3 ms·
Apple discovered fairly early on that while using a keyboard shortcut seems faster, using the mouse is almost always quicker, even for very advanced users. The
by jdietrich 16y ago
Apple discovered fairly early on that while using a keyboard shortcut seems faster, using the mouse is almost always quicker, even for very advanced users. The illusion stems from how we perceive time when performing the different tasks - we remember time spent searching for the correct target to click, but we forget time spent remembering the right incantation.
This paradox is one of the big reasons why I don't use Vi or EMACS - I think that the productivity gains are nowhere near as great as users make out, but the sense of mastery over such arcane tools is inherently satisfying to the kind of person that spends a lot of time in a text editor.
http://www.asktog.com/TOI/toi06KeyboardVMouse1.html http://www.asktog.com/TOI/toi06KeyboardVMouse1.html
- astrofinch 16y agoAfter reading that long ago, I timed myself doing keyword searches on a webpage using both cntrl-f and accessing search from the menu. cntrl-f was significantly faster.
- dasil003 16y agoThat's certainly interesting research, but it's far from conclusive. There are all manner of variables such as the accuracy of the mouse actions required, the number of keystrokes required, the familiarity of the user with the commands, and even the quality of the mouse. The tests that Apple conducted were based on simple tasks available on the Macintosh computers of the time. However, text editing is a complex task with a lot of room for optimization. There is no doubt that more keypresses can be achieved per second than mouse actions, and that if asked to repetitively perform a task that could be accomplished by means of 10 vim key strokes or some combination of 5 text selections and menu choices, the max speed of the vim'er would top out higher than the mouser. However true it is that the keyboarder forgets the time spent recalling arcane commands, it's also true that experienced vim'ers can issues multiple commands per second, some of which will do things that would not reasonably contained in a convenient location in a menu and/or icon-based interface. The powerful grammar and compositional nature of vi commands alluded to in this article, combined with the patterns that emerge in working with specific programming languages lead to opportunities to develop extremely efficient editing skills that blow a mouse-based workflow out of the water. It's not just my own experience, it's watching other people do things in vi or emacs that I guarantee are impossible with a mouse. You may well be right that the improved productivity of vi/emacs is exaggerated by its practitioners, but I don't think there's really a case to be made that advanced keyboard editing is a waste of time.
- sb 16y agoAnother thing that comes to mind is that using current devices (such as two 22" displays, i.e., a much higher resolution like 3360x1050), the time to do anything meaningful with a pointing-device increases, too. I, for instance, switched to a big trackball device because all this mouse lifting and re-centering became annoying. As for the simple tasks: Something like Emacs macros enable effective processing of raw text input data--something that would take a lot longer if it had to be done manually, if possible at all.
- tlack 16y agoI agree that this is true in some cases but I can give you a counter example that really showed me how convenient vim is: ciw. 'ciw' erases the word under the cursor and allows you to retype it. This process is very, very slow using the mouse: even if double or triple click tends to correctly highlight the word you want to replace, positioning your mouse there is pretty slow.