3 ms·
Sorry for the comment size! I use HN from a PC always and I tend to forget that's probably not the most common use. You're right, I'm not talking about common
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Sorry for the comment size! I use HN from a PC always and I tend to forget that's probably not the most common use.
You're right, I'm not talking about common sense. It was another commenter who mentioned it. I interjected that it's very hard to collect enough examples of "What cats do? How cats respond to things? How they interact physically with their environment?" to build a good model of cat behaviour.
I'll be honest and say I have no idea what is "common sense" in the context of cat behaviour. Not to mention that it's very difficult to agree on a definition of "common sense". Despite that, I think you'll find there's general agreement that machine learning models don't have anything that could be recognised as "common sense". One reason for that is that it's extremely difficult to collect training examples of "common sense", exactly because it's so very hard to define it.
Apologies if that was too much of a sidetrack from what you wanted to discuss!
I actually don't have a definition of intelligence :) I'm working off an assumption that there is such a thing, that it's one process or one set of processes and that we may be able to reproduce it on computers, at some point in the future. But not in my life time.
The great advantage of doing a PhD is that you have plenty of time to read up and experiment to your heart's content. I hope it all goes well for you and you can soon start your studies.
I'm sorry to hear about yoru parent. You both have my sympathy. Hang in there.
- ben_w 9y agoThanks! I think we’re basically in agreement then, as all of my responses were predicted on the incorrect belief that you were using common sense as an argument against AI. I certainly agree that humans can accurately extrapolate — for example what a cat is likely to do next — with what seems like less data than any current machine learning system. I suspect have my suspicions why, but to keep this short I’ll only say “catastrophic forgetting”, and separately that the normal approach in ML seems to be like teaching kids “by asking them random questions from the set of things we expect them to know at 18”, to almost-quote one of the podcasts I listen to.