7 ms·
One thing that bugs me a about the discussion of evolution in general is it tends to get treated as a smooth process influence mostly by the environment but DNA
by tim333 9y ago
One thing that bugs me a about the discussion of evolution in general is it tends to get treated as a smooth process influence mostly by the environment but DNA is essentially digital code for building bodies and probably the Cambrian was kicked off by some mutation a bit like a code refactor that allowed a lot of body variation subsequently by the changing of a few base pairs.
A bit like, in a loose analogy the old code was
print "protein"; print "protein"
and the new code was
for i=1 to 2 {print "protein"}
so that in the second case a single mutation in the "2" could result in a wide variety of body sizes.
- ak39 9y agoThe reason why the Cambrian was considered special and was often referenced as an "evolutionary explosion" was because the pace/rate of speciation is abnormally high during that period only. If you take your hypothesis for example, it may explain the explosion (rapidity) of the evolution of new species but it still doesn't offer viable reasons why the explosion was isolated to that period only. (Just an amusing side note: my God-believing and evolution-denying BIL uses the evidence of the Cambrian explosion to suggest that no scientist can explain why there was an explosion of diverse species is such a short time - it had to be "God's hand". "Only a creator can do such a thing". I must admit, until the arrival of my BIL, the Cambrian period was of mild interest to me. I now read about it with "special interest". Cheers!
- sgt101 9y agoIf he believes the the Cambrian explosion is due to God then he believes in the fact of the event, but has a different causal agent (vs don't know)
- ak39 9y agoCorrectly assessed. He uses the very same evidence of the existence of the explosion and the absence of evidence to explain the explosion part of the evidence as reason to believe that "it is God". I usually end the dinner conversation when I keep asking "how?". On some very rare but weaker moments he might trip and admit "I don't know". At which point I end it by saying, that's a very scientific thing to say. :-) He adds colour to our lives.
- BetaCygni 9y agoTo be honest, we don't know either, so the agnostic viewpoint (compared to atheistic) would be that it is equally valid. Either you believe in random chance or you believe in God. I'm always perfectly happy when someone calls the big bang the moment of creation. It could have been.
- Nursie 9y ago>Either you believe in random chance or you believe in God Not really true. "We don't know exactly how the Cambrian explosion came about, but have a lot of good evidence on how evolution works, which allows us to probe deeper into theories about what happened" is not equivalent to "it's all random chance!"
- BetaCygni 9y agoIsn't evolution random chance + selection? That's how I've always seen it.
- ak39 9y agoNot sure the point you're making. I do not differentiate between agnostic and atheistic thought. They are both the same thinking/belief systems in my view. An agnostic believes there could be a "god/creator" (but does not pursue this thought any further than "maybe"). An agnostic also believes there may not be a God/Creator given the absence of evidence to justify such a belief. An atheist believes that there is NO god/creator given the absence of evidence to prove the existence of such a being. If evidence had to exist then the atheist will believe the existence of such a being based on such evidence. That sounds exactly the same. As to your point about "we don't know" - well, not knowing is perfectly fine in science. We cannot ascribe to or embellish and fabricate imagined facts and agents to any unknown phenomenon without evidence.
- BetaCygni 9y ago> I do not differentiate between agnostic and atheistic thought. I find it very interesting that in de US there seem to be a lot of gnostic atheists (they know for certain there is no god, and are very vocal about this), while in Europe most people would be agnostic atheists, and they don't care as much.
- Insanity 9y agoBrother in-law?
- ak39 9y agoYip. He insists on hammering the vast wonders and myriad colours of life through the same blunt instrumentation of non-sequiturs and other horrendous logical fallacies. He simply cannot accept the removal of a "God's hand" in any conversation of scientific import. Conversations with him can get comical only if you insist on ignoring that he is a medical doctor to boot.
- fsloth 9y ago"He insists on hammering the vast wonders and myriad colours of life through the same blunt instrumentation" That's how human brains generally work. He's been conditioned to particular pattern matching and filtering. It's not a rational choice.
- Angostura 9y agoHow does he cope with the obvious evolution of antibiotic resistance through natural selection of bacteria? Or is he one of those 'micro-evolution' exists, but not 'macro-evolution'.?
- lugg 9y agoWould that not just be a tipping point in genetic diversity? Once you reach a certain level of complexity in one lineage you get exponentially more variation possible. Likewise, compound that from earlier lineage break aways that are now also reaching a tipping point in their own complexity. In other words, it's just an exponential situation under prime conditions for new species to emerge.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI always liked the "Radiological explanation" regarding the Cambrian explosion. Higher-than-normal levels of radiation would provide the mutagenic effects on all life. Many things would die because of dead-end deviations. I look at the area around Chernobyl at what radiation can do for evolution. Of course, it's pretty terrible for suffering on a whole, but we're talking about evolution. Life gets messy.
- tim333 9y agoMaybe in my analogy evolution was able to run through the different mutations of "2" and then had tried them all hence it finishing?
- zaphirplane 9y agoWhat I don’t get about evolution is why humans haven’t evolved in the last 5000 years probably 10,000 years
- Insanity 9y agoEvolution is a slow process. Plus humans are complex, so the small changes might be relatively invisible
- jacobolus 9y agoIt’s not like obvious evolutionary change typically happens in the course of just a few generations. But a quick web search turns up various discussions of recent evolution, e.g. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/20/science/20adapt.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/20/science/20adapt.html
- firmgently 9y agoThe timespan of a generation in humans is about 20 years. So in 5000-10000 years that's 250-500 generations, a tiny amount. For evolution to happen, a genetic mutation has to endow an advantage that makes its carrier more likely to survive and reproduce. Given that the reproductive selection process (which characteristics are attractive to a mate) is largely driven by cultural norms now, it's hard to see what advantages are going to raise a person's chances of reproducing. Fashion tastes change several times in a single generation. Women are often said to like taller men. Well we are getting taller as a species [1]. If men prefer a woman with a certain 'look', maybe women are evolving towards that look (it seems like a much harder thing to quantify). Manipulative, cheating males have more sexual partners - maybe we're evolving towards more of that kind of behaviour. If you're expecting humans to grow extra arms or become super-strong or something, I don't think it's going to happen. Extra limbs is too 'abnormal' and culture doesn't like that. Being physically strong doesn't affect chances of survival in humans any more. Same applies to better vision, hearing... any super-senses. They don't affect our survival. I've heard people posit that maybe we'll lose our little fingers as they don't do anything. Same again though - even if it's true that we don't use them, it doesn't mean that someone born without little fingers is going to have a higher chance of reproducing. Our development happens at a rate much faster than biological evolution now because of culture (meme vs gene). A lot of what constitutes a modern human is external (as a thought experiment just imagine what a human would be like if he'd never spoken to another human, read anything, or absorbed any culture in any other way). From this point of view, cultural evolution could be seen as evolution v2.0 as it happens and spreads much more quickly that genetic evolution. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-are-we-getting-taller/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-are-we-gettin...
- slfnflctd 9y agoMy understanding is that something very much like this is what is theorized to have kicked off a more recent 'explosion', that of angiosperms. Essentially there was some chromosome doubling which set the stage for the huge diversity and abundance of flowering plants which quickly dominated the planet. In the Wikipedia article on angiosperms it states, "The evolution of seed plants and later angiosperms appears to be the result of two distinct rounds of whole genome duplication events." I'm sure something like this is one of the more plausible triggers for the Cambrian.
- tim333 9y agoI was thinking - it's not an area I know much about really - but if something like that happened in the Cambrian you could probably figure out what by looking at the DNA of explosion descendents and species that were not involved and seeing what sequences were in the first group but not the second.