4 ms·
The question is if whether or not saving ten minutes is worth the amount it would cost the company to do the required upgrades. The answer is, at least right no
by bobthepanda 9y ago
The question is if whether or not saving ten minutes is worth the amount it would cost the company to do the required upgrades. The answer is, at least right now, not yet.
- masklinn 9y agoIt's a brand new regional train yet barely reaches the speed of your average euro commuter train from the 60s (not joking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_Class_Z_5300 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_Class_Z_5300 has a top speed of 81mph).
- bobthepanda 9y agoWe are also talking about rail service where none previously existed, in a sprawled out, auto-dependent metropolitan area. High speed rail was not built in a day. It's also worth noting that all rail has to be at this point is faster than its competition, which it is. Cars are slower and this is far too short of a distance for airplanes.
- projektfu 9y agohttp://www.tri-rail.com http://www.tri-rail.com The area has had commuter rail for over 20 years. This express service is using previously freight-only lines. What's really going to be impressive is when it connects Orlando.
- masklinn 9y agoThe 3h they're predicting for Miami - Orlando seems less than impressive. Especially as the Orlando station is at the airport.
- hamandcheese 9y agoEspecially considering you can fly Orlando to Miami, possibly in less total time. Granted, flying is not a cost effective means to commute, but I don’t think rail service from Orlando to Miami will have too many true commuters on board compared to less frequent travelers.
- ghaff 9y agoYou're basically talking the equivalent of Boston to New York City although you don't have the same potential for downtown to downtown travel. That's definitely not a daily commute sort of thing. I don't know enough about Florida travel patterns to know how much sense that city pair makes.
- hamandcheese 9y agoPersonally I’d rather see Orlando to Tampa, but it definitely felt like 80% of the people I went to college with in Orlando were from south Florida.
- masklinn 9y agoIf you have the market for an HSR (a real one) it's feasible, thought not great and you'd really need better downtown public transport. Assuming direct it'd be a ~1:45 trip, possibly 1:30 on the really modern 350km/h (~220mph) lines, and if you don't have trouble falling asleep you can usually sleep/nap, you can work, and you could have a meal service. Not cheap though, HSR tickets are not $10 (though it's not that far if you're using a high-frequency subscription thing, especially if you're using it daily).
- bobthepanda 9y agoWest Palm Beach to Miami is equivalent to Trenton to New York, which is not great but also not wildly unrealistic.
- bobthepanda 9y agoBoth airports are traffic prone and you have to account the time of getting there and passing through American security theater.
- saosebastiao 9y agoThe top speed here is regulatory. There is a 79mph speed limit on tracks shared with freight trains. Also we have weight minimums. Basically most of the reason our trains suck is because our regulatory body sucks.