7 ms·
This isn't disappointing at all as it reflects the state of the laws as they're currently on the books. Desiring or determining a court ruling based upon what y
by koolba 8y ago
This isn't disappointing at all as it reflects the state of the laws as they're currently on the books. Desiring or determining a court ruling based upon what you'd like the law to be rather than how it's currently written opens the door for legislation from the bench.
If workers want the law changed to ban arbitration clauses then they should ask their representatives to pass legislation to do exactly that. And if said representatives won't do so then they should elect someone else next election cycle who will.
- giobox 8y agoGiven the US is a common law system, whats "on the books" and "how it's currently written" is only part of the story - precedent established in prior cases is another large deciding factor in what the law "is", and judges have a fair degree of latitude to adapt interpretation in this regard. Interpretation is not static either. > opens the door for legislation from the bench In common law systems, indirectly this is what happens and has done for centuries. Through interpretation of statute and binding precedent, the bench does get to help define, albeit in far more limited fashion than the legislature, what "the law" is in a common law system. This is one reason why lawyers have to examine both the statute _and_ the case law. Disappointing is the right word.
- latortuga 8y agoOkay sure. But don't lose track of reality in your quest for idealism though. There is a vast power imbalance between worker and corporation, both money and power. Businesses control the contracts, they have far more money, and, as a result, they have vastly more powerful lobbying. So in practice, there is no defense for workers anywhere! Kicking the can to "elect someone else" is just as naive as claiming that this decision respects the law on the books.
- gowld 8y agoYour concern is valid, and is the domain of anti-trust law.
- bhups 8y ago> Kicking the can to "elect someone else" is just as naive as claiming that this decision respects the law on the books. But...it does respect the law on the books. Your concern seems to be that the law is bad, and that the judiciary ought to change that law. I don't think there's a lot of disagreement about the former, it's the latter that's more controversial. From an idealistic standpoint, enacting Federal law is necessarily onerous, owing to the requirement of a strong consensus so as to prevent a marginal majority from shoving Federal laws down the throat of a large minority. > Okay sure. But don't lose track of reality in your quest for idealism though. Okay sure, it sounds like you don't care much for the idealistic standpoint, so let's talk pragmatism. If we can't gather this consensus at the Federal level, we have the levers of state legislatures to pass those same laws at a more local level. Liberal states have the political will, the systems, and (if we're being frank) the majority of businesses that would be affected by Federal law anyway. They just need to have the will and pragmatism to compromise and pass their desired law at the state level until such a time that there's Federal consensus for that law.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"But...it does respect the law on the books." No, it absolutely does not. It completely makes up a reason why this should be considered any different than any other instance where things have changed since a law was enacted.
- bhups 8y ago> No, it absolutely does not. Can you explain what the law on the books currently is, and how the majority opinion "absolutely does not" respect it? > It completely makes up a reason why this should be considered any different than any other instance where things have changed since a law was enacted. Things have changed since a law was enacted by legislative fiat. The thesis behind those arguing the intended function of the judiciary is that any instance in the past where the judiciary has actually changed a law since it was enacted is considered abuse and not to be repeated.
- kup0 8y agoCan't it be argued that SCOTUS's positions: 1. FAA is less broad than NRLA 2. NRLA does not override anything in FAA due to it being overbroad and/or things in the FAA not being "common policy" are false, and thus the law on the books is not being respected? #1 appears to be false and #2 is based on their erroneous position in #1. NRLA is more targeted than FAA and came 10 years post-FAA, so the argument that things covered in the FAA were not "common policy" at the time NRLA became law and thus wouldn't be overridden by NRLA seem ridiculous to me
- cookiecaper 8y agoWe have a system that operates at the pace of 1776. That served us well for a long time, but since the post-war proliferation of mass media, it's hard to argue that it's adequate anymore. You're right that people don't understand the way the separation of powers works, but the system badly needs to be revised. The world has totally transformed in the last 75 years and it's much smaller now. Political and legal feedback loops need to become much more responsive. One can see how it all worked when it would take weeks or months to get news of things like national election results, and when most people lived mostly self-sufficient agrarian lifestyles, but we don't live in that world anymore. Our entire political system, including the functional ability for normal private individuals to seek and obtain useful legal relief, has ground to a halt over the last several decades. Technology has made the old methods increasingly bad fits for the modern era. It'd be great if we could renovate the system before we fully convince the populace that the elements of good governance, like separation of powers and an independent judiciary, are necessarily linked to stunning and clear deprivations of fairness (of which binding arbitration is just one good example).
- gowld 8y agoWe must occasionally remind ourselves that the Supreme Court ruled to uphold slavery, so injustice under law is not a recent phenomenon.
- bhups 8y ago> We have a system that operates at the pace of 1776. That served us well for a long time, but since the post-war proliferation of mass media, it's hard to argue that it's adequate anymore. I'd argue the exact opposite. The pace of our system is just a reflection of the current ideological polarization. Enacting Federal law requires a strong consensus (to prevent abuse), and the more polarized we are, the more difficult it becomes to shove Federal laws down the throat of a narrow minority. If we can't gather this consensus at the Federal level, we have the levers of state legislatures to pass those same laws at a more local level. Liberal states have the political will, the systems, and (if we're being frank) the majority of businesses that would be affected by Federal law anyway. They just need to have the will to compromise and pass their desired law at the state level until such a time that there's Federal consensus for that law.
- magicalist 8y agoIn addition to giobox's points, > This isn't disappointing at all as it reflects the state of the laws as they're currently on the books. 4 out of 9 supreme court justices disagree with the ruling, so this really isn't the narrative to go with.
- s2g 8y agoKind of sad that if it's fucking people over in favor of corportations, you can always guess the 4.