3 ms·
One challenge is that everyone's reading is different. What reading will regulators have? And what reading will they have in 6 months vs now? For example in
by btilly 8y ago
One challenge is that everyone's reading is different. What reading will regulators have? And what reading will they have in 6 months vs now?
For example in this article it is assumed that everyone needs a data protection officer - the only question is whether you want someone full-time, or you want to share one with several other companies. However when I read https://gdpr-info.eu/art-37-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-37-gdpr/ it seems that most companies don't fall under 1.a or 1.c.
The question mark is 1.b, the core activities of the controller or the processor consist of processing operations which, by virtue of their nature, their scope and/or their purposes, require regular and systematic monitoring of data subjects on a large scale. If you're just recording transactions, clearly you are not monitoring them. If you're running a data broker, clearly you are monitoring them. If you're running queries against your transactional data to decide who to send a marketing email to..is that monitoring? "Find all people who put something into a cart yesterday and then didn't complete the transaction." I don't think of that query as monitoring, but I can see how someone else might.
- BinaryIdiot 8y ago> One challenge is that everyone's reading is different. Really? I haven't heard of people who have vastly different opinions in what specific pieces of GDPR means. Do you have any links? > For example in this article it is assumed that everyone needs a data protection officer What? Where is that assumed? The first thing it talks about are the reasons you may need one and nothing about assuming everyone needs one.
- zerostar07 8y ago> Do you have any links? check reddit.com/r/gdpr. Every other question has been answered with both a yes and a no.
- btilly 8y agoSearch for the phrase, "Do I need a (dedicated) Data Protection Officer?" You will see that the only two options that he discusses are having a dedicated Data Protection Officer versus a designated Data Protection Officer. With the difference being whether they are your full time employee doing nothing else, versus a part time responsibility. Neither in the article nor in his comments here does he admit the possibility that it might be a role that you don't actually need filled.
- jacquesm 8y ago> Neither in the article nor in his comments here does he admit the possibility that it might be a role that you don't actually need filled. I replied to your other comment in this thread, and I will update the article.
- jacquesm 8y agoYou will need to assign the role of data protection officer to someone in the organization if it is small, and if it is a larger company then you will probably want to have an individual that does this as a major part of their job description. A CCO (chief compliance officer would be a good choice in a large org). In a really large company or a company that deals with lots of sensitive data you'd want a dedicated person.
- btilly 8y agoMy reading of the GDPR says that a basic ecommerce site does NOT need that role filled. By anyone. Can you explain why you think that it does? With reference to where in the legislation it says it, and why you concluded that?
- jacquesm 8y agoBecause a basic e-commerce site could easily accumulate in the 10's of thousands of records over a couple of years of operation. Besides that is is a 'free' operation, simply say 'Joe is our DPO' (assuming Joe agrees, and if you're a sole proprietor you are Joe). The designated representative however is another matter. The specific part in the law that triggers this requirement is that almost every e-commerce site qualifies size wise ('the numbers of data subjects involved') and technology wise (analytics, A/B testing, funnels and recommendation systems). https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/accountability-and-governance/data-protection-officers/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da... Would be a good document to review. If the numbers are low (100's), there is no tracking, no recommendation systems and no analytics then you are right, in that case you do not need a DPO, but even then I would still assign the role since it is free.
- btilly 8y agoDepending on how you do A/B testing, you might be in the clear because of https://gdpr-info.eu/art-11-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-11-gdpr/. If you've built recommendation systems that rely on profiling customer behavior, then clearly you're doing something that touches on the heart of what GDPR tries to regulate. There is a grey area, and no real guidelines. Also I do not believe that the DPO is actually a free position to fill. If you read https://gdpr-info.eu/art-38-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-38-gdpr/ in section 6 there is the requirement that the DPO should not have a conflict of interest. If you're both the DPO and the person who is being asked to sell data, that's a conflict of interest. Even if you're the sole proprietor. If I thought I needed one, I would hire one. Even as a part time contractor. It is safer.
- chx 8y ago> One challenge is that everyone's reading is different. What reading will regulators have? And what reading will they have in 6 months vs now? Multiply that by the number of EU countries.
- jacquesm 8y agoThere is just one GDPR. Yes, the local regulators will enforce the GDPR but the text they will use to guide them is the same.
- manfredo 8y agoI'm not sure how this is supposed to be comforting. Judicial bodies have repeatedly come up with different, or even conflicting, interpretations of the same text. Take the US Constitution, for examine. The main text has remained unchanged for over two centuries, and most of its Amendments are at least a century old. Yet the courts are still overriding past interpretations of the same laws.
- pwinnski 8y agoFrom my reading, EU member countries seem to have been much more consistent with each other than we in the US might expect. A lot of the fear in this thread seems to be from people reading EU law through US filters.
- chx 8y ago> A lot of the fear in this thread seems to be from people reading EU law through US filters. No, my fear is from reading the EU law with an experience based Hungarian filter.