citizenship fee by thousands of dollars! actually happened already.
- asimpletune 9y agoI didn’t know about this. Do you have any links?
- geomark 9y agoTry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renunciation_of_citizenship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renunciation_of_citizenship TL;DR: You could renounce your US citizenship for free before 2010. Then it when up to $450. In 2014 the fee was raise to $2,350. On top of the fee is the exit tax wherein you may be required to pay a tax on the entirety of any gains on your assets as if you had sold them all that day. And, further, if they think you are renouncing to avoid taxes they claim that you must continue to pay taxes for 10 years after you renounce.
- TuringNYC 9y agoWhy? <Insert any bad/questionable/controversial thing> is already there. Just because something is out there does not mean you want more of it.
- smrtinsert 9y agoHow many times do we have to learn this lesson?
- s_dev 9y ago>If you're allowed to have a camera, you should be allowed to look at it with whatever means you want. You aren't allowed to look in to people houses with it or in to schools, up girls skirts, inside some banks etc. You may have rights to own a camera -- I have the right to go around swinging my fists in to thin air but my right to swing fists stops where your head begins.
- lostmsu 9y agoActually, you are OK to do most of these things in many parts of US.
- zipwitch 9y agoBecause the advancement of technology changes the impact of certain classes of surveillance and tracking. Existing law is based on a balance that no longer exists. Bruce Schneier has a nice essay on this and license plates: https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2007/01/on_police_security_c.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2007/01/on_police_s... In short, having a unique id and database of car owners may be okay when the police need to manually look up information. But when they can have every plate in the city regularly scanned by robots and the data fed to an AI to look for patterns, that's not even close to the same thing.
- Spooky23 9y agoI don’t disagree with you. My point isn’t that pervasive surveillance is great. It’s that if you’re allowed to have cameras everywhere, why would you limit useful processing of the data? How do you regulate it? If you can’t hire Amazon to do LPR or facial recognition, can you pay a guy to recognize people walking down the street and note their patterns? Do you license/permit camera placement?
- thephyber 9y ago> How do you regulate it? Use vague words in the statutes like "reasonable" and have jurisprudence define how it can be used in practice. At least that's how the law already works. Even though private surveillance is pervasive in the US, law enforcement is still sometimes rejected from using some of it when it flies in the face of the privacy standards to which we are accustomed[1]. [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/08/judge-blasts-fbi-for-bugging-courthouse-throws-out-200-hours-of-recordings/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/08/judge-blasts-fbi...
- rtpg 9y agoThere's a supreme court case that's about this. The feds had thermal cameras hooked up to a helicopter, flew over some guy's house, saw thermal signatures looking a lot like someone growing marijuana. Supreme court threw this out as a warrantless search because people are allowed an expectation of privacy against tech that "everyday people" don't have. IANAL, but if you don't buy this logic, then search warrants are mostly limited by tech? Like if the gov't invented binoculars that could see through walls, does that mean they could just look into your house without a warrant? The search warrant is about intent and expectations. And while "police officer checks records manually of a person" is kinda expected, "police officer x-rays an entire crowd instantly" seems a bit less so. We _do_ put up signs about cameras, and there's rules about recording phone conversations too. It sure feels like there's case law around a lot of this.
- gitgacutils 9y agoMonitoring heavy trafficked interstate corridors is one thing. This is entirely a different. Amazon/tech is at a point where we could get blanket surveillance on most streets, in our homes, in our offices, etc. It's the difference between monitoring areas/locations and monitoring people ( us ). But I agree that the pandora's box has been opened and there is no going back.
- volgo 9y agoIt's funny how many people come out in defense of Amazon, compared to when it's done in China. It really reminds me a really wise saying I heard somewhere, that nothing is really sinister or even when it's happening in your own backyard :)
- em3rgent0rdr 9y ago> "they were able to charge him with a more serious crime" Isn't charging defendants with overwhelming charges part of the problem?
- xfitm3 9y agoI have concerns over misuse but I’m glad to see this is available to the public.