4 ms·
There is no "50% tax bracket". Obama's proposed plan would raise the 33% and 35% brackets to 36% and 39.6%.
by guelo 16y ago
There is no "50% tax bracket". Obama's proposed plan would raise the 33% and 35% brackets to 36% and 39.6%.
- jasonkester 16y agoThanks for that. This was actually the first I'd heard of this tax hike, since the little bit of news I get generally comes filtered through HN. I've modified the number in my comment for you.
- rdl 16y agoThere is if you count state and local taxes. In California you can be paying 9.3% + 1.0%, and in other places (NYC) it can be even higher. At 39.6 + 9.3 + 1.0, you would be above most countries in the world.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThat's funny, because on my federal tax return there's an entry where you deduct your state income tax. Sales tax, of course, is entirely different from income tax. http://www.irs.gov/publications/p17/ch22.html#en_US_publink1000173147 http://www.irs.gov/publications/p17/ch22.html#en_US_publink1...
- rdl 16y agoSomething being deductible on federal is nowhere near the same as a tax credit. You don't get a tax credit for state/local taxes. You get a deduction (which doesn't apply under AMT). So, if you're in the 25% bracket, you can deduct your 10% state taxes, which reduces it from 25+10% to 25+10-(0.25*10). California's 9.3% is the top regular marginal income tax rate. There is also an 8-10% state/local sales tax. There is no way around the analysis that California and New York are relatively high tax states compared to Nevada and Washington.
- anigbrowl 16y agoI know this, and am not trying to claim that high taxes don't exist - I live in California myself, and think we need to trim costs to become more competitive. But I see no value in exaggerating the impact of taxes either. Call me a pedant if you like, but I'm just tired of seeing economic debates where people begin with best/worst case arguments, eg throwing out numbers which don't take inflation into account or suchlike. I felt the message I replied could have acknowledged that one number does not tell the whole story.
- bhickey 16y agoSure, but you're leaving out FICA (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%). This bumps the brackets to 40.65% and 42.65% (or 43.65% and 47.25%). After local taxes this can easily top 50%. Suppose you earned $357k gross in Rhode Island. Your total tax liability would be in the area of $189k, or 52.7%. All of this also ignores the employer FICA contribution.
- rdl 16y agoFICA phases out around $100k, but there's also the future ObamaCare 3.8% tax (unearned income) 0.9% (earned income) as well (currently legislated to begin 1 JAN 2013).
- bhickey 16y agoI took this into account in my calculation. While, Social Security payments are capped at $102k (~$6k tax liability), Medicare is uncapped.
- rdl 16y agoThe amusing thing for me is that there are certain incomes where the marginal rate actually goes down when income goes up (although absolute taxes paid always go up), due to phase-outs of deductions, various regressive taxes like FICA, local, etc.. It's actually quite complicated -- someone did a table on Quora, which I can't readily find right now, and it looks like the marginal rate peak for a single person was usually around 180-220k. From a purely efficiency standpoint, it seems like one would want the marginal rate function to be as smooth and ideally monotonic (if not strictly monotonic) as possible.
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoCan you break down your calculation a little? It's way higher than what I got...wondering if you forgot that these are marginal tax rates?
- bhickey 16y ago