3 ms·
I personally would refer you to any number of comments/articles (including my own) pointing out that law is not written like code. Law doesn't work in absolutes
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I personally would refer you to any number of comments/articles (including my own) pointing out that law is not written like code. Law doesn't work in absolutes, we have judges for a reason. There has to be a law for enforcement of it to occur, and it has to be broad enough that it can't be evaded on technicalities (see the loophole in the EU "cookie law", which GDPR is specifically designed to close).
GDPR is actually surprisingly light on concrete technical rules. This isn't PCI compliance where they specify the number of letters that must be in your passwords and what version of TLS you need to use. GDPR creates a framework of general principles you need to adhere to in the best way you know how. (Good laws need to be written this way, since technology changes over time.)
It is not in the EU's best interest to punish you for a minor oversight when you are largely a well-behaving corporation, it's in their best interests to encourage you to fill in any gaps when needed.
- downandout 9y agoLaw doesn't work in absolutes, we have judges for a reason. What laws have you been reading? The whole basis of law is that it must be absolute - otherwise people don’t know how to follow it. People are both exonerated and convicted every day of serious crimes based on nothing more than technicalities (“absolutes”), even when the legal outcome is in direct conflict with the spirit of the law.