5 ms·
We lost our daughter to ALL. It's quite hard to read anything like this without thinking what could we have done differently.
by tonyedgecombe 9y ago
We lost our daughter to ALL. It's quite hard to read anything like this without thinking what could we have done differently.
- mr_golyadkin 9y agoThat must be far, far beyond "hard". I'm sorry.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoWe too lost a daughter to cancer, Nueroblastoma. I’ve always wondered if, even though there’s a genetic component, if there wasn’t an infection or other component we could have done something about. So many regrets. It has a 5% survival rate but we still wonder if we could have done something differently.
- btilly 9y agoThere is no blame in doing the best that you could have known how to. If it helps, you are far from alone. My sister lost her son to SIDS - just months before the American Academy of Pediatrics reversed their recommendation from putting babies to sleep on their stomachs to their backs. In one book I read a doctor described how his decision to go to medical school was shaped by holding a dying child he could do nothing for - and he learned the treatment in medical school and had had the materials on hand. I read a heartbreaking interview once with a doctor whose brother died of an infection not long before antibiotics came on the scene which would have made it trivial to treat. I've seen reference to similar accounts from Civil War surgeons who only realized how many their lack of cleanliness killed after Joseph Lister published in 1867. These examples could easily be multiplied a hundred-fold. We do the best we can. Learning improves our future. Nothing can change our past. I am sorry for your loss.
- mig39 9y agoWell said.
- teekert 9y agoMy condolences, I cannot imaging the pain. It is very easy to say I know, but try not to torture yourself. The research certainly does not point to this being black and white, more over, who knows what would have happened would you have had newer knowledge and acted differently. It's probably difficult and painful to imagine worse outcomes but who knows how well you handled things compared to what could have been? It's easier to imagine following all recent knowledge but still getting the same outcome. I'm sure you heard this all before.
- nickswan 9y agoSo sorry for you loss. As someone has said further down - this is one theory and isn’t a general medical consensus. Our daughter was diagnosed with ALL 12 months ago. She went to baby groups from 6 weeks and I would never have claimed our house was particularly clean. What I have always found frustrating is we have never been asked any environmental questions about our daughters early years. There are many theories of cause so I would have expected them to get as much information as possible from us.
- foxylad 9y agoNow we have the capacity to capture enormous amounts of data about our everyday lives, I'm amazed that as a society we haven't started doing wide-ranging pattern recognition to attempt to find environmental triggers for common ailments. Google and Facebook could redeem themselves by putting some resources into looking for statistical patterns in their massive datasets. Finding the smoking gun for Parkinsons or prostate cancer would go a long way to making their data-collection more socially acceptable.
- gautamdivgi 9y agoOur daughter was diagnosed with ALL a month ago. Again, as you said this seems to be a theory under discussion and not a general medical consensus. What I've found in my limited exposure to the medical system so far is that their singular focus is on the treatment and they rarely if ever look back for data that could be correlated to a cause. She's our second child and had her first cold at a few weeks old. Our house has never been particularly tidy and my older daughter kept bringing in the cough, cold and fever from pre-school. Interestingly, she had never been a rather sickly child or one that lacked stamina and has weathered most of the cold and fevers brought home by the elder child surprisingly well. Then she got her flu shot a couple of months ago that resulted in a fairly raging reaction (which the doctors dismissed that the flu shot can't do), which led to appendicitis (unusual for a 3 yr old) which led to the eventual diagnosis of ALL.
- nickswan 9y agoReally sorry for the diagnosis your daughter has had. Our girls were about the same age at diagnosis. If you have any questions or want to chat anytime feel free to contact me. L
- tssva 9y agoMy ex-wife is a survivor of childhood ALL and her early childhood was the antithesis of that described by the study. She was the 4th of 4 kids each having been born about 18 months apart. So she was exposed to the germs of 3 young siblings. Her parents were also very socially active, so she was also frequently exposed to the germs of the young children of those in her parents social circles. Please take this study with a grain of salt and don't beat yourself up based upon it.
- acjohnson55 9y agoI'm so, so sorry for your loss. You can't have known. And even now, the scientists probably don't fully know the situation.