3 ms·
The truth is, big real estate companies have the resources and the incentive to be aggressive. But perhaps that's the root of the problem? With so many units a
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
The truth is, big real estate companies have the resources and the incentive to be aggressive.
But perhaps that's the root of the problem? With so many units at below market rates, the current new to the market units get priced to cover the "loss" of the controlled units? And then of course there's the incentive.
I'm not defending the practice. But I am suggesting - similar to housing and a college edu - that "government intervention" often has unintended consequences.
- knuththetruth 8y agoThe government intervenes on behalf of Global Capital in the housing market all the time, allowing them to turn a basic necessity (shelter) into a vehicle for things like international money-laundering and finacialized speculation. These are the circumstances that have created the housing crisis we have now and previously took down the entire economy. I’m confused as to why you single out trying to intervene on behalf of the average person over the wealthy as the source of the problem when the “free market” term setting has caused the massive distortions and unaffordablity.
- ryanobjc 8y agoCommon myth of the 'free market' - the reality is the market is totally constrained in many ways by the political and legal system. There is definitely something very 'i am very smart'-like about tech nerds defending 'the market' against any attempts of humanizing life. "um, actually the free market will..." Governments exist to provide super-market force. Safety regulation being kind of a prime example, especially for employees. OSHA is anti-free market -- there should be no safety regulations, and let employees the freedom to choose safety or pay and let the free market work it out. Right?
- pitaj 8y agoThe market is very good at allocating resources, setting prices, and meeting demand. Countries with freer economies like Switzerland and Hong Kong have higher standard of living on average. Countries which free up their economies have higher relative standards of living after doing so. Countries which oppress their economies have lower relative standards of living after doing so. (By relative, I mean relative to the growth rates of neighboring countries and before the changes, as standards of living rarely decrease absolutely).
- linkregister 8y agoThat said, those economies have some weird aspects to them. Both are small states. Both have much lower proportions of their population in poverty than larger states. Both are centers of global commerce. In general I agree with you that markets allocate resources far better than the most earnest central authorities. That said, market failures often happen without regulation from governments.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago"I’m confused as to why you single out trying to intervene on behalf of the average person..." That's not the case. I'm only pointing out that X years ago the gov set out to Y and now X has become Z and is eating X alive.
- knuththetruth 8y agoCould you be more specific about to what you’re assigning responsibility? Your original post was somewhat vague and I’m not following your variable analogy without you outlining specific values being assigned to X, Y, and Z.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoThe gov set out to artificially control housing costs. Now there are so many units under market value that: 1) there is an incentive for landlords to be aggressive. 2) any unit that comes off rent control is driven up in value; to make up for the "loss" of control units; and control keeps units off the market which also drives up price. Long to short, yesterday'price fix is today's mega-cost __and__ shady biz / landlord practices. Does that help? I wasn't trying to be vague. I honestly thought the gist of the situation was fairly obvious. Sorry?
- knuththetruth 8y agoNo need to apologize. It does, thanks.
- forapurpose 8y ago> similar to housing and a college edu - that "government intervention" often has unintended consequences. There's good and bad to everything and every policy, but this statement is meaningless. How many people have been educated in government-owned colleges, which includes ever public university in the U.S.? Whatever the unintended consequences, it seems to have done an enormous amount of good.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI'm talking about cheap and easy to get loans. They created artificial demand - for housing and for higher edu - and as we all know that drives prices up. I hope this clears things up. The point is, when you squeeze a balloon...shit happens.
- cossatot 8y agoI really wish the approach to making university education more affordable was by subsidizing the universities more instead of subsidizing loans. I don't know if hand-outs to banks was the only way that the left could get enough support from the right to get any legislation passed or what, but it's terrible both for those who do take out loans and those who just cough up more of their own or their family's money.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoWas it the only way? No, of course not. Does Wall Street play the puppet master? I think we all know the answer to that.
- forapurpose 8y agoFor those interested in the actual policy rather than a rant: Giving loans to students is a 'market-based' approach; it allows the market to pick winners and allocate resources, via students choice of school, rather than the government. How does the government pick which schools get the funds? That doesn't make it a perfect policy, of course. I think grants to students or simply free education at public universities may be the best options. But that costs more money than loans.
- MisterTea 8y ago> The truth is, big real estate companies have the resources and the incentive to be aggressive. Those are the people who can afford to weaponize the courts. Us little guys still have to play by the rules as we don't have deep pockets and lawyers on retainer.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoTrue. But it's also a function of the upside for those companies. That is, price fixing has created a massive incentive / reward. The risk (e.g., 3rd rate lawyer's salary) is relatively low while the reward is now VERY high. The gov grabbed a balloon and now that bubble is bursting, just in a different way. Again. Not saying it's right. Only that it's really not a surprise. Not at all.