9 ms·
The shape of a 21st century I don’t want to see
- jgh 8y agoI've been having similar feelings about the state of the world for the past few years, and that's only been amplified by revelations like Cambridge Analytica and hysteria around GDPR. We're in a dystopian world now, one that could have been written about in the 70s or 80s when people feared technology, except worse. In those dystopian visions the world was chaotic. Today we are seeing the surveillance and panopticons that were envisioned in those dystopias, but we are, largely, comfortable. So it's almost illusory. Am I paranoid, or is the world really walking down a dark path towards....what?
- netsharc 8y agoMakes me think of the intro movie to the game Syndicate Wars: the world looks shiny and beautiful, until an agent hacks your chip, and you see that you're walking a dystopian world: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGvIrf86g4Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGvIrf86g4Y . Another thesis which basically supports Charlie's is: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/nov/25/13-crises-we-face-trump-soil-loss-global-collapse https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/nov/25/13-cri...
- bhouston 8y ago> Makes me think of the intro movie to the game Syndicate Wars: the world looks shiny and beautiful, until an agent hacks your chip, and you see that you're walking a dystopian world: Our existing dominant forms of escapism, video games & TV, have accomplished this fairly well already.
- bhouston 8y ago> So it's almost illusory. Am I paranoid, or is the world really walking down a dark path towards....what? It is just change. It was hard for the world to adapt to the idea of nuclear weapons, and before that the awesome power of mechanized war.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> It was hard for the world to adapt to the idea of nuclear weapons, and before that the awesome power of mechanized war. These are interesting examples because in both cases society only adapted to the new technology after it had been deployed to catastrophic or near-catastrophic effect. What is going to be the panopticon equivalent of WWI? I fear we're in for some interesting times.
- coldtea 8y ago>People will be die in large numbers, but it will happen out of sight. Out of sight for the first world (or parts of it in good neighborhoods) -- very much in sight for those dying....
- quickthrower2 8y agoI took that as implied.
- coldtea 8y agoWhen an international audience can read one's blog, such as the web allows for, it can be in bad taste to leave it implied.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoIn Mr Stross's case, "international audience" means "outside of Scotland".
- msandford 8y agoLet's not forget that it isn't 100% the right that likes to deny banking to "undesirables" - the Obama administration put the kibosh on Wikileaks funding through questionable means: https://wikileaks.org/Banking-Blockade.html https://wikileaks.org/Banking-Blockade.html It's very much a "people in charge" vs "people not in charge" rather than "this political ideology" vs "that political ideology"
- icebraining 8y agoObama is center-right by European standards.
- dantillberg 8y agoMaybe you like what Wikileaks has done, but if a group solicits and then publishes huge troves of your nation's secrets, it's kind of hard to distinguish the group's actions from those of a hostile foreign power. I used to be a fan myself, but nowadays I can't figure out why Americans don't all consider Assange to be either a malicious spy or a malicious insurgency. They're definitely not on the USA government's side, and it's not clear to me that they're on my side, either, but they're definitely on some side, and they are on the attack.
- ghthor 8y agoMaybe you're not on the best side? Just a question to ask yourself. IMO wikileaks is a natural evolution being pushed by this fact that we feel less and less like we have the right checks and balances on the actions and decisions of the US government.
- marssaxman 8y agoI am a US citizen and it is blatantly obvious that the US government is not on my side. "My" nation shouldn't have those secrets in the first place. They clearly can't keep themselves honest, so it's good that someone has found a clever way of forcing them to deal with it.
- JasonFruit 8y agoAnd of course people on the left who are certain all the killing will be done by the right aren't dangerous at all. Beware a prophet who proclaims your own perfection.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoTo clarify what you likely meant: Extremists on either side are equally dangerous. I figured you'd get down voted for sounding like if you're generalizing.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"Equally dangerous"? If so, that'd be a highly unlikely coincidence. Both sides advocate a bunch of really stupid ideas that'd be likely to kill a large number of people, but those stupid ideas are radically different in both likelihood and mass death potential.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoExtremists are usually unpredictable.
- paulmd 8y agoNo, I think people on the left are quite aware that fascists aren't going to punch themselves. When Nazis are marching in the streets, someone will have to step up to the plate. https://www.cbsnews.com/pictures/white-supremacist-rallies-in-charlottesville-virginia/ https://www.cbsnews.com/pictures/white-supremacist-rallies-i... (it's a sad sign of the times that "Nazis must be and should be stopped by force" is somehow seen as a controversial statement. Sometime, ask a WWII vet if they had any second thoughts about killing Nazis, let alone just giving one a black eye.) What Antifa does may be illegal, but it's also morally correct. A lot of people have problems with confusing those two concepts. Keeping torch-wielding supremacists from terrorizing innocents is not morally equivalent with those doing the terrorizing, even if both use violence.
- miiiiiike 8y agoOr, good people will continue coming together in good faith to create new and marginally better times. Is that guaranteed? Nope. But, I've seen too many good people (from all sorts of places and backgrounds) to be pessimistic.
- jgh 8y agoThe problem, the way I see it, is that a lot of the problems that are going to be coming to a head over the next decades aren't even really from malevolence. It's just ignorance, incompetence, and not really working together. Of course there are bad actors (e.g. the oil industry) who spread FUD and discord when it comes to the things they are interested in, but mostly it's humanity being too disorganized to really fix problems. Humanity being too short-sighted to see what the culmination of individual, otherwise innocuous, steps toward prolific data collection would mean. Did you imagine in 2006 when you first joined Facebook that some day it would impact your immigration status? Likely not. So going back to what you said yes there are lots of good people with good intentions, but along the way to creating our problems have been good people with good intentions.
- miiiiiike 8y agoWe don't disagree on much of that. The road to hell is paved with good intentions, people will act in poor faith, etc. Although, yes, I've always believed that anything that I say, anywhere, can and will be used against me. What I do think is unlikely/hyperbolic is the global "soft genocide" and organized "culling" that he describes in the post. I'm not much for Utopians or Dystopians, they're always trying to sell me something.
- jgh 8y agoYeah I doubt it would be organized as stated. Probably more along the lines of various restrictive immigration policies and sanctions which, perhaps inadvertently, lead to famine and war.
- icebraining 8y agoAs Ursula Le Guin wrote, "Predictions are uttered by prophets (free of charge); by clairvoyants (who usually charge a fee, and are therefore more honored in their day than prophets); and by futurologists (salaried). (...) I don't recommend that you turn to the writers of fiction for such information. It's none of their business."
- brobdingnagians 8y agoThey seem to like attacking the right; but it is the left which already screams about the world being overpopulated, are intolerant of religion or morals, advocates eliminating poor people through birth control, getting rid of "undesirables", uses violence to get their way, etc. and everyone seems to forget the Nazis were actually the "National Socialists", left-wing, not right-wing, but officially denied being either. I'm not saying the right is much better, but painting the left as being panda-bear loving hug-givers and the right as monsters is a very biased attitude. EDIT: main point being, I think it's a very biased article with little evidence of their claims. Sure, I think there are some bad things going on, and that we should take care of those, and that society should be less complacent, but forecasting doom and a certain group of people as being ruthless is a bit far out.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago> and everyone seems to forget the Nazis were actually the "National Socialists", left-wing, not right-wing They forget this because it is trivially, obviously, crashingly false https://www.snopes.com/news/2017/09/05/were-nazis-socialists/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2017/09/05/were-nazis-socialists... https://www.indy100.com/article/nazi-socialist-right-wing-white-supremacists-history-twitter-mikestuchbery-7900001 https://www.indy100.com/article/nazi-socialist-right-wing-wh... https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Hitler_and_socialism https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Hitler_and_socialism
- mindcrash 8y agoNational Socialism is an (extreme) offspring of Socialism, is entirely left-wing to modern standards and I have actual textual evidence from the man himself to proof it: "Socialism as the final concept of duty, the ethical duty of work, not just for oneself but also for one’s fellow man’s sake, and above all the principle: Common good before own good, a struggle against all parasitism and especially against easy and unearned income. And we were aware that in this fight we can rely on no one but our own people. We are convinced that socialism in the right sense will only be possible in nations and races that are Aryan, and there in the first place we hope for our own people and are convinced that socialism is inseparable from nationalism." -- Adolf Hitler, August 15 1920 "The common good before the individual good. (Gemeinnutz geht vor Eigennutz)" -- Adolf Hitler, February 1920 "Since we are socialists, we must necessarily also be antisemites because we want to fight against the very opposite: materialism and mammonism… How can you not be an antisemite, being a socialist!" -- Adolf Hitler, August 15 1920 "Because it seems inseparable from the social idea and we do not believe that there could ever exist a state with lasting inner health if it is not built on internal social justice, and so we have joined forces with this knowledge. " -- Adolf Hitler, August 15 1920 "There are no such things as classes: they cannot be. Class means caste and caste means race." -- Adolf Hitler, April 12 1922 "To put it quite clearly: we have an economic programme. Point No. 13 in that programme demands the nationalisation of all public companies, in other words socialisation, or what is known here as socialism. … the basic principle of my Party’s economic programme should be made perfectly clear and that is the principle of authority… the good of the community takes priority over that of the individual. But the State should retain control; every owner should feel himself to be an agent of the State; it is his duty not to misuse his possessions to the detriment of the State or the interests of his fellow countrymen. That is the overriding point. The Third Reich will always retain the right to control property owners. If you say that the bourgeoisie is tearing its hair over the question of private property, that does not affect me in the least. Does the bourgeoisie expect some consideration from me?… Today’s bourgeoisie is rotten to the core; it has no ideals any more; all it wants to do is earn money and so it does me what damage it can. The bourgeois press does me damage too and would like to consign me and my movement to the devil. " -- Adolf Hitler, 1931 "There is a difference between the theoretical knowledge of socialism and the practical life of socialism. People are not born socialists, but must first be taught how to become them." -- Adolf Hitler, October 5 1937 "We are Socialists, we are enemies of the capitalistic economic system for the exploitation of the economically weak, with its unfair salaries, with its unseemly evaluation of a human being according to wealth and property instead of responsibility and performance and we are all determined to destroy this system under all conditions." -- Adolf Hitler, May 1 1927 Sources, so you can read these actual quotes yourself: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler http://quotes.liberty-tree.ca/quote_blog/Adolf.Hitler.Quote.D6B3 http://quotes.liberty-tree.ca/quote_blog/Adolf.Hitler.Quote.... As an added bonus I also would like to point out that Mr. Hitler hated "the Left" (as in Marxist Socialism, but mainly because he didn't believe in "their kind of Socialism") as much as "the Right" (Liberalism/Libertarianism). He saw both as enemies of the German people. So why both classical liberals and libertarians alike are branded as "fascists" or "national socialists" these days is beyond me, because it is historically false. Secondly, I would like to point out that I am not at all a fan of Hitler and Nazi Germany but I do like to spend a lot of time studying history as it happened, and I still very much hope others will find the time to do the same aswell. If only to avert the biggest disaster Western civilization has ever faced in the near future (or let me put it otherwise: I agree with Charlie that a devastating event will happen in the near future. I disagree however that the Alt-Right, and solely the Alt-Right, will be the cause of this event. Because entoxicating extremism is literally anywhere and everywhere on the political spectrum these days).
- kmooney 8y ago...and now it's gone from the front page. Wouldn't want to burst that filter-bubble!
- jgh 8y agoThankfully the tweetstorm about becoming a CEO at 20 is still there!