2 ms·
You're reversing. Originalists says "this law's authors didn't anticipate modern conditions, so the law must not change under modern conditions" Non-originalis
by gowld 8y ago
You're reversing. Originalists says "this law's authors didn't anticipate modern conditions, so the law must not change under modern conditions"
Non-originalists say "this law's authors didn't anticipate modern conditions, so we must project their intent onto modern conditions"
- Bartweiss 8y agoI'm not reversing - I agree with you. In this case, I think an original intent reading and a living Constitution reading lead to the same place. But I only mention that because the decision references intent; original intent scholarship is rare in general and basically absent on the court. Original meaning is what's currently represented on the court, and is as you say: "the law must not change under modern conditions". That's what I'm suggesting was abandoned by its usual practitioners today.